|
|||||||
|
|
Thread Tools |
|
|
#1 |
|
I love weather; Sun for days
![]() ![]() ![]()
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 3,573
Where the Sun finally sets
|
I was rolling this around a little when I first took over DW, but KD24 and I agreed that it would probably be a poor move. Now that DW has balanced itself out a bit (with a fantastic banlist to boot!) I was wondering what everyone's thoughts on making Darkrai legal in DW. Personally I could see it going either way. We have awesome pokemon like Xatu and Espeon which can bounce back Dark Void. We have the new and improved Breloom (and Hitmonlee to an extent) to plow over it. Genesect to crush it. Ditto to make it setting up a risky move altogether.
While I don't really have a say in the tier anymore, that's Tobes's and Birkal's job now (sucks to be you guys!), I do want to push this around. When I made the tier I did promise I would listen to the people's needs. So I'm going to force Birkal and Tobes to listen to them anyway. |
|
|
|
|
#2 |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
|
I would be up for testing this, as there are a multitude of checks for Darkrai. Something that bothers me is how relatively easy it used to sweep in old OU though -- really, while there are better checks, you can just bring up that Choice Scarf Terrakion worked as a check in OU, and that Scizor always dealt major damage to it. I feel as though it would still be an overpowered Pokemon, and that maybe if this test goes through, we could limit the amount of time it stayed in the tier (1-2 weeks or something). Since there is going to be a Dream World ladder reset, we could use that to our advantage and test now or something.
__________________
!!! |
|
|
|
|
#3 |
|
Woo-hoo, woo-hoo-hoo, woo-hoo-hoo-woo-hoo-hoo-hoo!
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
Moderator
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 2,246
GONER
|
Darkrai is something I've been giving legitimate consideration to testing. I feel that Dream World should try to push the banlist to a reasonable extent; I'm just not entirely convinced that Darkrai falls under that reasonable extent. There are some decent arguments for it, and I intend to re-test it when BW2 is released and we have the Sacred Beast Formes (along with possibly Deoxys-N, since it never got a "fair" test, though I'm much more skeptical about that one. And no Skymin because it's still a cunt.).
If the public really wants this to happen I'd be willing to test it ahead of schedule, so make yourselves heard if that's what you really want. I'll be monitoring this thread.
__________________
|
|
|
|
|
#4 | |
|
I'm a macrophage
![]() ![]()
Join Date: Jul 2009
Posts: 3,849
|
Hm, I always did think Darkrai was the least broken out of the suspects banned in round 1 (along wih Deoxys-N), so I wouldn't really mind if it got tested again. Like Harsha, I do think it's still probably too good, but hey, I can't see what's wrong with letting Darkrai loose in the tier for a couple of weeks (definitely better than Chandelure, that's for sure).
__________________
Whatevs sig. QC member for OU and Ubers, VM me for a look at your analysis. Just make sure it's good. Also, if you want me to rate your team (OU/DW OU/Ubers), give me a VM. If I don't rate it, it's either 1) it's so shit it's too much trouble, 2) I'm busy, or 3) the team is fantastic and I have nothing I can suggest to you. You should be able to recognise which one. Quote:
|
|
|
|
|
|
#5 |
|
schemes and plots are the same thing
![]() ![]()
Join Date: Jun 2010
Posts: 1,023
Michigan
|
I guess I'm in the minority here when I say that I honestly see no reason to give Darkrai a legitimate shot. I remember back in round one of suspect testing where, at least for me, it was the second most annoying suspect behind Skymin. Sure it has a few more checks in DW, but Geno has really just replaced Scizor so it's not like it gained a check their and scarfers aren't quite as popular due to Excadrill ruining the speed tiers.
__________________
![]() |
|
|
|
|
#6 |
|
Join Date: Aug 2010
Posts: 111
Ohio
|
The problem with Espeon and Xatu is that if you don't have 100% perfect predictions, Darkrai just Dark Pulsed your poor little Psychic type to death. Essentially you have a 25% chance of succeeding against Darkrai by switching in your Magic Bouncer. If anyone didn't figure it out yet, that 25% chance is Dark Void (and if Darkrai were ever allowed in DW OU, I'm sure Lum Berry would be a very popular option, meaning you essentially commit suicide switching your Magic Bounce Pokemon into Darkrai).
