Okay, you have until Sep 2nd at 6pm edt for ratings.
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
Walrus Aura Guardian: Walrus of your Peers - died in cat 3.
- Thread starter Aura Guardian
- Start date
Deadline was a few hours ago. Tomorrow, gonna post when reveals happen. (Again, non-players welcome to listen.)
Scheduling reveal for 6pm edt on Saturday the 8th.
Code:
First, ragmatho is dropping. Their song will be played in the score slot it would have received. Due to only six songs, soon to be five, all will be played in full
Code:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C0vGk5MzVF
Code:
In sixth place with 2.4 points is Scott Joplin's New Rag, submitted by Lectrys. Cancerous gave it 1.5, and KnightsofCydonia gave it 0.9. It felt like it lacked any true spirit, which would explain why so few gave it much at all
Code:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g1MNGBRlS8k
Code:
In fifth place with 6.5 points is Bills (Instrumental) by LunchMoney Lewis, submitted by ragmatho. It received 3.25 from Cancerous, 2.25 from Lectrys, and 1 from KnightsofCydonia. It feels peppier, but lacks as much soul, probably due to being just the instrumental of a song meant for lyrics
Code:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HVcMi1CHDO8
Code:
In fourth place with 8.25 points is The King of Fighters 2002, submitted by ThePyrokinetic. Everyone staying gave it points: 3 from Jrdn, 2.875 from Lectrys, 1.25 from Cancerous, and 1.2 from KnightsofCydonia. This is the first song that feels alive
Code:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ssex8g5vVB4
Code:
In third place with 8.95 points is Cancerous’s submission, Before Dawn, by Isaac Shepard. KnightsofCydonia gave it 3.1, ThePyrokinetic gave it 3, Jrdn gave it 2, and Lectrys gave it 0.85. It feels soothing, but not hugely so. At times, it was more alive than any before it, but not all the time.
[code] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BeSbmS06k1k
Code:
In second place with 10.2 points is Made in Abyss OST - Tomorrow, submitted by Jrdn. KnightsofCydonia gave it 3.8, Thepyrokinetic gave it 3, Cancerous gave it 2.25, and Lectrys gave it 1.15. I’m a little surprised this got this high a score; it just felt too mild until after the “ah”-ing, which some nearly considered catfailing it for
Code:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JVpN8Jxi_Xs
Code:
KnightsofCydonia claims first place again, with 13.625 points for Wild Monk by Osamu Kitajima. Jrdn gave it a full 5, ThePyrokinetic a 4, Lectrys gave it 2.875, and Cancerous gave it 1.75. It definitely deserved this place; the song felt alive and powerful, and never wavered.
[b]ALSO, DUE TO BEING DOWN TO FIVE PEOPLE, I’D LIKE TO TAKE A POLL OF MY PLAYERS: SHOULD THIS CONTINUE?
You have until 7 pm edt on sept 15th to send both video and vote on if it should continue[/b]I'll try to get updated scores up in a day or two.
Sure, I'd love this to continue! (It seems that every single other walrus has stopped, at any rate.)
Also, Scott Joplin's New Rag is the peppiest and most alive of all the songs this round (IMO). All the other songs were too slow in comparison. (The songs I gave the highest scores to did have vigour, though.)
Also, Scott Joplin's New Rag is the peppiest and most alive of all the songs this round (IMO). All the other songs were too slow in comparison. (The songs I gave the highest scores to did have vigour, though.)
I want to play it out, but I'm worried about how the dropouts affect the scoring mechanism. Would adding a few guest judges to the mix be viable?
Nice idea; what do other players think of guest judges PROVIDED that I'm able to find any?
I was thinking as in they vote in rounds but they're not competing.
I've added round two to: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet...27a9LVyl0X1nAjHOHsZtMxySvA/edit#gid=582033511
Deadline happened, but I'll extend it to 7pm edt on the 16th. One potential mercy on my part.
submission deadline. Someone didn't submit.
cat 3 ratings deadline September 23 at 9pm edt
cat 3 ratings deadline September 23 at 9pm edt
Deadline. I've only received 3 ratings, for 4 songs; 5 players.
Activity is basically 3.5 players right now. That's too low.
Sorry, but I'm going to have to call this.
Activity is basically 3.5 players right now. That's too low.
Sorry, but I'm going to have to call this.
Aw. Ended up going AFK for some time due to real-life problems and wasn't able to contribute to the thread. Sorry to all.