Big Super Hero Mafia - Game Over - Villains Win

UncleSam

Leading this village
is a Forum Moderator Alumnus
Hi everyone, today we will be lynching Summer, the superpowered wolf who is now allied with the other now-alive superpowered wolf in Bass, who sadly we don't know the alias for

If we don't lynch Summer now he will Space Gem out to an NPC and they will proceed to 2vall everyone and probably we won't be able to stop them even if both mafias and the village ally together

Just so everyone is clear: Paperblade absorbed the following role Night 1:
Dear User,


You are Malefic.


The evil counter-part to your fellow martian Martin Manhunter, you are the cause of the genocide of your entire race save for the Martian Manhunter. Upon learning of his existence on Earth, you followed him there to finish your job of becoming the last remaining Martian alive.


You are skilled in the art of Shapeshifting. Once in the game, you may send LonelyNess “Night X - Shapeshifting into ALIAS”. You will permanently assume your target’s identity, including any abilities and win condition.


You are allied with The Villains. You win if the Villains are the last remaining faction Alive.

Note the bolded portion.

Now, he used this power on Bass, who he has since revived. This means that between them they have two day kills, control of the lynch once the requisite NPCs die (since they will both have a secret vote equal to 1+number of dead npcs, and a number of NPCs have already died...), and possibly Paperblade's additional kill depending on how LN chooses to allow the shapeshifting role to interact with his normal role (based on the evidence, it would appear he retains the kill).

The evidence for this is that LightWolf wanted Isaac lynched last day, but no one voted to lynch him...however, he was lynched anyway. LightWolf tells me this is because Paperblade told him he had cast a vote for Isaac.

At the time LightWolf assumed this was because Paperblade had a secret day vote of his own, and yet...Paperblade's role PM has been shown, and he has no such secret day vote, nor did he kill Bass, and therefore he could not have attained one via his normal kill absorb role.

The conclusion? He could only have gotten it by copying Bass' role and win condition with the above shapeshifting role.

Why else would Paperblade choose to revive Bass, after all? Bass is one of the only people who could solo kill him in a late game situation; if he was to use the Soul Gem at all, it would have been to revive a useless vanillager to give the mafia more villager numbers to deal with before potentially backstabbing him, in order to balance the numbers. Reviving Bass makes no sense unless he is allied with him.

We need both mafias to help us with this, as Paperblade and Bass control a huge number of votes already between them.

Justice League, I know that using the Time Gem is extremely tempting (and would help the village as well as you under normal circumstances), but we cannot afford to let the wolves both re-roll their aliases into unknown NPCs. Their power would be far too great for us to handle, as they would have two day kills, control of the lynch soon, probably Paperblade's night kill+role powers absorbed, and all items (which, among other things, allow them to continually Space Gem among the NPCs). If we don't deal with them NOW, before they manage to Space Gem out, we will be left randing among a massive number of NPCs for the two wolves and even if we get lucky, randing the NPCs will have the effect of rushing the wolves' lynch majority even faster.
 
Last edited:

UncleSam

Leading this village
is a Forum Moderator Alumnus
Yo guys so Bass can just daykill the holder of the time gem, scav it, then use it to night so there's no point to lynching paperblade...

We may as well rand for Bass at this point. Target coming up.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 1, Guests: 0)

Top