Breloom is the same, if Darkrai decides to run Ice Beam it is dead. It's a really sad excuse for a check, the only moves it can switch into is Nasty Plot (it enjoys an LO Dark Pulse like a person enjoys a bullet, it has no reliable recovery, and LO damage will wear it down really fast). Scizor isn't as popular in DW OU, mostly being replaced by Genesect (who does not enjoy Focus Blast or Dark Void. Neither of them do, in fact). The biggest problem with Darkrai is Dark Void - whatever it can't annihilate immediately gets put to Sleep and becomes a big burden for the other player (especially with Gen 5's new sleep mechanics). While you could say Breloom is the same, Darkrai users can mispredict and still KO whatever comes in due to its great coverage,
...
great speed, and amazing Special Attack. Really gimmicky checks to Darkrai would be Scarf Sleep Talk Heracross (ridiculous overcentralization, Heracross isn't seen very often due to a number of factors I won't get into at this very moment), and Sleep Talk Specially Defensive Toxicroak (a horrible idea useless for anything but checking Darkrai - if it carries a coverage move other than Focus Blast you're fucked) So do I think reintroduction of Darkrai would be healthy? Naw. The only real differences from Wifi is that TechBreloom is used quite a bit (eaten by Darkrai really easily), Excadrill is allowed (beaten by Focus Blast, common coverage move), and Thundurus is allowed (biggest reason for Darkrai to run Lum Berry is to allow it to beat Thundurus more easily and not end up paralyzed for the rest of the match). The new DW Pokes all get beaten rather easily by Dark Void + Focus Blast.
__________________
ENSLAVE FLASH http://pastebin.com/hXv38TSH http://pastebin.com/yQiLYEpu (19:58:47) Elite: IMP isn't shorthand for anything (19:58:50) Elite: it's an acronym (19:58:55) Elite: I Masturbate Profusely |
|
|
|
|
#7 |
|
Join Date: Oct 2010
Posts: 1,498
♠ AmoongBro ♠
|
i have split opinions of darkrai.
while it willbe cool to see darkrai in dw ou as it seems that there are enough pokes that check/counter him, am still not entirely sure. thats why i see darkrai as a parallel to jynx of NU. as you guys might know, jynx recently got banned and i think darkrai is the jynx of DW. let me demonstrate: 1) similar stat spread. both jynx and darkrai are specially-inclined offensive mons with speeds pretty high for their respective tiers (95 In NU is pretty fast). they also have sky high special attacking stats for their tiers. they are also, not that bulky. 2. movepools and 4mss this is a big one. they have almost identical movepools (kinda). most importantly, they both carry sleep moves with respectable accuracies. they also get a strong stab that gets almost perfect coverage in their tiers. They also get nasty plot, a great boosting move for special sweepers. they can both run sub+np sets with great success. this is where the problems come in. 4mss hits them hard. jynx would like to run sub+calm mind+nasty plot+ice beam+psychic+grass knot+focus blast+lovely kiss, but each 4m set has different counters. same withsdarkrai. he can run sub+nasty plot+dark pulse+focus blast+ice beam+extrasensory(does he learn this?)+dark void, but he cannot. this was a problem for both jynx and darkrai. and some of the main points that allowed jynx to stay for some time in NU. 3. counter and checks. jynx and darkrai have different checks for different movesets. this is worsened by the fact that they both can CHOOSE WHAT POKEMON TO IMMOBILIZE. this is a big point. they are diverse pokemon (heck darkrai can run a swords dance+sucker punch set) with great potentials that might be a wee strong for their respective tier
__________________
AmoongBro User (22:54:20) *** Your rank in Dream World OU is 15/16972 [1442 points / 244 battles]! |
|
|
|
|
#8 |
|
no.... no i do not look like psyduck
![]() ![]() ![]()
Moderator
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 3,988
play?
|
I do not support Darkrai for DW.
