Sorry for the wall of text. :/
I still find it really weird that @
Aura Guardian felt the need to claim. I understand you did it to try and "save the BG" but a claimed BG is a dead man walking anyway so revealing ANOTHER power role seems really unnecessary. Even if you can save him the only person (according to you) that he can protect to remain alive is you, which pretty much gives the mafia free rein to kill whoever else they want. I'd much rather Celever protect whoever he wants, whether it be A_G or someone else so the mafia have to play a guessing game for who they choose to kill.
Agreeing with the majority that I couldn't locate @
Zyphirex's Blackhawk11 and Woodchuck connection. The only connection I see is that they were voting the same way (for Celever) for awhile? But he said he'd give us evidence so I'll wait and see. Other than that he calls my interaction with Celever "suspicious" which really tells me nothing. I don't really get why some people piled their votes on him so suddenly (Blackhawk11, Celever, now Houndoomsday since I've been posting this) when he said he'd post the evidence. If his evidence isn't substantial enough I understand voting for him then, but I don't really see anything so scummy about him for now.
I disagree with @
Celever that being lazy is scummy. Being lazy just means the player is disinterested in the game, which could go for either village or mafia. And don't you have Jalmont as a town read? He is easily the laziest one in the game right now...
@
Houndoomsday's post #511 is p. scummy because he resorts to tons of WIFOM ("if I was mafia why would I do this?") as his defense. I do believe that there is a possibility that his assumption of scum daytalk could have been a scumslip.
@
Walrein I certainly hope you will try to read the thread because that's really the only way you're going to get accurately caught up. Also everyone lynch Walrein he is noncommital!
I'd like to clarify that I obviously was not aware that Celever was the bodyguard when I was pressuring him. He sure wasn't playing like it (jumping at any little thing to make someone seem suspicious instead of playing more lowkey) and some people really don't seem to understand (Snaquaza and Celever in particular) that villagers are not privy to the fact that they are mislynching
other villagers. So no, I did not "look bad coming out of it".
Ok so I looked over the thread and will now read a few people. I'll start with the two people I've talked the most about this day (that haven't claimed power roles) Metal Sonic and Jalmont. Then I will proceed with Snaquaza who is my new biggest scumread (congrats!). I'll stop there for now because I'm getting tired of typing...
@
Metal Sonic: I have pretty much already given my views on Metal Sonic today. His first post I now interpret as a blatant troll that some people took seriously and thought was town. Trolling isn't indicative of town or scum, especially with Metal Sonic, so that post is null. He then posts some pretty premature reads which were obviously lacking but it was so early on in the game that that isn't really a big deal. I already explained that I don't like Metal Sonic bullying Celever into voting for barty when barty had plenty of pressure at that time. On top of that Metal Sonic didn't contribute anything else and seemed only concerned in getting barty at L-1. Once again this does seem to be normal Metal Sonic behavior (looking at MFtD for reference) but that doesn't mean I have to like it. Then Metal Sonic apparently catches that Celever claimed power role when no one else did, which is +townie points because he could have just let everyone keep pressuring Celever and wasting more time if he was mafia (though this is WIFOM so a very minor point). Overall,
Null, very slight Town.
@
Jalmont: Jalmont hasn't really done much all game. He's been flying under the radar the whole game and posting only the bare minimum. It's possible that this is due to time constraints, but his vote is currently on no lynch which is unacceptable and I don't understand why people are just letting this go. I already stated previously that his first non-RVS post was "fluffy" (telling everyone that there's an unlimited deadline, etc.). His next few posts are much better, however, (wtf did I miss these the first time through?) and bring up many valid points about Solar Vapor. For some reason I had thought Jalmont did nothing all game but I come to find out he is capable of contributing something! This makes it more inexcusable for his lack of activity and his current vote of no lynch. Again I've been posting my beef with Jalmont for a lot of the game, so the only new additions are the posts where he calls out Solar Vapor (pointing out his summarizing etc.), I just disagree with his reasons because that sounds exactly like Shining Latios to me. His refusal to give any reads/votes is still really annoying. Overall,
Null and pissing me off.
@
Snaquaza: I know he subbed in for Marquis, but Marquis seemed like a very capable mafia player and he subbed out too early for me to get a good read on him, so I'm going to ignore what he contributed for this read. Starting off, the entirety of his post #214 is summarizing. He claims that this is just to help himself, but I really don't buy that and that post was completely unnecessary. He could have just pulled up another document and summarized the game for himself there instead of clogging the thread with it. There is only one reason why anyone would post summaries, and it's to
seem active without contributing anything. Is it just me or was his post #290 extremely complicated to understand? For instance:
Snaquaza said:
I see this as a nooby post of Celever as of which you can’t know anything as it is really something for him to do this.
Snaquaza said:
well BtB tries to make him look the best person as all he does is good
Please clarify what these statements mean because I have no clue. :/
His list of reads in post #306 pretty much say absolutely nothing. For example, he calls Solar Vapor's posts "good" which is the furthest extent he goes to describe the posts, and cxinlee's posts say "just enough" to make him think he's town. Additionally, I have responded to his lynch vote on me, but he has yet to give me a followup or even acknowledge my defense so I don't even know where his head is at at the moment. Other then this he hasn't made a worthwhile post in a long time, and litters the thread with one liners that don't even contribute to the game and seem to only exist to make him look active (I can quote some if you want I am just tired of this right now). Overall,
Scum.
Unvote Jalmont
Vote Snaquaza
A lot of you ninja'd me because this took forever btw.