-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
Official MLB 2012 Season Thread
- Thread starter tennisace
- Start date
I must have misread, but last I checked there were only three or four guys in the Jay's regular lineup who actually got on base at a clip above .300. You aren't gonna get that far with only four guys getting on base above 30%...
^Not to mention the Blue Jays trade their pitching talent away as soon as they show promise. I'm still waiting for Romero to be shipped off. It should be coming soon based off of the Carpenter-Halladay-Marcum schedule.
Also,
Here is how Yankee fans support their team:
Step 1) Show up in the 3rd inning
Step 2) Boo their all-star talent
Step 3) Leave after the 7th inning
These playoffs have been a joy to watch other than that Braves-Cardinals game
Also,
Here is how Yankee fans support their team:
Step 1) Show up in the 3rd inning
Step 2) Boo their all-star talent
Step 3) Leave after the 7th inning
These playoffs have been a joy to watch other than that Braves-Cardinals game
The Athletics won their division over the Rangers with even less players that got on base that much, iirc (I honestly think that only Coco Crisp and Cespedes had a .300 OBP...). They were also able to take their division series to a game five against the team that's probably going to win the World Series.
EDIT: Meh, their most commonly used lineups generally included about 5 players with a .300 OBP, so a little better than the Blue Jays. Still quite awful though!
Big difference. A's are what I call a "Three true outcome" offense. They lead the league in Ks, yes, but they also were among league leaders in drawing walks. Something the Jays weren't good at doing. A's also had a crap ton of Homers hit in the second half... Call that a wash with the Jays I guess...
Lol, Sounds about right
And yea, we need to start rebuilding our farm system
To J-Man. Most of the Blue Jays offense had career low years, and halfway through the season they stopped fielding any sort of lineup. The walks are a legitimate concern, but it's not as exaggerated as you state. They are also not completely lost by any means, lol. If we're going to critique anything they've done, my biggest critique is the Houston trade they had this past summer, but they're generally still on the right track for building a solid core. The biggest thing is actually pitching development, because even without walking too much, a healthy Jays offense is still a good - great thing (look at their numbers pre-whole team dying, ie first half)
but Jrrrrr that comment about trading the pitching as soon as they show potential has absolutely no validity to it, as well as no context. Roy Halladay had the most WAR of any pitcher from 2002-2009, and was second to only Johan Santana of all pitchers with 1000 IP in that period. That's not as soon as he shows promise. The point also misses that Roy had an expiring contract, was not going to resign, so they traded him as soon as possible to maximize return value..
and Carpenter hadn't shown anything above mid rotation potential, truthfully, how can you even fault a team when a guy suddenly plays two times better returning from injury..
and for Marcum, it's not even about showing potential. He had already provided years at his maximum value, there's no more potential in that.. And ignoring that, he was traded to get Brett Lawrie.. that's pretty awesome.
essentially, stop linking things that are entirely different scenarios and trying to group them all together to get a storyline. You're missing the real reason that these players were let go.
(also Romero sucks why would anyone want him?)
but Jrrrrr that comment about trading the pitching as soon as they show potential has absolutely no validity to it, as well as no context. Roy Halladay had the most WAR of any pitcher from 2002-2009, and was second to only Johan Santana of all pitchers with 1000 IP in that period. That's not as soon as he shows promise. The point also misses that Roy had an expiring contract, was not going to resign, so they traded him as soon as possible to maximize return value..
and Carpenter hadn't shown anything above mid rotation potential, truthfully, how can you even fault a team when a guy suddenly plays two times better returning from injury..
and for Marcum, it's not even about showing potential. He had already provided years at his maximum value, there's no more potential in that.. And ignoring that, he was traded to get Brett Lawrie.. that's pretty awesome.
essentially, stop linking things that are entirely different scenarios and trying to group them all together to get a storyline. You're missing the real reason that these players were let go.
(also Romero sucks why would anyone want him?)
O HAI DERE MR. STRAWMAN. FANCY MEETING YOU HERE.
e) insulting me while not even staying remotely on the topic of baseball after showing you did not fully comprehend what i just said about the AL East having the potential to fast becoming a cruddy division makes you look like an idiot
Usually when an entire thread thinks you're an idiot...you're an idiot.
