i don'ti remember when april fool's jokes were funny
I disagree with this. Banded Ninjask have a significantly higher damage output over Scarf Scyther with U-Turn and outspeed pretty much everything relevant Scyther does too. And to that there's final gambit that can actually take quite a bit of stuff out since Ninjask's HP isn't the worst ever. IIRC it wasn't even ranked in C+ because of the BP set anyway, because banded is leagues better (BP is probably a D worthy set, I'll give you that). Infiltrator is pretty nice too, because it can kill stuff through subs and screens. Fast Infiltrator Final Gambit it probably the best reason for Ninjask though, since it can stop a whole bunch of set up sweepers that way (and also stop defog/rapid spin I guess?).Ninjask from C+ to D: Scyther exists, making Ninjask completely outclassed in anything but the awful BP set ( Even Scyther can Eviolite + BP&SD with some more effectiveness, it even has access to Agility & Recovery to setup on some pokemons )
I would completely agree with your analysis that Piloswine does not carry the typing to switch into a number of resisted hits throughout the match, and often finds himself taking a lot of neutral or super effective hits that add up. However, Piloswine does not have Rhydon's 4x weaknesses nor his lack of priority, meaning Piloswine can at times choose to stay in on something he would switch out on, like seismitoad or carracosta or klingklang, and take a super effective hit and return with an EQ + ice shard for a crisp kill. Just his ability to situationally overcome his checks later in the match is a huge reason Piloswine should be considered more viable as it doesn't end up as dead weight. While it is true Torterra does have more set options and reliable recovery, he also has a set of weaknesses that are completely different from Piloswine, and I would think make him much harder to use in the current meta. Having a 4x ice weakness, along with 2x to fire, flying (and lesser extend bug) means you have an additional weakness to fire spam, mons like vivillion/swellow, mons like jynx/mesprit/aurorus, and having no priority forces you to always switch out on them.bird crew I get that Piloswine's potent dual STABs and tankiness warrants greater merit, but Pilowsine's flaws, while not apparent at first glance, do contribute greatly to its current ranking.
Piloswine does indeed have a decent matchup against various Pokemon in a 1v1 matchup, but when it comes to defensive utility it starts to come short, which is pretty notable considering its bad speed and lack of recovery pretty much force it into the role of bulky SR user; you don't want your tanky SR user to 'just be a tanky SR user' and at the same time not find many safe opportunities to switch in safely. You have to remember that people favor bulky SR mons that still provide good defensive utility due to the more offensive metagame (more so than in the BW meta), allowing them to switch into battle more frequently or easily, and either dish out hits and/or support the team in other ways.
Resistances play a crucial part in the usefulness of a bulky SR mon. Rhydon is a great example, possessing Piloswine's tanking ability but also has very important resists to the popular Normal, Fire, and Flying attacks that plague the metagame. Other examples include Carracosta and Regirock which possess the same resistances, Seismitoad with its immensely useful Water immunity, Uxie with its Fighting and Psychic resistance + Ground immunity, and even Mawile with its Bug, Ice, and Dark resistances. Piloswine has an Electric immunity and a pseudo Ice resistance, and sadly not enough opponents carry these moves to make Piloswine's defensive prowess worthwhile, not to mention there is severe competition with the Electric immunity as is with Seismitoad, Rhydon, and Mega Camerupt, which happen to carry other useful resistances respectively.
It's not just the lack of useful resists Piloswine has that contributes to its issues. Piloswine not only doesn't resist the many ubiquitous attacking types of the meta (Fire, Flying, Normal, Psychic, etc.), but it even manages to carry the weaknesses the other SR Pokemon have (Water, Fighting, and to a lesser extent Grass and Steel), meaning you still have to cover for Piloswine's weaknesses like the other SR Pokemon, but you don't even get the defensive benefits the other SR mons carry. A similar case occurs with Torterra, which doesn't have the crucial resists but carries the same weaknesses, but at the very least Torterra has much greater offensive potential in the form of Choice Band, Swords Dance, and Rock Polish, and has better longevity with Leftovers and Synthesis. Piloswine isn't bad, but it isn't particularly great either :[.
it can also do a nasty lure set with freeze dry so it can beat all of those mons 1v1 (With the exception of supergod prinplup) That does require investment however, and a reduction in speed which could be catastrophic, but its undoubtedly a way past its percieved "counters" and is really cool.I think mainly a reason why piloswine is notably not one of the go to stealth rock users is that the majority of the time, the most common defog users and other stealth rock users are bulky water types that can take advantage of its weakness to scald, fish for a burn and defog consistently. Mons like prinplup, mantine, pelipper, seismitoad all feast on it. The exception would be archeops but is rarely seen as a defog user for most teams. With this, it makes pilo's already hard job harder to the point where it would allow a free defog every time it would come in and lose offensive pressure. I like pilo, i just think B is high enough.
