Go Back   Smogon Community > Contributions & Corrections > Archives > Locked / Outdated Analyses
Register FAQ Social Groups Calendar Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

 
 
Thread Tools
Old Mar 30th, 2012, 9:20:08 PM   #26
JellyOs
 
JellyOs's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2010
Posts: 453
Default

You should mention Lucario as a great partner to take Bullet punches coming your way and getting rid of Blissey. Also, if you flee from a Ttar's Crunch you can take advantage of the Justified boost. I'd also recommend just calling the set Protect. It's a good set for the current meta and I hope it gets through. It plays a lot differently than the Sub+Misc sets.
__________________
JellyOs is offline  
Old Apr 2nd, 2012, 2:44:31 AM   #27
Pocket
Bakuman ;<
is a Forum Moderatoris a Community Contributoris a Tiering Contributoris a Contributor to Smogonis a Team Rater Alumnus
 
Pocket's Avatar
 
Moderator
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 7,177
Bergenfield
Default

I played with this set, but Protect Gar plays too similarly to the Sub + 3 Atks to warrant its own analysis. Protect and Sub both have its perks, and arguably Sub is more useful than Protect outside of beating CB Scizor. Even more, I find HP Fire to be the biggest selling point than Sub / Protect, being able to nail Steel-types without resorting to Focus Blast's atrocious accuracy.

Protect will probably be slashed with Substitute in the analysis on-site, but there's little justification to do more.

QC Rejected
Pocket is online now  
Old Apr 10th, 2012, 1:58:36 PM   #28
Jimera0
I have to get to GOLDENROD for myEnemy ???????
is a Community Contributor
 
Jimera0's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 1,454
Canada
Default

I... sorry but I completely fail to see how this is any different from the Substitute set on site. I'mnot saying Protect doesn't have its merrits; I'm sure it does. I just don't see why it doesn't get a slash on the current 3 attacks set and a quick mention and call it a day.

It has the same moves bar Protect, the same play style as Sub (more or less), the same EVs and items... there's no need for a separate analysis. Hell, checking right now PROTECT IS ALREADY MENTIONED IN THE 3 ATTACK ANALYSIS. This set is COMPLETELY pointless.

Sorry, no support from me here.
__________________
Credits for avatar go to my friend Seraphinu!
My Scramble Challanges: Found here
Current Challange: Hard Emerald Scramble No more video updates, sorry!
The Gauntlet Challenge!
Need help learning how to battle or getting into the Smogon community? Use the Mentorship Program!
Jimera0 is offline  
Old Apr 10th, 2012, 3:54:45 PM   #29
JellyOs
 
JellyOs's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2010
Posts: 453
Default

Current on-site analysis:


This set is similar to the previous two, except gaining one coverage move to specifically hit its counters who take neutral damage from Focus Blast. Due to the popularity of the previous two sets, Hidden Power Fire is sometimes neglected as a possible third move that can unexpectedly smash Scizor and Ferrothorn for the OHKO. Hidden Power Fire also hits Skarmory, Bronzong, and Jirachi for super effective damage, possibly 2HKOing Jirachi with Spikes on the field. Since Focus Blast's inability to hit consistently is such a letdown, Hidden Power Fire makes a great option over Thunderbolt for hitting Steel-types. However, Thunderbolt is still a useful alternative if bulky Water-types such as Gyarados, Suicune, and Vaporeon prove to be a nuisance to the team. As usual, Substitute is an absolute requirement for this set to act as a safety blanket against Pursuit users and status inducers. The item selection for this set is a toss-up; Leftovers allows for more survivability, while Life Orb increases damage output needed for OHKOs and 2HKOs on defensive threats such as Ferrothorn and Jirachi.

Maximum Special Attack and Speed with a Timid nature provides the most sweeping potency. Even with the Speed drop from Hidden Power Fire, Gengar is still a speed point ahead of the musketeers, and outpaces anything below them. However, it is recommended to have a sturdy Latios and Latias counter now that Gengar's Speed is a point lower than them.

