Shuckle: Ban
Reason: I personally like shuckle and wouldn't want it to be banned. But since the ban is going to be reverted, if found that shuckle is not the reason behind the (sticky web strategy) centralization of the Meta; then in that case its better to corner out the issue by banning shuckle for a while. Though if found that without shuckle the sticky web strategy is not as dominant, I would rather see shuckle move up so that the meta is more balanced.
p.s: my first suspect vote ;)