Alright, that's definitely a good point. I've always paired Piloswine with Roselia to supplement some of these weaknesses, although pilo definitely relies on her typing/bulk in order to do his job. I will say though that pilo disposes of archeops so effortlessly every match, you can almost ignore it from team preview.I think mainly a reason why piloswine is notably not one of the go to stealth rock users is that the majority of the time, the most common defog users and other stealth rock users are bulky water types that can take advantage of its weakness to scald, fish for a burn and defog consistently. Mons like prinplup, mantine, pelipper, seismitoad all feast on it. The exception would be archeops but is rarely seen as a defog user for most teams. With this, it makes pilo's already hard job harder to the point where it would allow a free defog every time it would come in and lose offensive pressure. I like pilo, i just think B is high enough.
This actually sounds really fascinating, and reminds me of the freeze-dry mamoswine set that gets used to counter Rotom-W in OU. I'll do some research on it, a base 60 special attack isn't that useless for a lure.it can also do a nasty lure set with freeze dry so it can beat all of those mons 1v1 (With the exception of supergod prinplup) That does require investment however, and a reduction in speed which could be catastrophic, but its undoubtedly a way past its percieved "counters" and is really cool.
Personally to me, i dont think pilo should rise yet, but if seis and m-camel leave, it will certainly be a worthy contender for a rise(aka my last post)
I'm just going to disagree for now since we have so many top tier threats that deal with klinklang reliably with mega-camel, seismitoad, gurdurr on nearly every team as well as the main stab move being inaccurate at 85% meaning it can't always reliably sweep. I'd suggest renominating this when tier shifts have happened. :]Guys, I'm making a new clock !
Klinklang A--> A+
Reasoning: This pokemon is a threat right now, with a solid steel typing and a great stab move, I believe this thing is defiantly worth of A+ rank, the fact this pokemon can set up on say many pokemon in the tier like Uxie, Cryogonal, Audino, Liepard, Jynx, Muk, Musharna, Mantine (NU no scald), Scyther, Swellow, Xatu, Mesprit. It can then easily kill all these mons if not put severe damage on them to where you can revenge kill it easily. It's stats are 60/100/115/70/85/90, I would like you to focus on that incredible defense and above average speed, this makes this mon extremly good for setting up, not to mention it's ability Clear Body, clear body is amazing as it means pokemon like granbull and mawile can not come in on this mon. I would also like to point out that due to the new suspect of Typhlosion and Mega Camerupt, this has decreased there usage, which are two of the best mons to OHKO klinklang, although even they can't switch in on a plus 1 return. This pokemon has amazing partners that can counter the pesky water types that stop it which are still limited. I also need to talk about Shift Gear which raises your attack by one and your speed by two, this is very key to klinklang as it allows it to run more bulk over speed which benefits it's overall sweeping ability. It's other move is Gear Grind, this move hits twice with base 50 power so added up it's 100 base power base move with stab and the ability to brake sashes which also lets it counter a lot of leads as well, klinklang is the full package!
Evidence: Of course, I can;t just say all these good things about klinklang and not provide at least a bit of evidence, so thanks to my friends SilverReaper21 and Winter's Howl for sweeping with this amazing pokemon. Sorry for lack there off.
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/nususpecttest-222804011
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/nu-222564724
Conclusion: Klinklang is a very good pokemon with two good signatures moves that separate it from other pokemon in the tier that can set up,yes it has it's flaws but if you didn't read what I previously just said it is definatly a high reward mon with low risk. TLDR; Gears are good for building clocks and for illegal imaginary animal fighting.
I agree with Liepard moving up... being one of the few good Dark-types is definitely a plus in a tier that's pretty much defined by the Fighting/Psychic/Dark core. Prankster T-Wave and STAB Sucker Punch are also great with all the offensive threats running around. Not sure about the Copycat set but I can definitely see it catching people off guard.
Anyways just something else I noticed... Lickilicky is C rank while regular Audino is C+. Literally the only thing Audino has over Lickilicky is Regenerator. Stat-wise it is outclassed completely. Most notably offensively (base 85/80 vs 60/60). That leaves Audino as setup bait for most of the tier. Audino doesn't even get Body Slam which would at least be somewhat acceptable. Lickilicky isn't Taunt bait either because of Oblivious, unlike Audino. Then there's the fact that Lickilicky has the stats to make use of its diverse movepool. You can run multiple sets like SubSD, SD + 3 attacks with Lum, lure sets with Fire Blast (Ferroseed) or Power Whip (Rhydon, Seismitoad), Choice Band with STAB Explosion... That's a whole lot of viable options, not even considering gimmicks like Curse or Belly Drum.
And then there's Audino. Once it reveals Lefties you know its exact set, Wish/Protect/Heal Bell/Knock Off. It's going to be the same thing every single time. With Lickilicky it's not that simple. Imo all these factors warrant Lickilicky to move up or Audino to move down.