Corporal Levi
ninjadog of the decade
Starly is really bad, but that's why it's being nominated for D rank, which is mostly reserved for really bad Pokemon that aren't wholly outclassed by anything specific (Psyduck, Goomy, Trapinch, etc). Starly is on a whole different level from Fletchling in terms of power, so you can't really say Fletchling outclasses Starly at all, even though I think we can all reasonably agree that Fletchling is the drastically better Pokemon in general. It's not completely outclassed by Taillow because it can run a much, much more powerful Choice Scarf set, taking advantage of Reckless Brave Bird and Double Edge; as a non-Choiced Pokemon, Taillow is significantly better because it can take advantage of Guts, of course. It's not wholly outclassed by Doduo because even though Doduo is faster, around same powerful, and has Knock Off, Starly has one advantage in U-Turn, allowing it to scout, which is actually pretty nice for bird offense when paired with Diglett. Starly's advantages are small, and it's rarely worth a spot on a team, but because it has those unique advantages that MIGHT be exactly what some really really weird team needs, it warrants a placement in D.
Of course, if we go by that, there are a few D rank mons that I'd like to move up, but to be frank, I don't really for such low-ranked mons enough to bring them up :D
One Pokemon I'd like to see moving up is Gastly; B+ seems like a nice place for it. I started using it because Missy is a goner, and I'm actually fairly impressed by its performance. The set I've been using is the Life Orb set, which is a phenomenal stallbreaker; Munchlax and Specially Defensive Lickitung are the only Pokemon able to avoid the 2HKO, and if they get poisoned by Sludge Bomb, which has a 51% chance of happening over two Sludge Bombs, they won't be around for long, either. Without Misdreavus, 18 Speed is now an even better Speed tier, only outsped by Abra, Diglett, and a bunch of normally irrelevant things, meaning LO Gastly can pull its weight against offensive teams as well, coming in on one of the many Pokemon it outspeeds and, if the Pokemon is weakened, often guaranteeing a KO due to the sheer power of its STABs preventing safe switch-ins.
196 SpA Life Orb Gastly Sludge Bomb vs. 132 HP / 28 SpD Zigzagoon: 21-27 (95.4 - 122.7%) -- 93.8% chance to OHKO
196 SpA Life Orb Gastly Sludge Bomb vs. 0 HP / 36 SpD Eviolite Mienfoo: 13-17 (61.9 - 80.9%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
196 SpA Life Orb Gastly Sludge Bomb vs. 236 HP / 76+ SpD Eviolite Porygon: 9-13 (34.6 - 50%) -- 87.9% chance to 2HKO after Stealth Rock
I can't speak for the Choice sets because I haven't been using them myself, but I'm really liking the raw power LO Gastly brings to the table. I personally prefer it over LO Abra despite Abra's greater Speed and lack of recoil, because Gastly's STABs are just so much better. Gastly won't be taking a hit any time soon, but neither will the opponent, which is nice because Gastly is really fast.
Speaking of Abra, I'd like to see it moved up to A. It can't beat both Stall and Offense, but depending on its set, it's an enormous headache to at least one of them, meaning it's ridiculously easy to fit onto almost any offensive or balanced team if the team is in need of a safety net or a wall-breaker. We all know about Abra's capabilities as a safety net; stick it onto your team and be completely covered against one set-up sweeper, granting offensive teams, which would often otherwise be ended by a single mistake, much more breathing room, which is, of course, incredibly useful. I've personally been having much more trouble dealing with Life Orb Abra. Even though it can't come in on anything, its great Speed tier means that it can still act as some sort of revenge-killer (just not for set-up sweepers, unless it's Bulk Up Timburr). Once it's in, things tend to crumble; once again, we are left with Specially Defensive Lickitung and Munchlax as the sole Pokemon that can wall it. Just kidding; it gets Psyshock! Thus, Berry Juice Munchlax is left as the only Pokemon that can avoid the 2HKO. Basically, once Life Orb Abra comes in safely, something dies.
Maybe it's just my playstyle or my teams, but I find fast glass cannons to be very difficult to deal with, and LO Gastly and LO Abra are probably the two most effective threats in that category. Their ability to almost entirely dismantle stall while getting kills pretty much every time they enter play against offensive teams renders them incredibly dangerous Pokemon, and arguably worth moving up.
Of course, if we go by that, there are a few D rank mons that I'd like to move up, but to be frank, I don't really for such low-ranked mons enough to bring them up :D
One Pokemon I'd like to see moving up is Gastly; B+ seems like a nice place for it. I started using it because Missy is a goner, and I'm actually fairly impressed by its performance. The set I've been using is the Life Orb set, which is a phenomenal stallbreaker; Munchlax and Specially Defensive Lickitung are the only Pokemon able to avoid the 2HKO, and if they get poisoned by Sludge Bomb, which has a 51% chance of happening over two Sludge Bombs, they won't be around for long, either. Without Misdreavus, 18 Speed is now an even better Speed tier, only outsped by Abra, Diglett, and a bunch of normally irrelevant things, meaning LO Gastly can pull its weight against offensive teams as well, coming in on one of the many Pokemon it outspeeds and, if the Pokemon is weakened, often guaranteeing a KO due to the sheer power of its STABs preventing safe switch-ins.
196 SpA Life Orb Gastly Sludge Bomb vs. 132 HP / 28 SpD Zigzagoon: 21-27 (95.4 - 122.7%) -- 93.8% chance to OHKO
196 SpA Life Orb Gastly Sludge Bomb vs. 0 HP / 36 SpD Eviolite Mienfoo: 13-17 (61.9 - 80.9%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
196 SpA Life Orb Gastly Sludge Bomb vs. 236 HP / 76+ SpD Eviolite Porygon: 9-13 (34.6 - 50%) -- 87.9% chance to 2HKO after Stealth Rock
I can't speak for the Choice sets because I haven't been using them myself, but I'm really liking the raw power LO Gastly brings to the table. I personally prefer it over LO Abra despite Abra's greater Speed and lack of recoil, because Gastly's STABs are just so much better. Gastly won't be taking a hit any time soon, but neither will the opponent, which is nice because Gastly is really fast.
Speaking of Abra, I'd like to see it moved up to A. It can't beat both Stall and Offense, but depending on its set, it's an enormous headache to at least one of them, meaning it's ridiculously easy to fit onto almost any offensive or balanced team if the team is in need of a safety net or a wall-breaker. We all know about Abra's capabilities as a safety net; stick it onto your team and be completely covered against one set-up sweeper, granting offensive teams, which would often otherwise be ended by a single mistake, much more breathing room, which is, of course, incredibly useful. I've personally been having much more trouble dealing with Life Orb Abra. Even though it can't come in on anything, its great Speed tier means that it can still act as some sort of revenge-killer (just not for set-up sweepers, unless it's Bulk Up Timburr). Once it's in, things tend to crumble; once again, we are left with Specially Defensive Lickitung and Munchlax as the sole Pokemon that can wall it. Just kidding; it gets Psyshock! Thus, Berry Juice Munchlax is left as the only Pokemon that can avoid the 2HKO. Basically, once Life Orb Abra comes in safely, something dies.
Maybe it's just my playstyle or my teams, but I find fast glass cannons to be very difficult to deal with, and LO Gastly and LO Abra are probably the two most effective threats in that category. Their ability to almost entirely dismantle stall while getting kills pretty much every time they enter play against offensive teams renders them incredibly dangerous Pokemon, and arguably worth moving up.