jrrrrrrr
wubwubwub
Salamence was definitely the most overrated pokemon, not just in Gen 4 OU, but out of any tier in any gen ever. Banning it was a huge turning point for this community, and it turned suspect testing into a way for people to ban popular things instead of identifying broken tactics for a more competitive metagame. It was the epitome of the absurd "overcentralizing" argument that was brought up in gen 4, showing that the voters value quantity over quality. The fact that people had issues with Salamence after spending years trying to deal with Garchomp and Lati@s baffles me to this day. Salamence has no longevity, it's destroyed by almost every priority move, was forced to use a Life Orb to hurt anything, and was SR weak in a metagame where the move was basically mandatory for teams. It was a solid pokemon that could dent teams that played against it poorly, but when I came back and found out it got voted Uber I literally laughed out loud.
#2 most overrated in my opinion was Gengar. Ghost was a terrible attacking type, Focus Blast is the worst move in the game, it was Pursuit weak, couldn't beat anything with even a modest SpDef stat, and had 4 moveslot syndrome to boot...but it was still everywhere. It's only real advantage was its 3 immunities, at least after Hypnosis' accuracy was dropped. Good thing Rotom-A came along and showed Gengar what's up.
As for the people saying Scizor...I'd put him high on the list but I think he's actually rated quite well. He got Bullet Punch, Superpower and Bug Bite later on in gen 4 and those moves are all excellent fits for him.
If we're talking about "gen 4" including discussion before it was actually released, then Rhyperior would take the cake. IIRC, Jumpman made a thread called "How do you kill this thing?", citing its decent typing, the new sandstorm spdef boost, and Solid Rock (combined with the first real evidence of a power creep). It was scary, before everyone realized that everything got moves with insanely high base powers that could 1-2hko it. Then we realized Solid Rock wasn't as good as we thought when you're weak to everything. Then we realized that Stone Edge was the second worst move in the game.
#2 most overrated in my opinion was Gengar. Ghost was a terrible attacking type, Focus Blast is the worst move in the game, it was Pursuit weak, couldn't beat anything with even a modest SpDef stat, and had 4 moveslot syndrome to boot...but it was still everywhere. It's only real advantage was its 3 immunities, at least after Hypnosis' accuracy was dropped. Good thing Rotom-A came along and showed Gengar what's up.
As for the people saying Scizor...I'd put him high on the list but I think he's actually rated quite well. He got Bullet Punch, Superpower and Bug Bite later on in gen 4 and those moves are all excellent fits for him.
If we're talking about "gen 4" including discussion before it was actually released, then Rhyperior would take the cake. IIRC, Jumpman made a thread called "How do you kill this thing?", citing its decent typing, the new sandstorm spdef boost, and Solid Rock (combined with the first real evidence of a power creep). It was scary, before everyone realized that everything got moves with insanely high base powers that could 1-2hko it. Then we realized Solid Rock wasn't as good as we thought when you're weak to everything. Then we realized that Stone Edge was the second worst move in the game.