-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
The Anime / Manga Thread (MK2) | Beware Spoilers
- Thread starter Acklow
- Start date
- Status
I recently finished the first season of SAO with the mindset of being able to watch SAO2 with everyone else.
SAO arc was good except the storyline where it jumped around from sidestory to sidestory with no real coherent forward plot driven point at the beginning. It makes sense when looking at it retrospectively how important the side quests were for Kirito's character development but the story was still meh.
ALO arc was better in terms of progression storywise but the story itself was much more lackluster. Also unnecessary fanservice, lack of memorable characters, and an honestly cringy antagonist makes it worse overall with comparison to the SAO arc.
Meh, I still enjoyed it and think that people give it too much flak. Gonna continue my Fate/Zero runthrough soontm.
SAO arc was good except the storyline where it jumped around from sidestory to sidestory with no real coherent forward plot driven point at the beginning. It makes sense when looking at it retrospectively how important the side quests were for Kirito's character development but the story was still meh.
ALO arc was better in terms of progression storywise but the story itself was much more lackluster. Also unnecessary fanservice, lack of memorable characters, and an honestly cringy antagonist makes it worse overall with comparison to the SAO arc.
Meh, I still enjoyed it and think that people give it too much flak. Gonna continue my Fate/Zero runthrough soontm.
NGNL finale was excellent, i've heard people complain that the series falls off at some point but overall i'm very happy with the first season
idk if anyones still watching utena, but i watched the first 2 episodes and dropped it. i dont get how anyone finds this shit enjoyable, the characters are bad, unlikeable and unmemorable, the art style is really ugly, the battle scenes are pitiful and i cant get into the inter-character relationships
someone please tell me why people enjoy this
someone please tell me why people enjoy this
I'm at 4, it's supposed to get really smart at a point I'm assuming isn't the dead start of the show. Even then I can't say I'm totally bored by it so far.
I raced ahead of everyone to about ep 15.
Honestly, the reason it frequently rates mentions as underrated is because it's not everyone's cup of tea. You also have to consider the time that this anime was created in (art).
I really enjoyed it so far and plan to resume it. I love the visuals (if you overlook the datedness, there's some real creativity there, especially with the shadow puppet art style) and the music, and Utena is a great character. The anime is definitely a slow starter (it has 40 episodes too...) and it takes the final ep of the student council arc to make it apparent why the arc is even relevant, but the story has finally upped the ante. I think to be able to withstand Anthy you have to look at her philosophically, which exposes the hypocrisy of Utena's own creed. The duels are metaphorical more than anything at the start as well.
I feel that I can't judge this show adequately until I get further in, because the buildup here is really obvious. I hate the filler episodes but thought the advancement of Anthy and Utena's relationship was both subtle and complex so far. I don't think it's meant to initially be easy to understand. The student council arc being like 90% reused footage and failing to engage the viewer with either good battles or engaging characterisation from the council (sans one character) for like six episodes is very valid criticism nonetheless. The latter does get better though.
Honestly, the reason it frequently rates mentions as underrated is because it's not everyone's cup of tea. You also have to consider the time that this anime was created in (art).
I really enjoyed it so far and plan to resume it. I love the visuals (if you overlook the datedness, there's some real creativity there, especially with the shadow puppet art style) and the music, and Utena is a great character. The anime is definitely a slow starter (it has 40 episodes too...) and it takes the final ep of the student council arc to make it apparent why the arc is even relevant, but the story has finally upped the ante. I think to be able to withstand Anthy you have to look at her philosophically, which exposes the hypocrisy of Utena's own creed. The duels are metaphorical more than anything at the start as well.
I feel that I can't judge this show adequately until I get further in, because the buildup here is really obvious. I hate the filler episodes but thought the advancement of Anthy and Utena's relationship was both subtle and complex so far. I don't think it's meant to initially be easy to understand. The student council arc being like 90% reused footage and failing to engage the viewer with either good battles or engaging characterisation from the council (sans one character) for like six episodes is very valid criticism nonetheless. The latter does get better though.
Last edited:
Honestly I'm still getting over the art, long and lanky is pretty much on the top of my least favorite art styles (there are a lot of good 90s series in term of art). Sure it's superficial, but ultimately I'm watching it.
I do enjoy what they do with entering the forest + those shadow girls with really creep voices.
I do enjoy what they do with entering the forest + those shadow girls with really creep voices.
I do enjoy how they ripped off Guilty Crown with the whole sword-out-of-chest thing.
I read the manga... it's absolutely crazy with random deaths left-right-centre.... much like AoT
ive also read the manga, i know exactly what it's like, which is why im so pumped for it and why i really hope its done well
also its way better than aot lol
How hyped are you for the ship sequence.... DBZ-esque fight in suits is ripe for anime badassery.
RODAN
Banned deucer.
also im there and im really cool
I think it's overhyped too. Not "mediocre", but I didn't like anything after episode 7, I think. The highs of the show were neat and well directed but imo after a certain point it wasn't enough to salvage everything else.
- Status