Ok, I had an idea that would help anyone playing RBY, or writing articles or analyses about it, or constructing ideas or whatever. I posted earlier about it but it prolly went unnoticed.
I want to make a guide where you can quickly look up how much damage you can expect from one common Pokémon to another, and preferably later write a program from this data so you can just input the attacker, defender and the attack so you get an output. It'd be a little quicker than a damage calculator, and after a while you'd know them all.
Now, why didn't I already make this? Because it is a shitload of work, and I'm sure there are some people out there who want to help. Do you want to help me?
What you can do if you want to help:
1) Suggest another Pokémon in this thread. Preferably provide the most common used attacks, and determine against which other Pokémon it should be added. I put the 13 most abudant Pokémon here but I'm sure there are more. Remember, however, please stick to stuff that is sometimes actually used. Nobody would want to know how much damage Farfetch'd Slash does to Parasect.
2) List redudant parts in these calculations. I put 4 items under the big list of Pokémon and attacks about what you can leave off, but maybe there's something I overlooked.
3) This is mainly why I made this thread: I want people to help calculating. There are over 300 calculations and with suggestions there will be more. Under the list you'll see how you could help. If you want to contribute to this project, please read the whole thread carefully.
I Tauros
1. Body Slam
2. Blizzard
3. Hyper Beam
4. Earthquake
II Alakazam
1. Psychic
III Starmie
1. Surf
2. Blizzard
3. Thunderbolt
IV Golem
1. Explosion
2. Earthquake
3. Body Slam
4. Rock Slide
V Rhydon
1. Earthquake
2. Body Slam
3. Rock Slide
VI Chansey
1. Ice Beam
2. Thunderbolt
VII Exeggutor
1. Psychic
2. Mega Drain
3. Explosion
4. Double-Edge
VIII Snorlax
1. Body Slam
2. Hyper Beam
3. Selfdestruct
4. Earthquake
5. Surf
IX Lapras
1. Body Slam
2. Thunderbolt
3. Blizzard
X Persian
1. Body Slam
2. Slash
3. Hyper Beam
4. Bubblebeam
XI Slowbro
1. Surf
XII Gengar
1. Psychic
2. Mega Drain
3. Thunderbolt
4. Explosion
XIII Zapdos
1. Thunderbolt
2. Drill Peck
For now, I think that's more than enough. Now, I'd want these all calculated on all 13 of these, except where it is probably not necessary. The following can be left off:
1. Body Slam, Hyper Beam, Slash and Explosion against Golem, Rhydon and Gengar
2. Other immunities, like Thunderbolt against Rhydon and Golem
3. 4x resists, like Blizzard against Lapras
4. OHKOs everyone's sure about, like Starmie Surf against Rhydon and Golem
5. Other unneccessary stuff, for example Exeggutor would rarely Mega Drain a Chansey, Zapdos or Snorlax (it's only needed for Starmie and Golem and stuff). If you're unsure whether to do it or not, just report so when handing in the results. I and other editors might or might not decide to put it in nonetheless.
I'd like everyone who wants to contribute to this claim Pokemon examples (take as many or few as you want) in this thread, and get on with the calculation. There are 13 Pokemon, so unless calculations are easily canceled by above exceptions, you'll have about 13 calculations per attack (26 if you count CHs, 52 if you count the addition of % AND normal HP damage).
For example, you decide that you'd like to take Starmie. You then have to calculate CH and non-CH, min and max damage on all 13 above Pokémon with all three attacks (I don't think I will add the suggestions to the target list unless it's really neccessary...I might be adding Articuno and Jynx later though in which case it'd be interesting). UNLESS one of the exception rules states you don't have to.
Please look through the thread carefully to see what's taken and what's not. I will edit it in asap but I can't catch them all. If you think another move is neccessary to be calced, you can either claim the Pokemon for it, or tell the one who's doing it. First come, first get.
Handy stats for quick reference:
TAUROS
HP - 353 / Atk - 298 / Def - 288 / Spd - 318 / Spc - 238
STARMIE
HP - 323 / Def - 268 / Spd - 328 / Spc - 298
GOLEM
HP - 363 / Atk - 318 / Def - 358 / Spd - 188 / Spc - 208
RHYDON
HP - 413 / Atk - 358 / Def - 338 / Spd - 178 / Spc - 188
CHANSEY
HP - 703 / Def - 108 / Spd - 198 / Spc - 308
EXEGGUTOR
HP - 393 / Atk - 288 / Def - 268 / Spd - 208 / Spc - 348
SNORLAX
HP - 523 / Atk - 318 / Def - 228 / Spd - 158 / Spc - 228
LAPRAS
HP - 463 / Atk - 268 / Def - 258 / Spd - 218 / Spc - 288
PERSIAN
HP - 333 / Atk - 238 / Def - 218 / Spd - 328 / Spc - 228
ZAPDOS
HP - 383 / Atk - 278 / Def - 268 / Spd - 298 / Spc - 348
SLOWBRO
HP - 393 / Def - 318 / Spd - 158 / Spc - 258
GENGAR
HP - 323 / Atk - 228 / Def - 218 / Spd - 318 / Spc - 358
I left off the Attack of those who only use Special Attacks.
If you have done your work, please put it in the following format:
Attacker on Defender (you don't put "action" here)
Move 1: x HP, y % damage
CH: x HP, y % damage
Move 2: x HP, y % damage
CH: x HP, y % damage
etc
Example:
Tauros on Snorlax
Body Slam: 154 HP, 23% damage
CH: 276 HP, 53% damage
(this is not real)
This is meant to be easy to view and easy to put in a FAQ. It took me a lot of time to put the 712909670 different formats in the moveset competition in one document, please spare me the work this time.
