Yawn. Good morning folks!
Flounder no longer! Last night, I discovered a prime lynch target, and I believe we should Lynch THE_IRON_KENYAN. Here's why!
Now, notice that he claimed to know of all the other Rohirrim. This directly goes against the idea of the game, that the village is an uninformed majority!
Taking the game OP too literally. Weaksauce argument
Furthermore, in a later conversation, I tried to verify the veracity of his claims - whihc is to say, I put some names to him. Some were Rohirrim, some weren't. He said they were all false.
Naturally, my alarm bells blazed. Now, I'll tell you what I think TIK is right now. Note that, where possible, it could be a combination.
What about this option: I only know some of the other rohirrim, and it turns out there are more of them or this other option:
- High
- Confused
- A neutral who has knowledge of all the Rohirrim and moles them to high heaven
- A Sauronite who has knowledge of all the Rohirrim and moles them to high heaven
You are lying and there are no other rohirrim besides the rohirrim I know
I rest my case. Bandwagon away!
Im gonna guess because every villager or most in this game is most likely part of a mason group. Which I think is the only way to justify making a 43 man NOC day game, make many into one by making them part of a group. Its just really obvious at this pointDouble posting because I forgot something:
If the Rohirrim really are masons, why didn't any of them step up to lead? Mason is basically the best role for leading.
I wouldnt do this, wed just end up with a risk of 2 rohirrim deadCan another member of the Rohirrim please state whether they know all the other members. This is important to either save TIK or condemn him.
Not as easy as youd think. Youd have to find out a way to organize the rohirrim vig votes without potentially revealing them in the process, and even then you might end up with a situation where you tried to kill someone with the rohirrim votes and then failed, narrowing down the people it could be without even doing what you wanted. The role is definitely deceptive, there are problems with using it and disadvantages. Definitely not as good as youd thing, and definitely understandable why there could be other rohirrim I dont know about. Either that or Ullar is lying about saying he knows other rohirrim, or getting lied to by people saying they are rohirrim but arentLynch THE_IRON_KENYAN
no way the riders of rohirrim all know each other, it would be ridiculously easy for them to guarantee a vig every other lynch
I dont get this. If we had more of them around, wed have more safety because it means that one could be picked off and wouldnt be as damaging if there were one less and another were picked off.Out of all the villagers in the game, I'd want the rohirrim to have their members depleted (but not completely rid of) first. They need all members to vote for a specific person in order to kill them, and with less numbers that becomes easier.
I doubt there are vanillas in this game due to the relatively simple roles of the rohirrim and soldiers, that act as the vanilla roles in mafia (but still have a purpose!)
Another rohirrim claiming would save your skin if you are, indeed, villager TIK, so your reluctance makes me more suspicious of you!