Maverick, this is not proportional, check it!
Defense, Dusclops, Base: 130
Defense, Dusclops-PES, Base: 195
195 in Total Stat.: 489
Defense, Dusclops, Total: 359
Defense, Dusclops-PES, Total: 538
538 in Base Stat: 219
So, you are both wrong.
In fact, all your calculations are...