That's the thing Chou. I really don't think he can intimidate those pokemon to a point where they feel the must tag out. I feel like his typing+ the fact that his best move will break not only his opponent, but him in the process makes him less intimidating over all. Is what I'm shooting at. I'm not saying he can't be effective I just don't think he will be more effective than luke
Well, keeping in mind that Luke itself is not all that effective... I mean in all the games I've played in BW, I can probably count the number of games I've been swept by a Lucario on my fingers. In comparing SD Arcanine to Luke, we're not saying that it would be a monster-- because frankly neither one is close to being anything "monstrous" in OU.
But seriously, what are you talking about it can't force switches? If it gets in, the Pokemon I listed will feel a LOT of pressure to switch out. Also, you are over-estimating the problems associated with Flare Blitz's recoil. Usually, id doesn't turn out to be all that much.
-Breloom (At -1, it can't really hurt Arcanine-- scared of being One-shot by flare blitz)
-Celebi (Most don't have the speed, power, and Earth Power in moveset to hurt arcanine. Also, if it's a bulky ev'd Arcanine (which is totally possible, unlike with Luke), it's screwed no matter what it does)
-Ferrothorn (Thunder Wave is the only thing Ferrothorn can do to hurt Arcanine. If Arcanine gets in on Ferro, it will have to switch out in fear of one shot)
-Jirachi (Most are support sets slower than a sweeper Arcanine. Flare Blitz will one shot it, so it's pressured to switch out)
-Ninetales (Can't do jack, so its switch out or get set up-- Roar / Toxic being your best options, but Ninetales is scared of repeated CC/ExSpeed)
-Scizor (Can totally set up on this shit)
-Skarmory (Can totally set up on this shit)
-Volcarona (From my experience, most are running Giga Drain now to deal with Terrak/Keldeo
-Foretress (.__.)
-Lucario (Luke is slower than Arcanine... unless he wants to be one shot, he will switch out)
-Toxicroak (Is pathetically weak at -1, and has Dry Skin. Unless Arcanine is taking him on in rain (why?) Toxicroak really doesn't want to face arcanine)
-Abomasnow (wtf would you leave your 4x weak weather starter in against arcy?)
-Bronzong (Can't do jack at -1 to Arcy)
-Amoongus (one shot-- might stay i and sac itself since it will have most likely used Spore by the time Arcy switches in on it)
-Sableye (is shit without W-o-W, might be brave enough to stay in and Taunt...)
-Xatu (can't really do jack to arcy, but t-wave and nightshade kind of do something I guess)