P.S. the morons in this thread that think parity is terrible for a sport need to look at the current NFL season and how it's probably the most exciting NFL season for the past few decades and the NFL continues to break ratings records even though there's huge parity which is apparently terrible for a sport.
jesus christ.
P.S. the morons in this thread that think parity is terrible for a sport need to look at the current NFL season and how it's probably the most exciting NFL season for the past few decades and the NFL continues to break ratings records even though there's huge parity which is apparently terrible for a sport.
jesus christ.
And when everyone believes that jumping off the Empire State building without a parachute or any other means of breaking your fall will not result in death...That must mean it won't result in death.
I'm done here. I don't even understand why I'm responding to your insults (WHICH BY THE WAY, INSULTING PEOPLE IS NOT ALLOWED HERE).
You're comparing your baseball ideology to people jumping off the Empire State Building without a parachute.
Dude the AL East is one of the best divisions in baseball, definitely not the worst. The Blue Jays were doing fine before Bautista went down; how would any team do if they lost their star player for half a season? If I had to rank the divisions, I'd go:
NL East
AL West
AL East
NL Central
NL West
-
-
-
AL Central.
So, certainly not the strongest one in baseball anymore, but saying that the AL east is bad is silly.
NL East
AL West
AL East
NL Central
NL West
-
-
-
AL Central.
So, certainly not the strongest one in baseball anymore, but saying that the AL east is bad is silly.
Well the Reds did have the best record in baseball over the duration of Joey Votto's time off... Or close to it, I'm not gonna double-check.
Pot and kettle arguing over who's more black... Oh, this topic. So amusing.
Thank you, thank you. I know, brilliant thinking isn't it? It's amazing that what the presupposed majority of people think is automatic fact, isn't it?You're comparing your baseball ideology to people jumping off the Empire State Building without a parachute.
On the topic of the AL East. NOWHERE HAVE I DECLARED IT THE WORST DIVISION IN BASEBALL. I think it has the capacity to become the worst division. That doesn't mean I think it will. I think there's a chance. That doesn't mean I think it will last for a long period of time if it happens, either. I'm just thinking out loud. Yankees are getting old. Could it bite them in the butt? Absolutely. Is it gonna send them into a dark age? I doubt it. They always find a way to maintain a ridiculously deep lineup. But that doesn't mean they are impervious to making mistakes that will cost them, and if they don't do something about that aging lineup it could definitely screw them over. Look, the Red Sox suck. Are they going to go suck forever? Well, I don't think so. But they suck now. Maybe they pull it together next year. The Rays? I don't know. They'll have to pay David Price eventually. If anything remains a constant, the Rays will probably do there thing... All divisions in baseball have at least one or two good teams. The Jays? Again, I said they were lost. They keep building up hype every year and then disappoint. Perhaps they finally put it all together next year. Who knows? I'm not calling them good until I see them doing well. Baltimore is not going to maintain that ridiculous record in one run games, and unless management makes improvement in that team they will likely regress to a low to mid 80s win team. But who knows the future? I'm just speaking my mind on something I observed as a possibility. It's entirely possible that all five teams come back next year as world beaters. 'Tis the magic of Baseball. You don't know what you're going to get until it happens.
Well, at least we won't be no hit, if that makes it any better
I wish I caught more Tigers games this season, they're playing very well.
And I don't care about WAR at all, it is at best a guideline and can't be used to decide anything accurately. Hell, the stat guys can't even agree on how to calculate it.
Carpenter and Marcum would have been excellent for Toronto if they kept them, those two out of three make sense at least.
Romero had a pretty good year last year although he regressed with the entire Toronto team this year. That's why I wanted to see him get traded to a team with a chance. idk I just like him OK?!?!
I drastically underestimated how long Halladay was with Toronto. You're right, he's not relevant at all to the point I was trying to make.
And I don't care about WAR at all, it is at best a guideline and can't be used to decide anything accurately. Hell, the stat guys can't even agree on how to calculate it.
Carpenter and Marcum would have been excellent for Toronto if they kept them, those two out of three make sense at least.
Romero had a pretty good year last year although he regressed with the entire Toronto team this year. That's why I wanted to see him get traded to a team with a chance. idk I just like him OK?!?!
lol
As much as I love it... Tigers are finally getting payback for all the bad luck they endured. Oakland gave us game two. Yankees are dropping like flies and none of their regulars can hit to save their lives... Heck, they've reduced themselves to using their bench to try and beat Verlander.
