but HG/SS haz better graffics.
Story's WAY better in Pt than the Johto games, but the Johto games, in both Gen II and IV, were and are revolutionary compared to their previous gen. Johto introduced color to the Pokemon games, had a thousand little quirks you could play around with (probably the greatest part), and sheer awesome new Pokemon. HG/SS is the same thing with OVER 9000x better graphics, an improved Kanto region, preserved Crystal enhancements, and more pokemon.
However, in retrospect...Gen IV is better than Gen II. But since your argument is against G/S being better than Pt, I'll give you that. Keep in mind I haven't played any regions other than Sinnoh and some short flights to Kanto and Hoenn through borrowed games.
Great job.
However...
Fight some gyms, fight another Rocket rip, climb a mountain, go Distortion world and fight the world's most uncatchable version mascot, be champion like the last 11-12 games, catch Heatran. The end.
equally describes Platinum. That is essentially what you're saying, minus prose and plus Heatran.
My opinion of this: Good job, but easy to lampoon with the above statement.
-Torterra-Infernape-Feraligatr-