Okay first things first, lets start with what all was said at the end of the last day.
I intended to reply to Gale at 2 AM my time but the event I was waking up for was not happening so I kinda just went back to sleep, either way Gale didn't help his case especially after flipflopping on MC and I(especially on me considering I didn't even post between his post where he last accused me and the one where I was suddenly no longer scum), nor the whole "hey I baited phoenix into voting me by claiming a suspicious role after I was told claiming like that hurt the village and was suspicious". At the very least I can't fault acidphoenix for voting there, especially at that stage of the game, especially when as mafia all he did was throw his name into an already decided mislynch.
This brings me to today's discussion, and frankly I want to stay away from acidphoenix simply because he did way too much harm to himself if he is mafia. Only survivor of his neighbourhood, which he brought on himself(correct me if I'm wrong but all his neighbourhood friends were killed), while purposefully voting gale when that lynch was already as good as done. There is too much stacking up there that brings attention to him, negative at that. Naturally he could be doing it on purpose, but then the risk is too high for a reward oh so little. The plan also depends on some random villager defending him or having a partner buddy him, which introduces another risk.
Naturally I'm gonna personally go with a 50/50 here, because if I was betting man, just based on the setup, I'd lynch phoenix, since it does a GREAT deal in narrowing down where a mafia could be hiding. At the same time though, discussing acidphoenix becomes pointless. I'm completely willing to lynch him, most people if we have nothing better to do would, just for the benefit of removing a whole neighbourhood if we are wrong, allowing us to utilise who is in what neighbourhood far more effectively. BUT this has nothing to do with how phoenix acts, what he says, and how suspicious his contributions are, as those no longer matter now that he is an objectively good backup lynch whatever the result.
That being said our attention should be 100% focused on ANYONE BUT HIM. Deciding on a singular lynch target to early, narrows our vision and leaves us with new material we could already be on about delayed until the next day.
So on to the matter of points, firstly
Jalmont please poke people privately who haven't contributed today yet(Who I'm a hippopocrytus!), let's skip the people just posting "Hey X post" posts.
Secondly,
rssp1 , from all the posts yesterday, you can only come up with so little, including comments on only MC and acidphoenix? I was the starter and the cause of the Gale lynch, yet having no comment on me, or Eo the 3rd person to vote him, is silly.
Speaking of
Eo Ut Mortus , I get this feeling of fluff when reading to your posts, an example is when talking about neighbourless people for the good first chunk of a post that amounts to "Lets not talk about it, but think about it, but maybe we should talk about it". More recently there was a lot of space just used to discuss whether MC should or should have, not exactly sure if he did it yet, left the neighbourhood he was invited into, then some points about whether one can be in multiple neighbourhoods(which really should have been a private question to jalmont considering jalmont clearly stated he won't confirm neighbourhood details in public). Now Eo is contributing and some of his dicsussion about MC's decisions can easily be attributed to him drilling MC to see his explanation about leaving the hood contradicts anything. I merely think that previously MC answered my questions about his hoodlessness when he first jumped on phoenix adequately and his recent stuff is way below that level. To put it simpler, I feel a good chunk of Eo's posts are fluff things directed at MC, and sorta pushing discussion back towards pointless stuff about neighbour rules. But he does contribute to current discussions, be it about phoenix or Gale, unlike previous fluffers, and I can see his potential logic behind like half of it. What I'd like is if you took solider stances, if you want to drill MC like that, then drill him, currently it feels like an afterthought that takes up a good chunk of your posts. I feel like this wastes time and I want to see solid stuff instead. I can't help being vague here because from Eo's perspective he might be seriously going after MC, but to me it feels like he isn't.
tl;dr of the above paragraph, Eo stop soft point your finger at MC, if you think he is suspicious then make a stand, because as it stands you're just making yourself look suspicious to me.
Also as my last note, I'd like comments from
everyone who didn't take an active part in the discussion yesterday on the matter of Gale, and the reasonings from those who voted Gale.
In the mean time I shall
Vote rssp1. I bet everyone thought I'd vote Eo? Nah rssp1's stuff is odd already, Eo's is vague and all it boils down to is I want to him making an actual stance. Eo this doesn't mean you can just ignore my drill.