Protect was a lot more effective back in DPP due to the prevalence of Choice Pursuit users, namely Scizor and Tyranitar. However, they are no longer as popular as they were, making Protect a barely adequate option to use over Substitute. It can still be used to conserve HP and scout for the occasional Choice trapper, however.

Offensive Dragon-types, such as Haxorus, Dragonite, and Salamence, make excellent choices for partners thanks to Gengar's ability to draw in either Steel-types or bulky Water-types and weaken them with highly damaging attacks. Fighting-types, especially Terrakion and Lucario, make perfectly good partners should Gengar be KOed by a Choice-locked Pursuit user. The free turn allows them to set up their respective stat-up moves and possibly sweep.




Maybe just take out the bold paragraph, put a few lines in the first one detailing Protect's advantages? I like Protect a lot, it's tons better for scouting. It really helps against Volt-Turn too, letting you ease your own buffer into it. But Jimera has points, as they do play quite alike. I don't want Protect go to waist at all, and it needs some better mentions than "it's inferior to Substitute", because it's not, they just do different things depending on the situation.
__________________
JellyOs is offline  
Old Apr 10th, 2012, 4:00:01 PM   #30
Jimera0
I have to get to GOLDENROD for myEnemy ???????
is a Community Contributor
 
Jimera0's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 1,454
Canada
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fat JellyOs View Post
Current on-site analysis:


This set is similar to the previous two, except gaining one coverage move to specifically hit its counters who take neutral damage from Focus Blast. Due to the popularity of the previous two sets, Hidden Power Fire is sometimes neglected as a possible third move that can unexpectedly smash Scizor and Ferrothorn for the OHKO. Hidden Power Fire also hits Skarmory, Bronzong, and Jirachi for super effective damage, possibly 2HKOing Jirachi with Spikes on the field. Since Focus Blast's inability to hit consistently is such a letdown, Hidden Power Fire makes a great option over Thunderbolt for hitting Steel-types. However, Thunderbolt is still a useful alternative if bulky Water-types such as Gyarados, Suicune, and Vaporeon prove to be a nuisance to the team. As usual, Substitute is an absolute requirement for this set to act as a safety blanket against Pursuit users and status inducers. The item selection for this set is a toss-up; Leftovers allows for more survivability, while Life Orb increases damage output needed for OHKOs and 2HKOs on defensive threats such as Ferrothorn and Jirachi.

Maximum Special Attack and Speed with a Timid nature provides the most sweeping potency. Even with the Speed drop from Hidden Power Fire, Gengar is still a speed point ahead of the musketeers, and outpaces anything below them. However, it is recommended to have a sturdy Latios and Latias counter now that Gengar's Speed is a point lower than them.

Protect was a lot more effective back in DPP due to the prevalence of Choice Pursuit users, namely Scizor and Tyranitar. However, they are no longer as popular as they were, making Protect a barely adequate option to use over Substitute. It can still be used to conserve HP and scout for the occasional Choice trapper, however.

Offensive Dragon-types, such as Haxorus, Dragonite, and Salamence, make excellent choices for partners thanks to Gengar's ability to draw in either Steel-types or bulky Water-types and weaken them with highly damaging attacks. Fighting-types, especially Terrakion and Lucario, make perfectly good partners should Gengar be KOed by a Choice-locked Pursuit user. The free turn allows them to set up their respective stat-up moves and possibly sweep.




Maybe just take out the bold paragraph, put a few lines in the first one detailing Protect's advantages? I like Protect a lot, it's tons better for scouting. It really helps against Volt-Turn too, letting you ease your own buffer into it. But Jimera has points, as they do play quite alike. I don't want Protect go to waist at all, and it needs some better mentions than "it's inferior to Substitute", because it's not, they just do different things depending on the situation.
Yeah I'm good with that. Protect certainly deserves a mention and some credit, but these two... they're the same damn set with one move swapped out! A simple paragraph stating how protect can help scout and how when combined with HP Fire it wrecks Volt Turn would be sufficient.
__________________
Credits for avatar go to my friend Seraphinu!
My Scramble Challanges: Found here
Current Challange: Hard Emerald Scramble No more video updates, sorry!
The Gauntlet Challenge!
Need help learning how to battle or getting into the Smogon community? Use the Mentorship Program!
Jimera0 is offline  
Old Apr 10th, 2012, 4:43:21 PM   #31
ThePillsburyDoughBoy
Ttar by Doughboy
is a Community Contributor
 
