Recent content by pokémaniac 212

I think the game was fairly close until the OD/Quagsires incident. After that, the mafia had a massive advantage. Anyway, thanks to walrein for hosting a good game, it was a new experience playing NOC, and I'll happily admit I wasn't the best at it, although its a miracle I survived so long.

I don't know how common a role it is here, but on other sites I've visited mafia quite often has a janitor which prevents role from being revealed, so thats my best guess.

Quick reads list, since someone (ginga I think) asked, I'll re-read the last few days and give something more detailed this afternoon when I'm less busy. EP: Someone I need to re-read really, seemed suspicious at first, but his defence seemed village to me, so I'm struggling to get an overall...

Yeah, I was mainly advising him to read up in case he has any useful thoughts.

I accept my last post was badly written, and I certainly didn't mean to say that it was funny flamestrike was dead, but my point that kaxtar has come out and said that 2 of the 3 most suspected people, and not just by me, are clear seems strange still stands. I'd recomment reading the whole...

That was a bizzare tactic by OD, I look forward to seeing the discussion thread. Anyway, @kaxtar, I find it amusing that of your 3 clears, 1 died and the other 2 are among the most suspected players here, whats your reasoning?

@ Jalmont, I can't point to any examples of AG leading a mislynch, and town hooker is a more believable role than One-shot insane question asker, but AG was scummy for reasons other than that. I believe I covered everything else in your post already. On the point of OD, I still find it strange...

The mafia aren't stupid, they'd know that chances are leading a mislynch against a vanilla would get the person who did it killed, especially in the way it happened. How would it not be stupid for mafia to sacrifice probably their most trusted member for a simple vanillager.

Yeah, I presume this sub is for pernicious. Anyway, as to yesterday, I'm inclined to trust OD on this. Yes he got it wrong, but for mafia to sacrifice one of their own to kill a vanilla makes no sense to me. If he was doctor then I could maybe see it, but even then the mafia would night kill...

My logic is that AG was incredibly scummy, and therefore I'm essentially lynching him, hardly bizzare logic. Also, OMGUS much? I've already given my opinion on Pernicious, and Quagsires, while looking scummy, wasn't as scummy looking as AG. Having said that, since we have a claim of...

I said that you are playing like a town, but that your predecessor in the role was so unbelievably scummy throughout that for the time being, that outweighs it to such an extent that for the time being you are the best person to lynch in my opinion.

I've read through EP's posts this phase, and to be fair to him his defence does make sense, and he raises some very valid points about AG, the one about him being hooked by a mafia hooker etc I hadn't personally considered. Therefore, while some suspicions of him remain to me, he's no longer top...

@mithril, jalmont had asked my opinion on empoof, and since I was writing down brief opinions on his posts to help formulate one, I thought I may as well post the lot. Also, while Jalmont I agree is playing like a town, at the moment it doesn't override how scummy Aura Guardian was, although...

@khz, I was primarily referring to AG, who only posted when attacked, and went completely silent after the suspicion lifted, although this has been raised since that post. Also, NWO was pretty quiet on the day in question. On Empoof, his first post obviously caused suspicion, although I...

@jalmont On Flamestrike, see this post:http://www.smogon.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3974916&postcount=528, which gives my thoughts on flamestrike. As for Empoof, I don't have any immediate thoughts, and its too late now for me to do a full read through of his posts (I'm in the UK so its past...