Seems only using the vote counts as my source for who voted who was a bit shortsighted, there were many votes i didn't catch as a result.. but i still want to iso these 6, as i feel any votes not shown by a vote count weren't really held long enough to really count (excluding twin's because it was there at the end of the day, and we never really got an EoD vote count)
Asek D1
#91: This is the post that everyone jumped on him for. Says US or LW are most likely mafia before voting Jalmont for being the "most likely lynch" when the bandwagon was long over.
#177: Admits it was bandwagoning, unvoting Jalmont, states he's against Vegeta or Buu claiming, elaborates on his US vs LW thoughts a little bit, particularly with US.
#317: States he finds internet and US to be the scummiest players, but steeledges, dle, and acid should be looked at for inactivity, fleshing out these reads as well, seems townie enough
#410: says internet is top scumread, saying acid isn't really a bad lynch either, explains his stance on LW, then voting internet at the end of the post
#421: Switches to acid, stating he wants an internet lynch next cycle
D2
#442: States flavor-wise it looks like Broly killed Walrein, says he'll give more thoughts later
#481: Explains why he believes the flavor on Walrein matches Broly better than maf, says twin is susp for really starting the acid lynch, confused as to why acid couldn't defend himself better, also pointing out how twin switched to US last minute, which was scummy. Proceeds to continue saying internet is his top scumread, voting him.
He says he's going to post a lot more this cycle, and honestly i'm inclined to believe him. He seems consistent in wanting to find scum, and he HAS made at least some contribution, although stumbling at first. Leaning Town
billymills D1
#25: bandwagon rvs on Jalmont
#97: doesn't want Vegeta to claim, except maybe near deadline
#100&106 not game relevant
#112&115: pushes BT to post
#120: votes US because he "doesn't get it"
#134: Gives some reads (US is bogging thread, Yeti is null, Blazade's good, not impressed by BT's non-reaction), voting rssp presumably for pressure
#136: "What's the problem with Vegeta claiming cop?"
#139: Misunderstanding of the confusing af claiming rules
#144: Explains the plan a bit more, saying ignore it if the claim rules work differently
#146: Gives up on this plan because the rules aren't really that clear.
#151: Extremely simplified summary of US vs LW
#159: comment on the shitpost following Yeti's iso post
#161: comment on his #151's response
#162&168: comments on deadline
#179: Says Yeti's #178 is strange, pointing out seemingly random capitalisation
#183: Clarifies he feels nothing about the current argument because it's all regarding meta
#200: votes US, finding it strange he's differentiating between mafia and android play, and US has been distracting from the goal of finding mafia
#204: "stop discussing androids"
#212: Says he's fine pushing US to claim, again expressing frustration over meta discussion
#219: expresses desire to lynch US
#223: points out that Android kills go through protection
#230: says half the game hasn't posted anything relevant, though he COULD iso me or Haruno, but wants to see more people post first.
#234: More reads, BT scum lean, Asek not scum, Jalmont null.
#237: "Can we please lynch Sam?"
#247: Says there's no point in posting currently because US is most susp and had the most votes.
#271: wants deadline moved up
#291: Is convinced US is mafia, saying he'll post closer to deadline
#335: Elaborates more on US, saying he's acting too insecure in his reads, and that US should know LW's play better
#380: Irrelevant
#386: Yup, US is back
#392: Unvotes US finally because "Yeti convinced him", doesn't see what's wrong with acid, points out how susp twin's unvote once acid gained traction was
#407: Explains why he focused on US
#408: Votes twin for reasons statd in his #392
#418: Switches to acid because he "seems to have conceded"
D2
#463: says twin is still susp af, but wants to push Mithril. thinks internet and BT are good, but finds twin, Mithril, and Haruno susp
#464: says he still would've preferred a US lynch over the acid lynch
#465: states he believes the androids misfired, and sam was probably killed for being 100% not Vegeta or Buu
#469: clarifies again why twin's scummy. says he agrees that there's scum within the 6 players i pointed out, suspecting Haruno, twin, and rssp to be it
#473: Response to Mithril, stating he's scummy due to buddying US and being overly safe
After looking over his posts, i do believe my scumread on him was a bit hasty, although early on there wasn't that much beyond "US is scum" and a few reaction tests, he has been giving much more since then. He's boosted himself to a Null
Now Jalmont has already ISO'd Haruno, so i'll only be covering posts made since then
Haruno Late D1
#429: Says they'll make a reads list, first to coin one of the veteran players must be maf due to balance
#431-433: NIGHTPOSTS -_-, all useless one liners
D2
#438: an OMGUS on Jalmont
#439: ISO of Walrein to see if they can find why he was killed, saying Mithril is the most likely scum to have lead this due to Walrein pushing him
#445: Goes over all the possibilities of how US and Walrein died. In other words, more meta.
