NOC Why is there a gun in my popcorn? GAME OVER SCUM WIN

[Empoof]

Yeti how's it feel to roll mafia in a game like this?

 

[Empoof]

wow josh is scum too

two down

 

[Empoof]

Moodycloud top town

after texas.

 

[Empoof]

Opinions on Blazade going for a derp clear?

Looks relatively real. Dunno if it's AI or not.

 

[Thetwinmasters]

actually nvm shoot empoof before he loses me another game

 

[Empoof]

actually nvm shoot empoof before he loses me another game

Baby you love it

 

[Josh]

it's not a derp clear. scum are no more likely to know that than town. it's just a derp.

 

[Empoof]

Josh do you like Fort more than Hitmonleet

 

[MoodyCloud]

On Texas being the first gunbearer : I can only conclude that mafia wants the people they see as experienced and a bigger threat to go first when their likelihood to fail is highest, instead of giving newer players the gun hoping they'll randomly kill a veteran player.

Doesn't really tell us much but it still makes the scum team's reasoning obvious and Texas misfiring on another solid player would work towards their objective the most.

For some reason I scumread Josh

 

[Empoof]

On Texas being the first gunbearer : I can only conclude that mafia wants the people they see as experienced and a bigger threat to go first when their likelihood to fail is highest, instead of giving newer players the gun hoping they'll randomly kill a veteran player.

Doesn't really tell us much but it still makes the scum team's reasoning obvious and Texas misfiring on another solid player would work towards their objective the most.

For some reason I scumread Josh

 

[UncleSam]

Vote remove honestly I can't believe we even have to vote on this I will straight sub out if I have to deal with something as dumb as a free for all village - it's hard enough dealing with noc villages when everyone's on the same team

Not much to go on but the most important thing is to stir discussion early. While I think that Leet's post was pretty bad in terms of logic (really I am not sure what he is trying to say in it) I do like the fact that he is actually doing something analytical

 

[Josh]

Josh do you like Fort more than Hitmonleet

yes. fort is null and hit is scum.

 

[winter-delta]

...literally slept through this wtf
I don't think I can say anything about this that someone else hasn't already said, so yeah.
Also I vote Remove.

 

[Empoof]

...literally slept through this wtf
I don't think I can say anything about this that someone else hasn't already said, so yeah.
Also I vote Remove.

what do you mean by the bolded?

 

[Hitmonleet]

At least you acknowledged the 13:7 ratio
I believe, however, that your reasoning has 3 major flaws:
1) there's no evidence that players not in that game did not read the game (except that, admittedly, it was hard even for me in the game to stay motivated in reading the walls upon walls of text)
2) town and mafia both should be able to respect him for his townleading ability.
3) has he put up a similar showing in mafia games before?

1. That is, honestly, a completely valid point. It was more that I doubted anyone actually had the willpower to read through +100 pages worth of NOC.
2. Yes, but Mafia are the ones that choose the first gunwo/man, so it doesn't exactly matter what the town thinks about him as much as what the Mafia thinks about him (although he is a good player, just to get that out of the way).
3. I have no counterargument to that, except that OCNOC was the most recent game, so it would be fresh in the players' minds.

In light of these points, however, UnFoS Former Hope.

I still maintain that Haruno is always mafia, however. :-)

 

[Josh]

I read the entire oc noc. haruno v Texas was pure entertainment. mostly haruno. btw, for all yall insulting him, he tried hard and played towards his wincon of throwing people off the mafia as long as possible. he tried.

 

[Asek]

haruno is detrimental to town no matter what as he is either a) scum or b) towny but acting so scummy u gotta kill him anyway

 

[Josh]

no he's not. he's both readable and can scum hunt pretty well

 

[Asek]

no he's not. he's both readable and can scum hunt pretty well

if by scum hunt u mean call omgus on every1 then yeah sure i guess

 

[Empoof]

I don't think we should shoot Haruno

Hide

 

[Empoof]

no he's not. he's both readable and can scum hunt pretty well

So do you think Haruno will -never- get shot this game as town?

 

[Wayan Vistar]

Remove, never really use that rule in non-ffa games here from what i've seen

Also i don't intend to idle this game. There's a reason i signed up for this game, and no it isn't to just sit on my ass doing nothing. That said, i am in school, so i won't be here 24/7, but i will be reading the thread from my phone if i can

We need more discussion before deciding whether or not Haruno's the right shot, really. I don't believe we should currently, but depending on how conversation develops today and how they act this could change. Haruno hasn't spoken much yet, so there isn't much in the way of reads, so i'd be a bit more careful.

 

[Wayan Vistar]

Shit, missed an entire page, i thought Haruno was still the topic @_@

 

[Empoof]

Shit, missed an entire page, i thought Haruno was still the topic @_@

Well he kind of still is, in my opinion. So don't trip

 

[Wayan Vistar]

Wait Haruno IS still the subject. The "There have been more posts, view them?" or however it's phrased option is fucking confusing as hell, showed those posts but not the rest of this page @_@