Originally Posted by Fat polelover44
No, this set actually works. I was just in a battle with it, down 6-4, and 6 turns later, I had won 4-0.
Just because you manage to beat someone with it, doesn't mean that it's good or will actually work most of the time. You're able to do much less damage than you can with a Bulk Up or Choice Band set, and have less survivability than you would if you had run Leftovers and Recover. It's also more solidly walled by things like Zapdos and Celebi, being able to do less potential damage to them than it could otherwise. It may take people by surprise, but Arghonaut has better things to be doing and there are Pokemon that can run Choice Specs much better.