My personal experience on our "Ubers" ladder was a month+ worth of me gaping wholes in teams that the opponent never seemed to redeem himself/herself from; holding first position on the ladder for this length of time simply due to Darkrai alone. Haunter may attest to this as he was sometimes spectating my Uber run. This was in our Uber's metagame and while I encourage to test suspects in Dream World, I'm baffled as to how we wind up proposing the idea of Darkrai after banning Blaziken. If we are to nominate Darkrai, why was the question popped after one half of the council deemed Blaziken Uber? If Blaziken was currently still legal in Dream World then I'd be more optimistic about this suggestion.
__________________
Last edited by Taylor; May 23rd, 2012 at 4:13:18 PM. |
|
|
|
|
#9 |
|
♭
Join Date: Sep 2010
Posts: 2,425
♯
|
While I don't feel that it will stay for long, I personally don't think it would be a bad idea to test Darkrai on the DW ladder at this time. This is mainly due to the fact that it has several offensive checks in this meta, ranging from Extremespeed from Dragonite to the common sight of Mach Punch Breloom. A lot of Choice Scarf Pokemon in this meta can outspeed and OHKO it as well - Chandelure, for one, outspeeds all non-Scarf Darkrai and revenge kills easily. Basically, any non-scarf set is easily taken out offensively. On the other hand, Choice Scarf is a lot more difficult to handle depending on how you look at it - Trick + Dark Void is pretty nasty for Stall to handle, but at the same time it's a lot weaker without boosting moves, so a dedicated special wall can tank it once Trick and / or Dark Void have been used up.
tl ; dr I support testing this.
__________________
|
|
|
|
|
#10 |
|
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 400
The Round Stable
|
Darkrai wouldn't stay for long in DW unless Blaziken were reintroduced to offset it (something I wouldn't be impartial to).
__________________
|
|
|
|
|
#11 |
|
schemes and plots are the same thing
![]() ![]()
Join Date: Jun 2010
Posts: 1,023
Michigan
|
I said this in irc last night but I figured that I would just rehash it here.
The problem with dream world is that half of the players want to see more bans and reach a ban list similar to the one seen in OverUsed. The other half of the players are all for less bans and testing the boundaries of what is actually broken. The first section won the Blaziken vote, so introducing Darkrai seems extremely counterproductive to what happened before. If we unban Darkrai we may as well just reverse the decision on Blaziken. Before we get too far into testing I really think we should consider what we want out of the dream world meta-game, more bans or less.
__________________
![]() |
|
|
|
|
#12 | |
|
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 547
|
Okay, looking back at the Smogon philosophy.
Quote:
In all, the DW tier is fine as it is. The only thing I'm really looking towards banning is maybe Garchomp (Sand Veil is ridiculous. I've lost like 3 matches to it). Even then, I can still deal with it with some luck and prediction. >.> |
|
|
|
|
|
#13 |
|
(e^(i╥))+1=0
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 307
|
Darkrai is obviously going to have a huge impact on the metagame. If its brought in on the revenge kill it has an 80% shot of taking out at least one counter before the opponent can even touch it due to its whopping base 120 speed. Darkrai's two big uber factors are Dark Void and Nasty Plot respectively. If any test were to be conducted it would focus around how easily Darkrai could eliminate opposing threats with Dark Void, and its power once it starts sweeping. I would be open to a test, but I have a feeling that it won't stay in DW OU for long. Still, the knowledge we would gain from testing it would be quite useful for determining how our approach to the future of DW OU will change apart from standard OU. As another point- testing it can't really do much harm. It only has to be for a month. We can always ban it if it appears to be too strong. Just my two cents.
|
|
|
|
|
#14 | |
|
no.... no i do not look like psyduck
![]() ![]() ![]()
Moderator
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 3,988
play?
