Not that I want to add gasoline to the fire here but I actually enjoyed reading this. Right or wrong, MrE's post presents an in depth argument about competitive pokemon which we hardly see anymore in this particular forum. I read it as opinionated more so than self indulgent and I think the main reason E states that he doesn't want to address arguments is because he's already made his points. He's merely stating his opinion. At the very least this isn't a completely senseless "X is uber" or "Y is not uber" whatever post.
That said, I'm not about to step on another mod's toes here and unlock this because a) that would be rude and b) Caelum is actually correct in closing this. You've made your points MrE but maybe you should have done this in the proper place or followed the methods we're going by to determine what's uber and what isn't.