MMF
Give me the strength to part this sea
I'll go ahead and respond to this since no one else has.Just going to share my two cents here.
- Probopass for A tier. He has all the moves and STATS he needs to succeed. Sure, he has some awful weaknesses but his utility and diversity alone make him a possible A tier. He can set up Stealth Rocks, lead with Sturdy, be a decent offensive threat with Sp.Atk investment while also being stupidly bulky, provide momentum with Volt Switch etc etc etc
- Emolga for C tier. He's a pretty good scout with access to U-Turn and Volt Switch, can hit decently hard (especially after boosts), can paralyze, and be a general pain in the ass. His immunities to both Ground and Electric are rather handy too. It's fraility and lack of power stop it from rising higher, in my opinion, but he's certainly much better than E tier.
- Illumise for D tier. She's essentially a weaker Volbeat, and I wouldn't use her over her male counterpart, but she's still a good supporter.
- Mothim for D tier. The Gen 4 Quiver Dancer hits pretty hard but is too slow and frail to be as high as the likes of Butterfree and Masquerain.
1. Probopass: I think Probopass is right where he needs to be in the B tier. And here's why: (Reserved for Pokemon that are outstanding in the NU metagame and can sweep, wall, or support the majority of the tier. These Pokemon require less support than other Pokemon to be used effectively and have few flaws that can be overlooked when compared to their outstanding trait). This to me does not describe Probopass at all. He does not wall the majority of the tier and does not have the capability to sweep at the drop of a hat. Probopass is still a good pokemon but he has a few noticeable flaws. And thats what the B tier is for.
2. Emolga: To be honest, Emolga shouldn't go anywhere either. Its a less than mediocre Pokemon that really doesn't do anything that something like Rotom-S or Rotom-F doesn't already do. Its weak and needs Charge Beam boosts to do anything. Its fine right where it is. You can try and make a case for it but I don't think this spot will change.
3. Illumise: She's basically the exact same as Volbeat. So she should stay in the exact same tier as Volbeat. There isn't really any difference between the two.
4. Mothim: Ok so yeah move this up to at least D
Edit: Oh lol they aren't in the same tier. Well they almost should be then since they're the exact same bar Tail Glow. Why the hell was Mothim not in a tier? Its nearly the exact same as Butterfree and Masquerain except for abilities.