Because of MUDS. If you read the Rules thread, in the part that deals with priority and signups, the fifth bullet point is why you're P2.
"Being dead or having subbed out from another game will still count towards your tally until the game in question ends. Exceptions from this are deaths in the first cycle of a game with working kills or a working lynch (usually Day 1 or Night 1), as those are unavoidable."
So even though you subbed out of MUDS, for whatever reason, it still counts against your priority.