My ID and SID were checked loads of times, it was 11:16 AM, I made the game time exact as a world clock, write down the second I pressed continue, I didn't mis-calculate the taps, and yes I double tapped the Happiness checker so all the Pokemon jump up.
Was the date correct?
Also, you don't need the seconds.
All I can think of other than that is maybe you read your AR wrong? (Don't they go in a weird order or something?)
Were either of your parents holding an everstone?