Ok so what I'm going to show you is the long way of doing it. See what Itchni did for Paperblade for what I sort of generally expect from a person doing a read on another person. I'll do the short way in a bit on someone else for a good example of that. Want to do the long way on Orcinus because my gut was yelling scum from the Itchni lynch. I like being thorough when I'm listening to my gut.
BEWARE WALL OF TEXT
OK let's be productive here
Please answer the following questions
1). Is it a better strategy to be bold or to be a coward in NOC games, and what strategy will you adopt?
2). What are your thoughts on having a "town innocent child"?
3). What do you think game setup is?
4). Bank account and pin?
Icebreakers. His answers to them are fine. First question could be seen as role fishing though. Not necessarily scummy, but is a bit anti-town in that knowing a PR helps the mafia more than it does help the village. Third could be seen as mafia fishing to see if there might be evidence of a neutral. That's a stretch though.
Stuff with aura guardian happens with lists for like 5 posts. Orcinus Duo overreacts a bit, but given it's just getting out of random vote stage, that's understandable. Pro-town to try to get something started, although his way of doing it is poorly executed.
So you should do that coolking
And itchni and Jalmont because they're lurking this thread
Also, additional question: How should the detective use their night action?
I would definitely encourage them to use their abilities on the inactives. There is almost other no way to find an inactive scum when there are multiple inactive townies, and this is the case in many smogon NOCs.
Mostly null, slight scum on the inspection part. Mafia can often say nothing, but they're more likely to be "active lurkers" than full-on lurkers. Also could just be seen as just a philosophy difference, because the advice can seem reasonable.
I don't know who to rage at, coolking for encouraging answering surveys and then not doing so himself (yeah I agree that was defensive), or Jalmont and itchni for being dicks, or Paperblade for not saying anything. Seriously guys we have 48 hours. That's nothing. Start giving villy something to go on please.
Haha Paperblade ninja. I don't think voting red is a good way to go. If you're going by useless "I want to talk about something else but I'm not going to talk about it", might as well vote coolking.
I think lynching an active on day one isn't a good way to go. There's not much information to go on, and so I don't believe in the success rate of such a vote. I'd rather lynch an inactive, and let the actives give us more information to make a more informed lynch later on in the game.
Not lynching an active, got it. I agree with this for the most part. The thing about Rediamond is something to keep in mind but isn't particularly scummy. The pseudo-pressure on coolking is justified from his prior post, but he doesn't seem sold on a coolking lynch for some reason. Slight inconsistency, but not something to call scummy.
Oh ok then
##Unvote
##Lynch Itchni
NOC is based on analyzing social behavior. If you're not going to make an effort to make sure town trusts you, then I don't actually think you're worth keeping around. Might as well test our 'luck' with you.
Reasonable. Itchni was being unhelpful at this point.
Ok actually
Since itchni isn't going to give us anything to go on because he's playing this game by luck, I opt that detective investigates him tonight, and we pressure, as jalmont's said, Walrein or dp67
Itchni wanting to lynch a vanilla today is ridiculous. Why don't you volunteer then?
Role fishingggggggggggggggggg
Mentions pressuring
dp67 and walrein. He NEVER goes on to pressure dp67 ever. We know how dp67 flipped. Scummy by association.
Yeah ok
##Unvote
##Vote Walrein
Encouraging wagon
Would also like to call out Cereza
Got pressure on walrein to get off his ass and post. Pro-town. Calls out Cereza without actually saying anything. Null to slightly scum. Null because context helps, and cereza wasnt really doing a whole lot, so there wasn't much to say about what she had already said. Slightly scum because it still is kind of just floated out there nonchalantly.
Is voting PokemonRocks for stupidity a valid reason
lol
Ok now I'm tired thanks to posting this the long way. I'll look at the rest later.
ATM nothing too awful stands out, but there is some slightly scum leaning stuff so far.