I'm glad if you decide to help Smogon out. There are over 300 (maybe even 400) of calculations to be done, and every little bit helps.
I want to make a guide where you can quickly look up how much damage you can expect from one common Pokémon to another, and preferably later write a program from this data so you can just input the attacker, defender and the attack so you get an output. It'd be a little quicker than a damage calculator, and after a while you'd know them all.
Now, why didn't I already make this? Because it is a shitload of work, and I'm sure there are some people out there who want to help. Do you want to help me?
What you can do if you want to help:
1) Suggest another Pokémon in this thread. Preferably provide the most common used attacks, and determine against which other Pokémon it should be added. I put the 13 most abudant Pokémon here but I'm sure there are more. Remember, however, please stick to stuff that is sometimes actually used. Nobody would want to know how much damage Farfetch'd Slash does to Parasect.
2) List redudant parts in these calculations. I put 4 items under the big list of Pokémon and attacks about what you can leave off, but maybe there's something I overlooked.
3) This is mainly why I made this thread: I want people to help calculating. There are over 300 calculations and with suggestions there will be more. Under the list you'll see how you could help. If you want to contribute to this project, please read the whole thread carefully.
I Tauros
1. Body Slam
2. Blizzard
3. Hyper Beam
4. Earthquake
II Alakazam
1. Psychic
III Starmie
1. Surf
2. Blizzard
3. Thunderbolt
IV Golem
1. Explosion
2. Earthquake
3. Body Slam
4. Rock Slide
V Rhydon
1. Earthquake
2. Body Slam
3. Rock Slide
VI Chansey
1. Ice Beam
2. Thunderbolt
VII Exeggutor
1. Psychic
2. Mega Drain
3. Explosion
4. Double-Edge
VIII Snorlax
1. Body Slam
2. Hyper Beam
3. Selfdestruct
4. Earthquake
5. Surf
IX Lapras
1. Body Slam
2. Thunderbolt
3. Blizzard
X Persian
1. Body Slam
2. Slash
3. Hyper Beam
4. Bubblebeam
XI Slowbro
1. Surf
XII Gengar
1. Psychic
2. Mega Drain
3. Thunderbolt
4. Explosion
XIII Zapdos
1. Thunderbolt
2. Drill Peck
For now, I think that's more than enough. Now, I'd want these all calculated on all 13 of these, except where it is probably not necessary. The following can be left off:
1. Body Slam, Hyper Beam, Slash and Explosion against Golem, Rhydon and Gengar
2. Other immunities, like Thunderbolt against Rhydon and Golem
3. 4x resists, like Blizzard against Lapras
4. OHKOs everyone's sure about, like Starmie Surf against Rhydon and Golem
5. Other unneccessary stuff, for example Exeggutor would rarely Mega Drain a Chansey, Zapdos or Snorlax (it's only needed for Starmie and Golem and stuff). If you're unsure whether to do it or not, just report so when handing in the results. I and other editors might or might not decide to put it in nonetheless.
I'd like everyone who wants to contribute to this claim Pokemon examples (take as many or few as you want) in this thread, and get on with the calculation. There are 13 Pokemon, so unless calculations are easily canceled by above exceptions, you'll have about 13 calculations per attack (26 if you count CHs, 52 if you count the addition of % AND normal HP damage).
For example, you decide that you'd like to take Starmie. You then have to calculate CH and non-CH, min and max damage on all 13 above Pokémon with all three attacks (I don't think I will add the suggestions to the target list unless it's really neccessary...I might be adding Articuno and Jynx later though in which case it'd be interesting). UNLESS one of the exception rules states you don't have to.
Please look through the thread carefully to see what's taken and what's not. I will edit it in asap but I can't catch them all. If you think another move is neccessary to be calced, you can either claim the Pokemon for it, or tell the one who's doing it. First come, first get.
Handy stats for quick reference:
TAUROS
HP - 353 / Atk - 298 / Def - 288 / Spd - 318 / Spc - 238
STARMIE
HP - 323 / Def - 268 / Spd - 328 / Spc - 298
GOLEM
HP - 363 / Atk - 318 / Def - 358 / Spd - 188 / Spc - 208
RHYDON
HP - 413 / Atk - 358 / Def - 338 / Spd - 178 / Spc - 188
CHANSEY
HP - 703 / Def - 108 / Spd - 198 / Spc - 308
EXEGGUTOR
HP - 393 / Atk - 288 / Def - 268 / Spd - 208 / Spc - 348
SNORLAX
HP - 523 / Atk - 318 / Def - 228 / Spd - 158 / Spc - 228
LAPRAS
HP - 463 / Atk - 268 / Def - 258 / Spd - 218 / Spc - 288
PERSIAN
HP - 333 / Atk - 238 / Def - 218 / Spd - 328 / Spc - 228
ZAPDOS
HP - 383 / Atk - 278 / Def - 268 / Spd - 298 / Spc - 348
SLOWBRO
HP - 393 / Def - 318 / Spd - 158 / Spc - 258
GENGAR
HP - 323 / Atk - 228 / Def - 218 / Spd - 318 / Spc - 358
I left off the Attack of those who only use Special Attacks.
If you have done your work, please put it in the following format:
Attacker on Defender (you don't put "action" here)
Move 1: x HP, y % damage
CH: x HP, y % damage
Move 2: x HP, y % damage
CH: x HP, y % damage
etc
Example:
Tauros on Snorlax
Body Slam: 154 HP, 23% damage
CH: 276 HP, 53% damage
(this is not real)
This is meant to be easy to view and easy to put in a FAQ. It took me a lot of time to put the 712909670 different formats in the moveset competition in one document, please spare me the work this time.
I'm glad if you decide to help Smogon out. There are over 300 (maybe even 400) of calculations to be done, and every little bit helps.