Knuckstrike
Hi I'm FIREEEE
Can we not put 10 gods in the 5 star rank please? I could see an argument for mence/kyogre to go but Xerneas, Yveltal and Dialga have too many problems to be considered 5 star.
Yveltal does have a good type combination to build a team around but is not the strongest god around. It also fares badly around the prevalent Fairy teams and doesn't have many positive matchups against the most useful gods.
Xerneas is one of the most powerful, if not the most powerful, god around that can sweep through an entire team. However, its mono-fairy gives a great teambuilding restriction that fails to cover steel-type threats (Azu and diancie do ok I guess?) and is very one-sided. It has a good mega but you're required to go to whimsicott/regular gardevoir lengths to get a decent team together. If Xerneas can't sweep, it's very tough to make good progress.
Dialga is a nice bulky god but doesn't have quite the power or means to excel as well as other gods. It can't plow through the opponent's team nearly as well as a kyogre/mence/xern/arceus can. Dragon/Steel combination is nice on paper but even kyogre teams have good means to deal with it (Swampert, Keldeo, Kingdra) and it doesn't enjoy a very positive matchup against any other god really.
Of course, all three of those are perfectly viable but not nearly flawless enough to put on 5star rank.
And yeah put kyogre higher pls. Seems one-sided but has all the means to deal with all prevalent gods.
Yveltal does have a good type combination to build a team around but is not the strongest god around. It also fares badly around the prevalent Fairy teams and doesn't have many positive matchups against the most useful gods.
Xerneas is one of the most powerful, if not the most powerful, god around that can sweep through an entire team. However, its mono-fairy gives a great teambuilding restriction that fails to cover steel-type threats (Azu and diancie do ok I guess?) and is very one-sided. It has a good mega but you're required to go to whimsicott/regular gardevoir lengths to get a decent team together. If Xerneas can't sweep, it's very tough to make good progress.
Dialga is a nice bulky god but doesn't have quite the power or means to excel as well as other gods. It can't plow through the opponent's team nearly as well as a kyogre/mence/xern/arceus can. Dragon/Steel combination is nice on paper but even kyogre teams have good means to deal with it (Swampert, Keldeo, Kingdra) and it doesn't enjoy a very positive matchup against any other god really.
Of course, all three of those are perfectly viable but not nearly flawless enough to put on 5star rank.
And yeah put kyogre higher pls. Seems one-sided but has all the means to deal with all prevalent gods.