Yes, you can write it again at any time but you need to provide reasoning as to why it is viable that wasn't states in the rejected analysis.
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
XY Ubers Analysis Index
- Thread starter MMII
- Start date
Catacomb
I advise that you run it by a mod before you write an analysis for a Pokemon that has already been rejected for one. Analyses are rejected either because the writer lacks an understanding of the Pokemon in question (analysis can be reassigned), or because the Pokemon is deemed undeserving of one as it lacks a significant enough niche in the metagame. In the latter case, it is unlikely that an analysis for the Pokemon will ever be accepted, so seeking a mod's opinion beforehand is a preemptive thing that might save you time and effort
I advise that you run it by a mod before you write an analysis for a Pokemon that has already been rejected for one. Analyses are rejected either because the writer lacks an understanding of the Pokemon in question (analysis can be reassigned), or because the Pokemon is deemed undeserving of one as it lacks a significant enough niche in the metagame. In the latter case, it is unlikely that an analysis for the Pokemon will ever be accepted, so seeking a mod's opinion beforehand is a preemptive thing that might save you time and effort
Disaster Area
formerly Piexplode
Can I redo mawile? :] Since now it needs it and I wrote the previously rejected one..
WreckDra already took it lol
Disaster Area
formerly Piexplode
lel soviet just informed me on showdown of this. Darnation; ah well I might be writing an article for The Smog or something and I have lots of other creative outlets, I can let this one go. It's not like it'll be relevant by the time it's on site what with suspect tests and ORAS.
Can someone update the OP's list of analyses?
I'm a terrible john and we'll likely be seeing mass revamps soon so updating the OP isn't too high of priority. (if a good neighbor wants to do it for me, they are welcome to)
Can I write on Tornadus-I?
Disaster Area
formerly Piexplode
What does it even do?
It uses a team slot.
A slight revamp of Giratina-O with Shadow Force and a Speedy Spread in set details is something I can do if you will let me :)
can i finish ditto because the OP is banned
I heard that one of Piex's infractions expires soon, so I'm not sure that will be necessary.
Not to mention it's literally just implementing the final GP check that needs to happen, Fireburn or MM2 can do that just as well if need be. (as happened on OU Mamoswine after Nog quit)
first, take a look at the title. this is for xy ubers analyses. we will probably need an entire new subforum (or at the very least a new thread) for oras c&c, and that takes time. the metagame hasnt even started to shape up yet either since we dont have a ladder and judging from a very small number of battles that people may have had so far is a bad way to judge an entire metagame, so i suggest holding off on the eagerness to grab analyses when we have little idea what the mons will run, how they will be used and what will be used to deal with them.
*HEAVY BREATHING* Must. Reserve. GROUDON!!!!
BTW asking out of curiosity - you guys plan to mix together Groudon and Primal Groudon in one analysis or you plan to split them up into two different analyses (and in other cases like those for example Kyogre or Rayquaza) ? While Primal Groudon is far stronger, normal Groudon still looks like a fine physical tank for example with different typing and some different niche.
The Primals and Megas operate as sets of a mon so I see no reason to separate them.