Yeah we talked about it on IRC last night and I agree the best spread is the 176 HP / 192 Atk / 4 SpD / 136 Spe one. The extra bulk isn't that much useful and being able to take Scrafty down reliably is way better. I agree with FlareBlitz about not making the stronger one the main spread, as I think the 192 Atk spread fares already well enough against BU Scrafty.
__________________
|