Birkal
We have the technology.
Hello! As the result of this thread, we will be implementing a list of banned abilities from future CAP discussions. The purpose of this thread is to create a banlist that will remove abilities that impede the process and make typical CAP conversations difficult. I implore you to read the original post of the thread to get a full understanding of why this was agreed upon by the PRC.
So, we'll essentially be treating this like a typical CAP ability discussion. I'll keep track of lists at the bottom of this post about what we have and have not discussed. Let's try to get through this quickly and concisely. As a rule of thumb, if the discussion of one ability derails this thread, it likely should be banned from regular CAP discussion. Also, as this is a hard banlist, I prefer to err on the side of caution. If we think that an ability is possible for some concepts, I personally would like to see it unbanned. I'll try to work off of the community consensus here as much as possible. As usual, don't be afraid to PM me with questions or thoughts!
Discussed
Arena Trap
Cute Charm
Drizzle
Drought
Sand Stream
Sand Veil, Snow Cloak, Tangled Feet
Serene Grace
Snow Warning
Speed Boost
Stench
Super Luck, Sniper
Big Pecks
Flower Gift
Friend Guard
Healer
Honey Gather
Illuminate
Pickup
Run Away
Telepathy
To save on time, feel free to copy/paste your posts from that thread into this one if your thoughts on Proposal 4's specifics are still the same.
So, we'll essentially be treating this like a typical CAP ability discussion. I'll keep track of lists at the bottom of this post about what we have and have not discussed. Let's try to get through this quickly and concisely. As a rule of thumb, if the discussion of one ability derails this thread, it likely should be banned from regular CAP discussion. Also, as this is a hard banlist, I prefer to err on the side of caution. If we think that an ability is possible for some concepts, I personally would like to see it unbanned. I'll try to work off of the community consensus here as much as possible. As usual, don't be afraid to PM me with questions or thoughts!
To see his reasoning, check out Proposal 4 in this post.
DougJustDoug's Suggested Banlist:Moody
Multitype
Drizzle, Drought, Sand Stream, Snow Warning
Wonder Guard
Imposter
Huge Power, Pure Power
Multiscale
Shadow Tag, Arena Trap,Magnet Pull
Speed Boost
Skill Link
Color Change
Forecast, Zen Mode
Normalize
Stall
Slow Start
Truant
Scrappy
Bad Dreams
Sand Veil, Snow Cloak, Tangled Feet
Super Luck, Sniper
Cute Charm
Stench
Serene Grace
Teravolt, Turboblaze
Victory StarDougJustDoug's Suggested Banlist from Non-Flavor Discussions:
DougJustDoug's Suggested Banlist:
Multitype
Drizzle, Drought, Sand Stream, Snow Warning
Imposter
Huge Power, Pure Power
Shadow Tag, Arena Trap,
Speed Boost
Sand Veil, Snow Cloak, Tangled Feet
Super Luck, Sniper
Cute Charm
Stench
Serene Grace
Victory Star
Big Pecks
Flower Gift
Friend Guard
Healer
Honey Gather
Illuminate
Pickup
Run Away
Telepathy
Flower Gift
Friend Guard
Healer
Honey Gather
Illuminate
Pickup
Run Away
Telepathy
Discussed
Flower Gift - Unban
Magnet Pull - Unban
Multiscale - Unban
Skill Link - Unban
Stall - Unban
Scrappy - Unban
Air Lock - Ban
Bad Dreams - Ban
Color Change - Ban
Defeatist - Ban
Forecast - Ban
Huge Power - Ban
Imposter - Ban
Moody - Ban
Multitype - Ban
Pure Power - Ban
Shadow Tag - Ban
Slow Start - Ban
Teravolt - Ban
Truant - Ban
Turboblaze - Ban
Victory Star - Ban
Wonder Guard - Ban
Zen Mode - Ban
Discussed FlavorMagnet Pull - Unban
Multiscale - Unban
Skill Link - Unban
Stall - Unban
Scrappy - Unban
Air Lock - Ban
Bad Dreams - Ban
Color Change - Ban
Defeatist - Ban
Forecast - Ban
Huge Power - Ban
Imposter - Ban
Moody - Ban
Multitype - Ban
Pure Power - Ban
Shadow Tag - Ban
Slow Start - Ban
Teravolt - Ban
Truant - Ban
Turboblaze - Ban
Victory Star - Ban
Wonder Guard - Ban
Zen Mode - Ban
Hyper Cutter - Unban
Normalize - Ban
Not DiscussedNormalize - Ban
Arena Trap
Cute Charm
Drizzle
Drought
Sand Stream
Sand Veil, Snow Cloak, Tangled Feet
Serene Grace
Snow Warning
Speed Boost
Stench
Super Luck, Sniper
Big Pecks
Flower Gift
Friend Guard
Healer
Honey Gather
Illuminate
Pickup
Run Away
Telepathy