Braviary-
When I originally posted about Braviary I gave its SubBulk Up set a little too much credit and closed my mind as to how it was against other playing styles such as Offense and Stall. Against Offense Braviary doesn't have nearly as much of an open window to do what it wants to freely as powerhouses such as Zangoose, Emboar, Samurott, and even opposing Braviary are always around the corner ready to blast it before it can really get to doing anything. Against Stall Braviary can get the upperhand against most of the Pokemon found in the archetype, however these teams should have ways to stop this such as Psych Up Regirock, Psych Up Metang, Toxic + Power Gem Probopass, and Roar Bastiodon. My main beef with this is that they have to force themselves to use silly moves such as Psych Up to beat Braviary, but I guess this can just be looked at as the essence of metagaming; adapting to beat threats. Against Balance is possibly where SubBU Braviary's best match-up lies; it can use its excellent bulk to set up on the less offensive threats that Balance brings and rain chaos and destruction if played correctly. SubBU Braviary forces Balance teams to play more offensively if they want to prevent it from setting up and shredding through. Even so there are a lot of threats in NU that do this such as Ludicolo, who puts pressure on teams to prevent it from setting up a Rain Dance, or Zangoose, who forces a team to outpredict it and then hit back with priority or a faster threat. Overall Braviary's individual sets each have their strong points and their weak points, but when put together is where I think the main problem arises, and the real reason why it was placed as a suspect.
For example switching Alomomola into a Braviary expecting to tank one of its Scarf or Choice Band attacks, when it then reveals Substitute and you wind up in an awful situation that you will likely not be able to get out of. At the same time, all of this could have been avoided if the player did didn't make assumptions and decided to test the waters beforehand. Samurott shares this trait with Braviary in that if its set is mispredicted it can lead to a possible sweep such as in the situation of switching in Regice expecting a special set and ending up at the wrong side of a SD Samurott sweep. I think that main reason why I initially wanted to ban Braviary was because I didn't take into account that SubBU is as of now a prominent set and that people are expecting it more and will be less careless. SubBU will easily destroy anyone who is careless, however the same applies for a lot of other Pokemon. If you were you to only think of Braviary in the situations where the opponent doesn't even know of SubBU's existence, Braviary will win ever single time. I think now that the tier has gotten a taste of Braviary's new set it has the ability to adapt to it the way it should and already has. (Example being the use of Psych Up)
I already have my position on Braviary's Scarf and Band sets
here, but I would like reiterate it quickly. Both sets are excellent and put a lot of pressure on offensive teams who will generally lack switches into Braviary or Pokemon to outspeed it. However both sets share a flaw in that they lack recovery, have a Stealth Rock weakness, and are usually seen taking recoil from Brave Bird. This will usually limit the Choice sets to 5 shots at damaging the enemy at most, however this will usually be less as the recoil from Brave Bird racks up quickly. The Choice Scarf set packs great speed however it misses out on a lot of power in exchange which makes it easier to check or tank its attacks. The Choice Band set is very powerful however since it only has base 80 Speed its not hard to check or revenge kill it. Not to mention that like any Choice user it is placed into a guessing game on what move it should lock itself into. With every team using a Rock-type or other Flying-type resists this pressure is placed on Braviary in every match. This compounded with its Stealth Rock weakness in my opinion make the Choice sets very manageable. This is not to say that Braviary is a bad Pokemon, in fact I think that it is the best Pokemon in NU at the moment, but I feel that as of now it is not an unstoppable force.
Do Not Ban