#454: More meta
#479: States Jalmont's way of thinking is "dangerous", objects to the signifigance of my line of thinking about the group, seeming to think i think all of them are automatically scummy for this. Yes, i suspect them slightly, but i'm not calling anyone scum until i ISO them like this and come to that conclusion.
Speaking of which Haruno seems to do nothing but post meta related fluff, and they're playing insanely defensively the moment someone even remotely suspects them (see Jalmont OMGUS, and questioning my list). Scum
internet D1
#126: wants to move away from Vegeta/Buu discussion in favor of discussing the "good player's reads"
#147: points out US vs LW is seemingly normal, though seems to think LW was a bit odd
#185: Votes US, bandwagoning off me, calls out acid to post
#188: States he already believed US was susp, saying he has a "good gut feeling" about me
#190: points to the mandatory lynch rule
D2
#467: Wants to look for android signals, pointing out those who voted US
Okay, internet has barely even posted anything, and what he has posted for the most part is repeats of what others have said, me especially. As such there isn't much TO read. Lean Scum
rssp1 D1
#45: Speculation on how transporter works
#49: Wants clarification of how roles work before any claiming takes place
#51: Agrees with Blazade about how Vegeta claims should be handled, bringing up the problem of if they don't claim they could kill town
#141: says he'll post after a haircut
#149: Agrees mostly with Blazade, but "his math is silly". Says Vegeta should claim if being lynched, iffy on LW, agrees nobody can really "lead" in NOC
#152: Tries to get clarification on what the Vegeta plan is
#154&157: shitposts
#160: wants clarification from LW what the plan is
#231: Admits to being lazy, saying he'll read up and contribute
#252: Thinks we're gonna have Vegeta claim on lynch, pointing out worse-case we're using our revive on him, because maf will 100% claim Vegeta if being lynched
#257: says he'll give some reads, gives some reads, then says he'll elaborate later
#260: gives a stance on reads lists
#264: "I thought deadline was on Sunday?"
#269: NL due to thinking deadline's soon and needing to vote
#270: nvm, deadline is later
#273: still talking about deadline :/
#327: Massive post summarising the game so far and giving a full readslist, votes billy
#329: "the 'everyone dies' setup"
#331: says he posted his thoughts as he read through the game
#358: Points out a votecount mistake
#359: explains to LW his read on him, agrees with billy US should be looked at later, switches vote to acid
#364&367: Host question clarification
#371: Asking questions to acid about his reads
#414: shitpost
D2
#460: Says he'll post later, agrees with Blazade about billy, finds Haruno's OMGUS strange
#472: believes the kills were maf and Broly, reviver shouldn't claim, android signalling is going to be difficult to find
not exactly sure what to make of him... he has a few good points, but a lot of non-content posts as well. Null
THE_IRON_...KENYAN? D1
#9: Says he agrees with Vegeta claiming
#14: Says he feels there's a couple of softs already
#58: shitpost
#59: Votes US for tryharding
#308: Requests sub
Thetwinmasters (post-sub D1)
#340: Says he won't be able to post for a bit, but he's reading up
#344: Votes acid for idling like he did in Fire and Ice
#376: Switches to US for being inconsistent, saying US, internet, and acid are all good lynches
#417: Comments on how king just null read most of the game, also asking US what he wants to hear
#419: tags US
#425: top two town are LW and Blazade, top scum are internet, acid, and macle. Gives additional reads before switching back to acid for majority
D2
#459: votes Yeti
#484: Switches to king so he posts some actual reads, wants Yeti to flesh out reads more, points out Haruno's OMGUS, internet's interest in androids, and dle's current iDLE state
Let's start with TIK. He barely even did anything, though pointing out the fact that he sees softs isn't exactly the towniest thing ever. then as soon as twin subs in, he pushes acid, then abandoning it for US after the US bw had completely died, then switching right back to acid in time to hammer it. Also definitely seems to not like King... maybe I'll look into that, but his D1 was pretty bad, and his D2 doesn't have much yet. Scum
That took nearly all day to do, you're welcome guys. Ranking these players in order from who i personally think is scummiest to who i think is towniest, that gives us:
Haruno
Thetwinmasters
internet
rssp1
billymills
Asek
As such for now Lynch Haruno, they have a slight edge over twin for being waaaaaayyyyy too defensive. If they provide a good enough defence i'll change this
