I'm not a big thrash metal fan, so my top 4 is probably most of the thrash bands I listen to. I just feel like a lot of it starts to sound the same after a while, so when I get past the big name bands, everything else is boring.
Metallica and Megadeth are at the top here, they just seem to have something more. I don't think I really need to explain myself, because most of y'all know what I'm talking about.
White Zombie and Pantera, I kind of group them together, because those are the bands that I call thrash, but I've heard some people call groove metal (I don't know what that means).
Metal Gods said:
I hate Pantera with a passion. They are the band that wrote the birth stone for nu metal and all the brocore genres, in my opinion. Vulgar Display of Power is the birth stone. Looking for immature whinny lyrics about how tough you are? Looking for a vocalist who is screaming and straining his voice, to the point he sounds like a fourth grade bully? Just listen to Phil on that album. For the most part, Darrell's riffs just consist of down-tuned chords. Sometimes palm muted for that extra "hardcore" effect. No disrespect to the memory of someone who seemed like a really nice guy, but the irritating riffs and aimless solos show a guy who needed more practice, and was no guitar god.
My unbiased opinion here, Pantera's Power Metal is their only album I can tolerate. It's the first album after their glam days, and the album before their groove era. Phil's vocals on here aren't bad at all. Had they kept making albums like this, I might enjoy them. Kinda funny how the band pretend this album doesn't exist.
I see where you're coming from here, but actually I don't mind nu metal at all. I don't really love it, but some of the bands and some of the songs I can really get behind (of course, I don't go overboard because there are some nu metal bands that are complete shit. But there are shitty thrash bands too). Pantera's Power Metal, thankfully, isn't glam metal or power metal, so it doesn't really offend me, but it bores me to death. It's nothing new, just second rate thrash metal that wouldn't have been discovered if they hadn't changed it up on their next album.
The only other thrash band I listen to is Early Man.
edit: oh shit metal church haha! I forgot about them, Metal Church slays.
speaking of things that slay, slayer is not a very good band. Their early album is listenable, but their most well known album is just too fast, I guess they wanted to push it to see how fast metal could be made? Anyway, maybe y'all's brains work faster than mine, but I can't understand what they are playing or process any of it because it's just too fast. At least their first album is maybe 15% slower, but I can actually feel the grooves rather than just let myself be assaulted by it.