|
Quote:
It's just the ending to this sentence assumes all of us can tell the difference between the "suspect" and its respective "balanced metagame", as if we already have a balanced tier. Dream World, like any tier, is usually under constant monitorization and ongoing trial-and-error runs until the high and mighty are confident that the metagame has settled to a degree where it's not stale, repeatitive, etc. To add, it may well be just as beneficial to assess new ways to improve team diversity and structure. We should thrive on multiple styles of building teams around weather/offense/defense/ etc. People feel like a "suspect" imposes on their will to consider other options and new ways to manipulate the metagame. Take a decently minded player when (bam) sparks a fresh idea up in their head, yet knowing deep-down, they would have to stretch the boundaries of what is competitively viable to actually build something that is innovative as it is effective. Sure, Darkrai would mix up Dream World. I know from personal experience it is one of the most dominating Uber Pokemon because it does seem to possess that "x-factor" by sweeping teams outright or least severely weakening the spine of the opponent' core well enough to gather enough information to take advantage of the game you're in. I asked people's thoughts on Blaziken on one occasion and the majority seemed optomostic about remaining vigilant and standing firm on his position in DW. Out of the blue, or on one day for some reason a change of heart occurs and... well we know where that story went. Hell, I did ask our some council members/leaders what would come of Dream World and the direction with which we wanted it to go. I don't remember getting a clear response though afterall, we are running this together.
__________________
|
|
|
|
|
|
#15 |
|
wubwubwub
![]() ![]() ![]()
Join Date: May 2006
Posts: 3,117
wubwubwub
|
I don't think there's anything that is broken in the current DW OU tier, and the council and other people have already heard my blunt opinions that I think things should start getting unbanned. Darkrai is one of the few mons I think is worth at least a trial run in the tier and I'll explain why. The only other mons I would even *consider* testing are Blaziken, Deoxys, Deoxys-A, and Skymin.
Firstly, Darkrai has a handful of things going against it in DW that Standard OU does not have. - Genesect - Excadrill - Keldeo - Technician Breloom - Manaphy in rain - Deoxys-S - Scarf Chandelure Overheat - the popularity of Chople TTar - Blaziken COUGHUNBANITCOUGHCOUGHGHGH ...among other things. Darkrai also has serious 4 moveslot syndrome, having to choose between Dark Void+Dark Pulse and then a combo of Nasty Plot/Focus Blast/Substitute. So basically, it has to choose between a boosting move, type coverage, or protection from revenge kills....and it can't have all 3. Dark is terrible typing both offensively and defensively, with no notable resistances in DW OU other than Chandelure's Shadow Ball. Keep in mind that the only Dark attack that is seen in DW is Tyranitar's Pursuit. Offensively, 6 of the top 10 most used pokemon resist Dark and only one is weak to it. If Darkrai switches in, it's after something just died. Using Darkrai makes you play 6-on-5 for the whole match. It is 100% dependent on Dark Void hitting AND the other pokemon staying asleep for multiple turns. Darkrai also has great Speed, but it can't do anything to Choice Scarf users. And there are shitloads of viable ones in the tier, most of which have super effective moves against Darkrai (or STAB moves that can OHKO it outright). And lastly....lol Focus Blast is it's only viable non-Dark attack. Maybe we should have a mini-tournament on this subforum instead of unleashing it on the ladder? This way we could make intelligent posts with actual matches to back up our opinions. It would also boost forum and IRC activity!
__________________
NIGMAN: JRRRR IS A SHIT NIGMAN: HO ESLE THINK IT?? |
|
|
|
|
#16 |
|
no.... no i do not look like psyduck
![]() ![]() ![]()
Moderator
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 3,988
play?
|
There aren't many viable Choice Scarf users outside of Chandelure, Genesect, Politoed and perhaps Garchomp. DW has a variety of ways to strike first through exceedingly fast Pokemon like Deo-S and Excadrill; additionally hard-hitting, priority users such as Breloom and Dragonite. This was not enough fire power to hold Blaziken in DW, for its set wasn't so straightforward and predictable.
