Ok, now that we got this all out, there are a few things I can say. I'm kind of shocked that the village did not even consider the fact that there are only 23 people and that there is no way that there can be like 6 neutrals that demon238 was claiming when it was clear that each mafia faction had 4 people per team and two neutrals had already died. But... that is their fault I suppose. Firstly, let's look at the role PMs starting from the first who died.. Veedrock. 1/10. Definitely worst player ever. He had claimed to convert people Night 0. This was obviously a stupid thing. Claiming that you convert people to join your faction will definitely not keep you alive. I do not get why you would claim that, there are other things to claim yet you decide to claim something extremely far fetched. He had the role of being a silencer/delayed hooker, with the ability to kill every three nights at the beginning of Night 3, and if the game ever got to Night 7, he would have been able to steal. Very disappointed in how this role was executed. You had a very powerful role that could have won if played correctly. 8/10. Actually Lightwolf did really good at his job if only he survived. Night 0 he got Veedrock, which rendered Veedrock useless while Night 1 he got Fishy, the mafia inspector. Unfortunately Fishy never turned her PM in, but if she did then it wouldn't have received anything. So even though Lightwolf died, I'm sure he would have been a great asset to the village. 5/10. The other neutral, who had the ability to kill every night, post day 5 he would have been able to steal. Stealing was a big asset in this game since this game had many Presidents dependent upon items. Unfortunately though, McGraw used his one time kill ability on Fishin and well.. he died. 5/10. Again, didn't really do much. He held the constitution which would have kept Shade alive past day 3. Misaki-Chi had stolen it though Night 0 and there was really no chance of Shade living. If he got hold of the Emancipation Proclamation, which he almost did (Stoo had sent in the PM to give it to him, though he died) then he would have gained the ability to redirect people every night. Of course, once the item was stolen, so was his ability. 6/10. The first mafia to die. She had stolen the constitution which would result in a big hit on Day 3 when there would be three deaths. She also, like Fishy, didn't send a PM in on Night 1 on time which was disappointing. It wouldn't have mattered though since she was martyred by Twash that night, although it would have given her Twash's item -- the one time kill item, Rifle. However, failure to send in her PM gave thunda the opportunity to steal it first. 10/10. Flawless, he stole items each night he was alive from the mafia/neutral, and was giving darkie the emancipation proclamation at the time of his death. Unfortunately though, he didn't give it to him during the day and after being targetted for death, thunda just came in and stole all the items that he had. Stoo had three items on him, at this point it seemed like the Lost Presidents were unstoppable. 7/10. Accomplished what he had to, he protected the inspector Jimbo although Jimbo was never targetted. He was killed by dak on orders of thunda. 5/10. Used like a tool to say the least. Once thunda got him to target the bodyguard, he was immediately discarded during the Civil War. Lol dak kept sending me target PMs every night when it only worked during the even nights. Once he died, Fishy gained a delayed kill role. 3/10. Didn't do much, pretty much idled other than the time that he targetted Misaki-Chi when she idled. demon238 some how managed to make Twash look like a mole and he got lynched off. Twash should have done more to convince them to keep him alive, but it doesn't seem like he did. 7/10. Shade almost got the constitution but he realized that darkie had it too late, and Misaki stole it from him. To balance the Civil War, I made Shade a balance by forcing him to be impeached by the end of day 3. 6/10. Really didn't get much useful information, he found that dak was a mafia, although by that time demon238 and his gang was already knowledgeable about that. Once Toothache was gone, the Lost Presidents made no hesitation to get rid of Jimbo. 6/10. I mean, he really didn't stop anything big.. He forgot to turn his PM in once too, but I got Fishy to send in an order for him. I guess that's what happens when you're in a group where everyone is in a different time zone than you. 8/10. Did fairly well. Kept to himself, and just did as told by his partners. He, like billymills above, forgot to turn in his PM once so I got thunda to decide a kill for him. Flawless team work coming from the Lost Presidents. 9/10. Definitely helped a lot by silencing and preventing an action of a user per night. He could have gotten a flawless score if he had a tad bit more participation. Nonetheless, he used the Pistol on Fishy (as did demon238 when used the second time) and stopped alot of people from voting towards the end of the game when it got more crucial. Well played. 10/10. Lol, I am almost concerned at the village's credulity level. They believed pretty much anything that came out of BL's mouth. Haha. That being said, he was able to manipulate the village to do many things, including: informing him of any and all items being held, lynching people like Twash even though it was clear that he was good, and other things. I won his game and now he won mine! 10/10. Thunda ended the game with all the items in his possession. How he got info about Misaki-chi carrying the last item is kinda fishy, but who cares! Thunda really did a great job. However, thunda did get inspected the night he stole the Gas mask, but since that came after the inspection it didn't go into effect. Unfortunately though Fishy kept this to herself instead of revealing it to the villagers; that's what i would have done. 5/10. How unfortunate, Fishy was targetted for so many things. The pistol, which prevented the night action from going through was targetted at Fishy both times. Fishy really didn't do much like revealing info to the village, so her score is pretty low. 7/10. First forum mafia for McGraw I think. He had the one time ability of a impeacher and a hooker. The Lost Presidents used him to get rid of Fishin, Adolf Hitler, early in the game as they let him do whatever with his secondary ability. 5/10. As you can see, I got really tired of writing role PMs by the time I got to Earthworm. Earthworm really didn't do much so there really isn't much I can say about him.. Since Jedil revealed them both (I think) early in the game, the chance of one of them dying really diminished away. 8/10. Did fairly well to rally the villagers early in the game, although he was under the total control of demon238 the whole time. Other than this, you can pretty much read Earthworms comments since it applies equally to Jedil. I was surprised that Jedil didn't even find it at all weird that there were so many neutrals in the game that demon238 was concealing. 5/10. Rogue. No one targetted him :( Not much to say. 6/10. Well, GP had the ability of an even night BPV or a one time BPV, I can't really remember, as long as he held onto the Monroe Doctrine. Poor GP though, the night after he got the doctrine thunda came in and stole it lol. I thought that was a little bit humorous. On top of that he was abducted too so he couldn't post his fury. Hehhh. Annywayy, that's it! I hope you guys enjoyed it, even if it was only for the beginning of the game. I'll make awards for this game soon! I already have in mind who is mvp etc etc.