Here's my problem with the miller claiming: it is literally the easiest role to fakeclaim in the history of mafia. "I turned up maf on inspect? Uh... uh... I'm m-m-miller. Yep. That's it." Granted, the existence of the godfather makes it so that only the hooker can claim miller, but still, all someone claiming miller does is give them a 50% chance of being mafia. THAT BEING SAID I do have an idea that would make this work: 1. Miller claims 2a. If there is no counterclaim, we assume he's real. 2b. If there is a counterclaim, we lynch the sketchier one. If he flips hooker, he's probably legit, but incase of bussing, cop inspects the other claim. A guilty means he's legit, an innocent means he's godfather. If he flips miller, we lynch the other guy, no questions asked. If he flips godfather, the other guy's probably legit, but there's no way to tell that the real miller is simply inactive/keeping quiet for some reason. Flaws with this plan: It could be considered a tad bit all-or-nothing, requiring us to drop everything and test this. If both mafians cc miller, things get a lot more complicated (however we've also achieved a 66% chance of hitting scum so lol) The cop must be alive and unhooked, and the miller claiming makes it mathematically more probable that he will be hooked or killed. Because of the above, we'd have to do it today. Basically, this plan is basically guaranteed to kill at least one scum; however, the possibility of at least one mislynch is also high. The question is, are we willing to risk it? I'd like opinions.