Orcinus Duo said:
nEsp: keeps using busy/inexperience as an excuse. I'm not a fan of that.
To be honest, I think you'd rather hear my current reason then a lie. If you'd like, I could tell you what I've been doing each day, if you need that to believe me. But I agree that it seems like a fishy excuse, and I would probably not trust myself either, if I didn't knew my role already.
Engineer Pikachu - I want to hear some thoughts on people from you. Especially on MB, AG and OD. Even if you have no certain reads, you must have at least an opinion right now. (Okay, I am slow to write posts. But I wonder if there was a reason behind choosing me when you list others as equally suspicious as me.)
(theangryscientist) Paperblade - Many uninformative posts. To me it seems like someone trying to seem like he's posting a lot while giving no important information, such as thoughts and analyses. Still need to explain why he thinks Mithril is town. (Okay, you answered this while I was writing. Still don't like that we had to ask you for reason, but that's just my paranoia.)
Mithril - Was post #281 the thoughts you promised us? It seems awfully little to me. I'd rather he posts a bit more. If you need inspiration, you could give us some thoughts on AG, OD and MB. I wouldn't mind people analysing me a bit more either.
Ditto - Keeps prodding inactive users, and giving small but useful posts. Not much to say about him yet, which is far from comforting me.
auramaster - Too inactive recently. Thoughts on MB, AG and OD, please. On second thought, his recent posts haven't been that contributing. The only recent post where he gives us any information was #265, and he himself says it was only because he was voted earlier that he posted his opinions. To me, that sounds like mafia.
Flamestrike - I didn't knew I had a clone. Seriously though, his behavior is so similar to mine that it's creepy. I cannot really say anything else about him, which isn't comforting as it means you probably cannot say anything about me either. Most people seem to think he's helpful, but I fail to see what makes him seem townish.
empoof - Nothing to complain about. Keep going like this.
Metal Bagon - Seems new, as an experienced player probably wouldn't have said that he'll turn wolf the second the doctor dies. And it's not the most common role, making me doubt that it's the role a newbie would claim. But if he's experienced, it'd be a smart fake-claim. Or would it? It would only buy him time enough until the doctor dies. In other words, if MB is mafia, the mafia would be losing a member the second the doctor dies, forcing them to out a member in order to kill a villager. But if they already know who the doc is, they could let him live in order to have MB's fake-claim be viable.
Even though, I have a hunch that he's town as there are other uncommon roles to claim as. Thus, I'd say we let him live, for now, as we can kill him the second the doc dies. Or manipulate him. What do you say, MB? Are you willing to cooperate with the village in case the doctor dies, or do we have to kill you?
Orcinus Duo - A bit more offensive then the rest of us, but that's probably because he's used to a more active community. I wouldn't say 100% town yet, but I doubt that he'd be advocating discussion this much if he's scum. But on the other hand, I believe he's skilled enough to be able to fool all of us.
nEsp - Myself. And maybe a bit too inactive, I'll do my best in order to be better from now and on. Even though when I get on, there usually isn't much discussion going on. Probably due to time-zones, I guess.
khz - A difficult one. Seems to be a bit better then the average in this game. If nothing else, I appreciate his ability to see things from different perspectives. Cannot say whether his scum or not, though.
(Maxim) Hydrattler - After you've read through the thread, post something of substance, okay?
Aura Guardian - Defensive and quiet. I doubt that a counterclaim will occur, due to that I doubt that the village even have a roleblocker. Someone'll have to fill me in on how common the role is as village. He tried to go on the offensive with that trap though, which I appreciate. Just don't stop now.
pokémaniac 212 - Way too uncertain of. Please post more, okay?
New World Order - Seems clean. I find it unlikely that the village has no mayor, and there's been no counterclaim.
Seconding that MB should post his questions and answers. And I cannot see how that post from Spiffy can help us, really, as opinions are very likely to change over time.
Going to bed now, and I'd appreciate if there are some questions for me to answer tomorrow.