Do you honestly think that the community are going to pick really stupid suspects to test? You're saying it would never stop if the users pick, yet your Council of 5 members had suspects to test for what; 2 years of BW1?
If you don't agree with letting us pick the suspects, then at least let us discuss what we think about it in the thread. Censoring us to talk ONLY about the ones YOU picked is not helping. We should be working together here, but what you're doing is causing the users and the Council to drift further apart.