So I have been responding to many of the complaints about the current big game hosted by zorbees. A lot of people seem to think that it is severely imbalanced and is one of the worst things they have ever played. Well, I say prove it! Is it really the worst? So bad that it shall not be named, let alone its existence be acknowledged?
Well, I made this thread with the intention of finding out. You see, a long time ago some of us played an unspeakably bad mafia game. Gmax thought it was so bad that we must continue to pretend that it never existed. For the record, I will only relax this taboo once. In other words, in this thread, I will say right now that the unofficial title holder for "game that must not be named" is:
.
While I think Yeti's BIG SANDS comes close and at one point clearly contested the title, I still personally think that it is the current champ for a reason.
However as I said it is not official. So I have decided to make a light-hearted "Tournament" of sorts where we nominate notable mafia games that we have played as the new game that must not be named. We will then vote them off tournament style and the last one standing will be the new title holder. In accordance to the title, the existence of said game should no longer be acknowledged in any idle conversation outside of this thread.
So please go ahead and make a nomination, and justify why. It doesn't have to be dozens of paragraphs long (but it can if you want, and may potentially strengthen your case if read by people who weren't in said game). When I see that there are enough (ideally around eight or so) then we will start the brackets.
So as for my nomination:
deserves to be the current champ. As one of the first big games to prominently feature "pointless neutrals", some of which were able to win even by idling the whole time, it remains a legend, and something that shames the righteous name of
Well, I made this thread with the intention of finding out. You see, a long time ago some of us played an unspeakably bad mafia game. Gmax thought it was so bad that we must continue to pretend that it never existed. For the record, I will only relax this taboo once. In other words, in this thread, I will say right now that the unofficial title holder for "game that must not be named" is:
Megaman Mafia
While I think Yeti's BIG SANDS comes close and at one point clearly contested the title, I still personally think that it is the current champ for a reason.
However as I said it is not official. So I have decided to make a light-hearted "Tournament" of sorts where we nominate notable mafia games that we have played as the new game that must not be named. We will then vote them off tournament style and the last one standing will be the new title holder. In accordance to the title, the existence of said game should no longer be acknowledged in any idle conversation outside of this thread.
So please go ahead and make a nomination, and justify why. It doesn't have to be dozens of paragraphs long (but it can if you want, and may potentially strengthen your case if read by people who weren't in said game). When I see that there are enough (ideally around eight or so) then we will start the brackets.
So as for my nomination:
Megaman mafia
Megaman.
Last edited:
