Deadline
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
Big Lord of the Rings Mafia - Game Over! Forces of Sauron Win!
- Thread starter UncleSam
- Start date
For once, it appears as though the night brought cause for the Fellowship to celebrate.
A very odd siamese twin orc was found strangled to death. Yeti/jumpluff lay motionless in the fields.
Results going out, don't post in the meantime.
A very odd siamese twin orc was found strangled to death. Yeti/jumpluff lay motionless in the fields.
VonFiedler was found cut down by a Morghul Blade. While preliminary glances had you mourning the passing of another pair of good Hobbits, a closer look showed he had played trickses on you all.
Boom headshot.
Results going out, don't post in the meantime.
Two players in one; die right away. Mega-lame.
Andy Snype
Mr. Music
damn this was hella nice for us
I have a lynch target.
As Faramir, I can check on the gordoriness of players. billymills claimed soldier of gondor, he is not a soldier of gondor.
Lynch billymills
As Faramir, I can check on the gordoriness of players. billymills claimed soldier of gondor, he is not a soldier of gondor.
Lynch billymills
Let's make this a quick lynch and get out of the ass that is NOC. I want it to be night again.
You guys are good at reading.
Blue_Tornado has been silenced and cannot post.
It is NOW Day 3. Any votes placed before now are irrelevant. Deadline is at 10 PM EDT on Thursday, July 17th.
Blue_Tornado has been silenced and cannot post.
It is NOW Day 3. Any votes placed before now are irrelevant. Deadline is at 10 PM EDT on Thursday, July 17th.
Last edited:
SORRY DLE, I SUCK DICKS.
AND I GUESS SINCE MY OLD VOTE IS NILL, Lynch billymills
Reinfleche has been subbed in for Rextreff.
I expected as much, my play this game was poor. Go Gollum!
ariariadne
formerly Reinfleche
Hey everyone, I've been keeping up but I want to look over the thread some more and such before getting a vote down. I'll probably be all caught up by tomorrow.
Andy Snype
Mr. Music
I have questions about LN's claim before I believe this.
If LN is Faramir, a Gondor checker, I question LightWolf's role's existence, which according to here: http://www.smogon.com/forums/threads/lord-of-the-rings-mafia-night-2.3511055/page-13#post-5579841 , is a generic Middle-Earth alliance check.
I would also like to know how LN knows billymills claims Soldier of Gondor.
If LN is Faramir, a Gondor checker, I question LightWolf's role's existence, which according to here: http://www.smogon.com/forums/threads/lord-of-the-rings-mafia-night-2.3511055/page-13#post-5579841 , is a generic Middle-Earth alliance check.
I would also like to know how LN knows billymills claims Soldier of Gondor.
Andy Snype
Mr. Music
Also DLE it is Day 3, not N2 like it says in the title or even Day 2 like it says in your post. Silly boy.
I'm only a Soldier of Gondor in lore, sorry bro.
I also told Lightwolf that everyone should claim Soldier of Gondor, regardless of actual role.
I also told Lightwolf that everyone should claim Soldier of Gondor, regardless of actual role.
Wow. Two anti-Middle Earth dead... by night. That's... weird. Well, before a little logic, anyway. Though I find it odd that people are complaining about the LN/LW roles when there's already the Gimli/Elf-guy role pairing. Really, why the skepticism?
And what the heck does billy mean by that post he made as I typed this up? And saying everyone should claim Gondor... that only makes sense in the event someone can't be trusted, but why claim at all, then? And only soldier in lore? Really, that sort of stuff... oy.
(Short break from being serious, because I'm tired and need a little break from it.)
Oh, and while I'm complaining about irrationalities and stuff making no sense, let's provide some nonsense to go with it:
The dawn cow barks at the lonely sponge on a midsummer's eve.
(Ok, done)
Back to being serious, and NOT complaining about stuff not making sense:
Lynch billymills for now. Enough evidence has been presented for a pressure vote, I feel. Either fake claim, which should be discouraged; fake claim by mafia, which should be lynched; fake claim by LN, which will be ousted soon enough to not lynch billy if LN's lying. All situations have a win.
And what the heck does billy mean by that post he made as I typed this up? And saying everyone should claim Gondor... that only makes sense in the event someone can't be trusted, but why claim at all, then? And only soldier in lore? Really, that sort of stuff... oy.
(Short break from being serious, because I'm tired and need a little break from it.)
Oh, and while I'm complaining about irrationalities and stuff making no sense, let's provide some nonsense to go with it:
The dawn cow barks at the lonely sponge on a midsummer's eve.
(Ok, done)
Back to being serious, and NOT complaining about stuff not making sense:
Lynch billymills for now. Enough evidence has been presented for a pressure vote, I feel. Either fake claim, which should be discouraged; fake claim by mafia, which should be lynched; fake claim by LN, which will be ousted soon enough to not lynch billy if LN's lying. All situations have a win.
Don't try and weasel out of it lol, you literally claimed vanilla soldier... there's no way to interpret that any other way.
I'm boromir. I had no intention of claiming it until I saw fit to use my role. I am not remotely denying what I told Lightwolf.
[01:28:42] <LightWolf> either claim up or clam up
[01:28:50] <billymills> ok
[01:28:55] <billymills> im soldier of gondor
[01:29:05] <LightWolf> show me your PM as proof
[01:29:06] <billymills> i honestly expect
[01:29:11] <billymills> 60% of the game
[01:29:13] <billymills> to say this
[01:29:15] <LightWolf> I accept linking the OP of the game
[01:29:23] <LightWolf> silly billy
[01:29:32] <LightWolf> 30%
[01:31:31] <LightWolf> I wonder if the game assumes
[01:31:55] <LightWolf> one to expect all possible inspect cheating roles to be soldier fakes
[01:32:09] <LightWolf> which'd reward wild claiming of actual roles
[01:32:17] <billymills> thats not the point
[01:32:26] <billymills> the point is not to claim a power role
[01:32:34] <billymills> to tie to your name
[01:32:34] <LightWolf> sush I'm having an internal debate in ths query
[01:32:40] <billymills> i
[01:32:42] <billymills> understand
[01:32:46] <billymills> it beats querying yourself
[01:28:42] <LightWolf> either claim up or clam up
[01:28:50] <billymills> ok
[01:28:55] <billymills> im soldier of gondor
[01:29:05] <LightWolf> show me your PM as proof
[01:29:06] <billymills> i honestly expect
[01:29:11] <billymills> 60% of the game
[01:29:13] <billymills> to say this
[01:29:15] <LightWolf> I accept linking the OP of the game
[01:29:23] <LightWolf> silly billy
[01:29:32] <LightWolf> 30%
[01:31:31] <LightWolf> I wonder if the game assumes
[01:31:55] <LightWolf> one to expect all possible inspect cheating roles to be soldier fakes
[01:32:09] <LightWolf> which'd reward wild claiming of actual roles
[01:32:17] <billymills> thats not the point
[01:32:26] <billymills> the point is not to claim a power role
[01:32:34] <billymills> to tie to your name
[01:32:34] <LightWolf> sush I'm having an internal debate in ths query
[01:32:40] <billymills> i
[01:32:42] <billymills> understand
[01:32:46] <billymills> it beats querying yourself
I'm kind of dubious about that claim, given that you're kind of my brother, and therefore you would be seen as a gondor.
Andy Snype
Mr. Music
"Gimli/Elf-guy" is about flavour. My skepticism is about the actual roles here, the stuff that we can get results off of rather than relatively meaningless details. If we have a Soldier-of-Gondor checker, why do we also have someone that can tell a village-allied checker? This is what I'm skeptical of. Why have a sheriff AND a gimped sheriff? If LN is actually a Soldier-of-Gondor checker, then it follows there should be a Rider-of-Rohan checker. A village sheriff AND 2 gimped village sheriffs is a setup that I'm skeptical of.