I am willing to test Darkrai but strongly dissaprove how we banish Blaziken, yet should be aware it takes a little initiative to summon Darkrai when the advangtage is there for the taking. Tyranitar has to choose between Lum Berry / Chople Berry / Air Balloon and the like, which means you're relying on whether the opponent selects right move or not. All in all, I just feel if we test Darkrai now it would disrupt the balance within DW that the council feels we now possess. Just remember this Pokemon has dominated the Ubers ladder so regardless of our outlook on DW's standing, do not be too surprised if we see an immediate impact. Dark/Fighting is perfect coverage, no matter how you look at it.
__________________
|
|
|
|
|
#17 |
|
Laying the Groundwork for the Pound Work
![]() ![]()
|
The main problem that Darkrai has though over other Pokemon is that it has Dark Void. This means it can come in, basically outspeed the entire metagame, and make one Pokemon completely useless for the entire game. It's not that it's too powerful or anything, but its speed and access to one of the best sleep moves in the game (fuck BW mechanics) means that it is guaranteed to put one of your opponent's Pokemon out of commission (unless everything decides to start running Lum Berry). I also feel that preparing for both Dark Void and Shadow Tag Chandelure will make the metagame very unhealthy, and will basically put an end to stall teams.
Edit: Oh, there's also the option of every team running Rain + Manaphy, but that means Darkrai is overcentralized, which sucks.
__________________
![]() |
|
|
|
|
#18 | |||
|
wubwubwub
![]() ![]() ![]()
Join Date: May 2006
Posts: 3,117
wubwubwub
|
Quote:
Quote:
performance in Ubers doesn't matter!!!!!!!!!!!!! This is an OU discussion!!! Quote:
Compared to now, where "every team" runs Tyranitar + Excadrill? I'd say that having people more run Rain + Manaphy would be a positive thing for the metagame...especially when you talk about "centralization"
__________________
NIGMAN: JRRRR IS A SHIT NIGMAN: HO ESLE THINK IT?? |
|||
|
|
|
|
#19 |
|
no.... no i do not look like psyduck
![]() ![]() ![]()
Moderator
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 3,988
play?
|
Everyone can easily understand which Pokemon check Darkrai. They are either Scarfed, Excadrill/Deo-s and Breloom, at least for the most part.
Garchomp's mere presense is enough to scare the life out of anyone playing against it, so he should be included in the same vien as TTar/Exca when we are to assume sand is everywhere. Why some may feel Darkrai may help shift the momentum in a new direction, this experiment is likely to end with the same controversial arguments for and against regarding how lenient we wish to be with our suspects, and the future of Dream World. This was not the case with Blaziken as people would prefer if Sun were to be completely non-viable from there-on-afterwards. Darkrai isn't necessarily going to favor anything but provide sand with a universal sweeper, and a newer way to exploit scenarios where you need Darkrai to expose the opponents' team. I would expect roughly the same "sand cores", just with Darkrai leading the line. All you have to do is time your Dark Void right and follow with Nasty Plot. The player with Darkrai practically forces the opponent to into submission as he is left with two options: get swept or prematurely summon their Darkrai check (which if not Genesect's Scarf U-turn) locks them into a move where the trainer using Darkrai can capitalize on by setting up a sweeper who resists the Choice-locked Pokemon. Tanga Berry could be used to ensure you sleep a Pokemon, followed by the opponent's switch to Genesect as I am able to use Nasty Plot. Meaning there's a good chance I can faint the incomming Pokemon with that neutral coverage. If a Pokemon performs extensively well in a tier with a higher demand for effectively constructed offensive/defensive teams, due to the options available, then to stand out in that tier is worth noting for our beloved yet still blossoming Dream World metagame. I am on board with the tournament proposal, perhaps with those other Pokemon mentioned in this thread.
