15:41 dogfish44 akela: Can you explain comment in the SQSA?
15:41 dogfish44 I can't figure out any way for that line to make sense :x
15:43 akela the one about people trying to get refunds while breaking the rules about mandatory move purchases?
15:43 dogfish44 ?
15:43 dogfish44 Yes, don't understand it at all :x
15:44 akela The person that tried to get a refund on a starting egg move because it learned the same move via level up?
15:44 akela That was me
15:44 dogfish44 ... nope, you've lost me
15:44 Kingmidas isn't that legal
15:45 akela I was informed, before I became an approver, that I could not get a refund on an egg move if it learned the same move via level up.
15:46 dogfish44 Ah, right
15:46 Kingmidas weird
15:46 dogfish44 I see where the confusion seems to stem from
15:46 Kingmidas an approver actually reminded me of that mistake when he approved one of my claims
15:46 akela because of that, I just enforced that logic.
15:47 dogfish44 Right.
15:47 dogfish44 When a mon is moved from BW to BW2, it's the one time we can meddle with opening egg moves (Presumably because we'd have purchased something else).
15:48 dogfish44 But I see where you're coming from...
15:48 dogfish44 Legacy stuff 9.9
15:49 akela If tort can prove he purchased the move as an egg move before B2/W2, I will allow a refund.
15:49 dogfish44
http://www.smogon.com/forums/threads/prize-claiming-thread-update-5-09-13.86269/page-2#post-3327184
15:49 dogfish44 Numel is a non-issue case at least, since it's logical for a Numel to pick a different egg move in such a scenario. The awkward part would be with opening egg moves
15:49 dogfish44 where the mon is short on possible moves
15:49 akela OK, I will allow it should IAR not overrule me.
15:50 dogfish44 Stupid legacy rule, I've half a mind to throw a brick at it 9.9
15:51 akela unless it was a mandatory egg move purchase (as in you have to choose 3 egg moves and the pokemon only has 3 egg moves). I won't refund counters for a move you HAD to purchase.
15:52 Tortferngatr ...which is the case.
15:52 Tortferngatr for now I've crossed out the "only if move refund for Yawn" stuff in my update claim
15:53 dogfish44 nah tort, Numel is ok in that sense
15:54 akela by only 3 moves, I mean like Staryu
15:54 dogfish44 since at the time it could've purchased, say, Swallow
15:54 akela Staryu only had 3 egg moves. You had to purchase those 3 egg moves. No leeway.
15:54 Tortferngatr oh.
15:54 Tortferngatr ok
15:54 dogfish44 Staryu's a sad case
15:54 akela Numel had other egg moves it could purchase
15:57 akela a current mon would be like honedge. I won't allow refunds for the 2 egg moves it purchased if it later learns those moves via level up in a new game
15:58 Tortferngatr or clawitzer, which gets two of its egg moves via levelling up >.>
15:59 akela this is part of the reason some of the approvers say "No, you don't want to buy that move that way. It learns it cheaper another way."