Updated Vote Count (final given for day 1)
ButteredToast (2): Amianki, Serious Bananas
Cancerous (2): Jalmont, rssp1
Spiffy (2): Celever, PokeguyNXB
Fatecrashers (1): Spiffy
Haunted Diamond (1): vonFiedler
Jalmont (1): Haunted Diamond
Not voting (6): ButteredToast, Cancerous, Fatecrashers, Lightwolf, sunny004, Ullar
---
Day 1 End Vote Count
Cancerous (7): Jalmont, rssp1, sunny004, Fatecrashers, Amianki, Spiffy, ButteredToast
Spiffy (2): Celever, PokeguyNXB
Haunted Diamond (2): vonFiedler, Lightwolf
ButteredToast (1): Serious Bananas
Jalmont (1): Haunted Diamond
Not voting (2): Ullar, Cancerous
---
Day 2 final votecount:
Haunted Diamond (8): ButteredToast, vonFiedler, Mithril, Spiffy, PokeguyNXB, Amianki, Jalmont, sunny004
sunny004 (3): Celever, Serious Bananas, rssp1
PokeguyNXB (1): Fatecrashers
vonFiedler (1): Haunted Diamond
---
Day 3 Update:
Amianki (4): Spiffy, Jalmont, ButteredToast, Mithril
sunny004 (3): Serious Bananas, Celever, Fatecrashers
Interesting. Not only was rssp1 not voting for HD when he got lynched, but he was one of two people always voting for Cancerous on day 1. He also just plain didn't participate in the lynch that killed a neutral, but that might have more to do with his inactivity.
Early game rssp1 always kept himself out of the lineup of accusations regarding activity by posting just enough, but I wonder looking back how insightful his posts ever actually were. I encourage people to look back and decide for themselves.
Then there's the very strange subbing out by the host. More Cowbell was desperate to find a sub, but when he finally had one and didn't need it, he used it to sub out someone who didn't want out? Is it possible that rssp1 had a mafia teammate or two complaining about his absence? Perhaps his idling is why we haven't seen another post restriction.
And now his replacement is kind of pushy and opportunistic.
At the same time, now that I lay it out, as I gathered this evidence I couldn't help but notice that Serious Bananas, the village watcher, was in favor of lynching sunny004 two days in a row. Even when we had what was by all means a better scum target. Lightwolf is a high profile player, making him an obvious person to watch. I'd say this throws even more suspicion on sunny004.
Could they both be mafia? rssp1 has gone after sunny in the past, but that was also when there was no way we weren't lynching HD. Meanwhile when sunny and Pokeguy are both on the chopping block for activity, Old Ghost goes after Pokeguy even though several players have called Sunny more scummy and even though Pokeguy's activity has suddenly increased.
I heavily encourage everyone to use this analysis as a springboard for discussion. For now, I will;
vote sunny004