__________________
|
|
|
|
|
#20 | |
|
Join Date: Nov 2010
Posts: 596
Row! Row! Fight the power!
|
Quote:
Off-topic but if it's about banning the starter all together, than I agree with you (doubt there's anywhere where this proposal can be made). |
|
|
|
|
|
#21 |
|
I love weather; Sun for days
![]() ![]() ![]()
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 3,573
Where the Sun finally sets
|
I just don't see the reason "why not?" Yes, we just banned Blaziken. Yes Darkrai was banned in the first suspect test. But if the idea of Dream World is to be open, more alluring, and less strict to all (which we have included completely), then I don't see why not. The worst case is Darkrai is too much for Dream World to handle (1-2 weeks tops of it on the ladder) or it is proven to be enough of a suspect to inspire debate (3-infinite weeks tops). If it isn't as bad as we say, and we can, then we have a sweet new pokemon to play with. If it is then we're no worse off then we started.
I don't like the tournament idea. Mostly because tournaments take a bit to set up through the TDs and secondly it's open to the public who just want to play. If they care about DW they'll play on the ladder and give their opinion, not just play in a tournament with Darkrai in their team. |
|
|
|
|
#22 |
|
I love weather; Sun for days
![]() ![]() ![]()
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 3,573
Where the Sun finally sets
|
I can't figure out how to edit my post right now but listen.
In regards to Taylor: either Darkrai is too strong in sand (who is taking sand + LO damage or sand + sub damage, both of which are retarded completely), or it is another asset for rain, sun, and non-weather teams to use in regards to sand (really? you're going to bring in Excadrill or Garchomp against my Darkrai? Be more cute, please). Darkrai without TrickScarf or Life Orb isn't a Darkrai to be scared about. A worse Special Attack than Volcarona with, arguably, worse typing. Or Alakazam with worse type coverage? Yes it is fast as hell with an 80% sleep move, but let's not forget the move Stone Edge (also called Stone Miss). Stone Edge has been, without a doubt, the most disappointing move in anyone's match through 4th through 5th gen. Maybe that's just because of its distribution, which is much larger than Dark Void, but if you hate Stone Edge's miss factor then you have to hate Dark Void equally. It's no Spore. |
|
|
|
|
#23 | |||
|
COME FORTH
Join Date: Feb 2012
Posts: 1,055
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
...
Last edited by Princess Bri; Aug 5th, 2012 at 4:13:07 AM. |
|||
|
|
|
|
#24 |
|
I love weather; Sun for days
![]() ![]() ![]()
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 3,573
Where the Sun finally sets
|
Perfect coverage isn't everything, and everyone seems to think it is. Dark + Fighting is "perfect" THAT IS SUPER COOL!!!! No, super effective is what wins games, or rather if you're so fucking pumped up (see +4 Volcarona or the fuck whatever) then you're sweeping without issue. Dragon + Ground + Fire is the best coverage I can think of right now, and that only works because of those three attack type coverage + stab. Dark + Fighting with Sleep / NP / HP Ice / Sub isn't that threatening. Four moveslot syndrome is such a common thing for Darkrai that I'm astounded you don't think it's worth a shot. Also I was wrong about Volcarona, I was looking at Darm-Z for some reason.
|
|
|
|
|
#25 | |
|
no.... no i do not look like psyduck
![]() ![]() ![]()
Moderator
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 3,988
play?
|
Darkrai 2HKOs Uber stall teams, and that is without Chandelure picking off anything who can go toe-to-toe with said suspect. He can be checked but that goes for just about every Pokemon in the game bar Arceus.
I'd take a pure Dark type over something taking 50% damage for merely switching in. Quote:
Basically you have Dark/Fighting coverage with the offensive stats and speed to make most of the tier unusable because why would you pass up on the advantage that is there for the taking. Dark with STAB is resisted by Dark, Steel and Fighting; two of which are hit for super effective damage by Focus Blast. How can Alakazam have better coverage when Darkrai can already hit everything for neutral damage? If anything, the sleep inducing move and speed outweigh the benefits of Magic Guard as far as competitive battles on our ladder are concerned.
__________________
|
|
|
|
| Thread Tools | |
|
|