-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
NOC There's Actually a Sequel to the Matrix - Day 9 (Deadline Tuesday 10 PM EST)
- Thread starter Da Letter El
- Start date
on mobile atm
he's in my current poe along with you but i need to get to finishing your iso
i do find his latest content strange because i find the way the way his votes are used, he's been treating flipped town weird and i do not like the drookez 2nd vote, maybe to avoid plurality?
i do think his d1 and d2 feel town but hes been slipping off just based on later days and scum has to do some peculiar things(#1572 and #1599 are certain instances but given how FH treated a hypothetical scum partner whydon it doesn't seem unreasonable to reverse bus everybody else to expose the cop and win on towncred)
noticably from the iso whydon drops reads which i can't tell is scum indicative or not based on meta but i don't think it's certainly towny
i don't think it's unreasonable to assume it's a possibility
usually scum caught early push each other down but there's obviously been bussing somewhere
i mean this doesn't necessarily help you either, considering you had an early vote on 3p1k and went for FH somewhat i think as well
not helping me by the mentality ive stated you mean? what's your take on vote distribution this game?
who do you want to hammer test
yeah if you're saying mafia did a lot of voting and pressuring on each other, i don't know if that is too helpful, since town has done the same thing. maybe i'm not understanding what you're saying?
what do you mean by vote distribution?
obv me but pidge is also good
got back to a computer again
though i can see the mindset behind "both did so" . do you think it's completely useless information at this point? how are you visualizing your reads at this point of the game?
vote distribution being how people placed their votes basically
i think it's at least a little bit noteworthy to see how people reacted to the flipped scum because caff and fh also pushed each other after being under fire
though i can see the mindset behind "both did so" . do you think it's completely useless information at this point? how are you visualizing your reads at this point of the game?
vote distribution being how people placed their votes basically
from my pov you or me is fine ig
i don't really see myself voting you over the other two
either way lets decide one soon
how sure are you on pidge
it is useless in that it doesn't help differentiate nuxl from whydon. my reads haven't changed much from last time i commented on them.
asking me how people distributed their votes is such a broad question. i don't even know how to answer that or why, when looking at posts in general is even broader and more helpful. like drookez did a vote count analysis and it was pretty useless, since it didn't take into account stuff like people purposely not hammering and unlynching and relynching.
i still don't understand how hammer testing anyone helps us mathematically
i can see where you're coming from wrt hammer testing not being "mathematically" optimal but the thing is in a hypothetical where hammertesting works favorably a confirmed town is better than having none because then the poe narrows for everybody meaning
1. scum can't force a way out on multiple avenues by spinning their reads on somewhere else
2. are trapped into the kill or else they only have one way out in lylo
it clears up minds in mylo and stops unnecessary paranoia from coming through before the nightkill.
and this is extremely ballsy and i'm not doing this myself, but if you hammertested someone in your poe and it passed the answer would be clearer
1. scum can't force a way out on multiple avenues by spinning their reads on somewhere else
2. are trapped into the kill or else they only have one way out in lylo
it clears up minds in mylo and stops unnecessary paranoia from coming through before the nightkill.
and this is extremely ballsy and i'm not doing this myself, but if you hammertested someone in your poe and it passed the answer would be clearer
this sorta answers my question but i think you're heavily misinterpreting what i'm saying
basically, did the votes on a wagon matter from your perspective to develop a read on?
drookez post was useless because he didnt even fucking read the day and just looked at the end of day wagon, that does not equivocate to the entire vote analysis being useless