ThePillsburyDoughBoy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Posts: 955
Default

I personally would slash Thunderbolt in the third spot since when using HP Fire you lose out on tieing in the critical 110 speed tier (aka Latios, Latias, Espeon) all things Gengar can hit super-effectively. However if it is to beat Volt-Turn (have fun switching in :l ) then I guess HP Fire should be there alone.
__________________
ThePillsburyDoughBoy is online now  
Old Apr 12th, 2012, 10:00:22 PM   #32
Woodchuck
<Feranfell> punbot irl aka virginity protector
is a Smogon IRC AOpis a Battle Server Moderator
 
Woodchuck's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 1,652
us best
Default

Thunderbolt in the third slot would kind of completely defeat the purpose of the set. With Protect, Gengar becomes an excellent lure/scout, especially when used with Magnezone. It actually plays quite differently than with Substitute; Gengar seems to have a greater support role with Protect in my experience.

Quote:
they're the same damn set with one move swapped out!
So are the rest of the Gengar sets, lol.
__________________
Woodchuck is online now  
Old Apr 19th, 2012, 9:16:32 PM   #33
Trinitrotoluene
And we will never be alone again / 'cause it doesn't happen everyday / kinda counted on you being a friend / kinda given up on giving away...
is an official Team Rater
 
Trinitrotoluene's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 717
np: Daft Punk - Instant Crush (feat. Julian Casablancas)
Default

WIP post for Deep Sea of Mare.

...
__________________

Last edited by Trinitrotoluene; Jul 18th, 2012 at 5:40:12 AM.
Trinitrotoluene is offline  
Old Apr 20th, 2012, 2:49:38 AM   #34
Black Rain
 
Black Rain's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2012
Posts: 112
Default

Protect would give Gengar a really nice edge over a large portion of the metagame, namely, as others above me have stated, Scizor, Tyranitar, and volt-turn based teams. In my opinion, it's a pretty forgotten set and not many people use it anymore.

@STEELDRAGON: I don't think the Defense EV's will be necessary. The idea is to use Protect to scout whether Scizor uses Bullet Punch or Pursuits. If Scizor pursuits, Scizor will be OHKO'd by HP Fire, and if Bullet Punch, Gengar will switch into a resist.
__________________
Terrakion used Stone Edge!
The attack of Terrakion missed!
Black Rain is offline  
Old Apr 20th, 2012, 11:28:29 AM   #35
zdrup15
is a Tiering Contributoris a Battle Server Moderatoris a Contributor Alumnus
 
zdrup15's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 1,720
Default

I'm sorry but I don't like this set. It's too situational and you're usually better with Sub + 3 Attacks.

QC REJECTED 2/3

However, I do agree that Protect deserves a mention and the one currently on-site isn't the most flattering, so if this gets a third rejection, I'll edit it.
zdrup15 is offline  
Old Apr 25th, 2012, 12:48:55 PM   #36
Bloo**
mon cœur s'ouvre ŕ ta voix
is a Tutoris a Tournament Directoris a member of the Smogon Site Staffis an official Team Rateris an Artistis a Community Contributoris a Pokémon Researcheris a Contributor to Smogon Mediais a Tiering Contributoris a Contributor to Smogonis an Administratoris a Battle Server Admin Alumnusdefeated the Smogon Frontieris a Smogon World Cup defending champion
 
Bloo's Avatar
 
Administrator
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 1,455
Default

Giving this its third rejection. The reasons for the rejections have been explained already, so I won't say anything.

Moving to L&O. Feel free to mention this on-site when you can, zdrup!
Bloo is offline  
  Smogon Community > Contributions & Corrections > Archives > Locked / Outdated Analyses

« Previous Thread | Next Thread »
Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



All times are GMT -4. The time now is 6:41:55 PM.