Originally Posted by Fat polelover44
I actually didn't think it worked out that well. It runs on a complete honor system, as Outlaw mentioned, and people can fake logs to get the host to godkill the player. Also, as Raikage mentioned, it takes all the fun out of mafia, whereas you can still talk when silenced. Nerfed, it would make a good role, but it's not really that good as it was specifically used in Metroidvania.
So, just add a requirement that they must screenshot (full screenshot, including the computer clock's time) the conversation, etc. for evidence. This would be an exception to the general no screenshotting rule. Also, many players do obey the honor system; it's just a few who don't that are making people hesitant about this role.
On to other, unquoted, posts.
As for the previously mentioned problem of it's NOC, and you need to talk during mafia: thread conversations (maybe set up keywords beforehand, so "gargle fire" means "kidnap Aura Guardian" or something like that), maybe let mafia talk with each other, make it unable to work with silence, make it last less time, etc.
So, some people are hating this power from one game. It hasn't had time to be perfected yet. Find the perfect balance for it, and it will be a good role, just like many other roles that are potentially overpowered. Of course I dispute that it's overpowered and all.
So, this role needs to be done more times.