Ok so the idea of a Circus Maximus scoreboard was raised in this thread, so I figured I'd make one.
I'll add my own stats to this post so that people can get an idea of how I see this working. Feel free to comment on format changes that ought to be made etc.
First, a few notes:
Stats: UncleSam
Totals across all games:
Cumulative win rate: 498/1350 = 36.9%
My win rate: 26/53 = 49.1%
Average per game: 25.5 players with 9.40 winners.
I wasn't surprised by my stats much, I know I'm worst at NOCs relative to the average and the order NOCs < Mafia Vs. Village < Multifaction < FFAs is what I'd have guessed going into this so it's interesting that the stats worked out that way.
Also worth noting that this manner of stats is a bit misleading for certain games (particularly FFAs), because some games you can do quite well in but not technically win (for example, Walrein getting second in Late Summer Diplomacy or me coming in second in The Genius Game both just count as generic losses using this reckoning). Would welcome input on better ways to keep these.
Anyway feel free to comment with your own stats, corrections to mine, or comments on changes that ought to be made in how we keep player stats. Personally I'd rather we only keep player stats for players who want the stats to be kept and who submit their stats, though if we could get a few people who review stats that would be good as well.
So ya go nuts! Calling for Walrein to show his no bich
I'll add my own stats to this post so that people can get an idea of how I see this working. Feel free to comment on format changes that ought to be made etc.
First, a few notes:
1. Regarding substitutes: I count any games lost in which I sub in or out as losses (so, for example, both Dota Mafia and Wayne Bradier count as losses). I count games in which you sub out and later win as void (aka they don't show up on the record), and I count games in which you sub in and win as wins only if you make a contribution to winning (the only example I can think of that wouldn't count is PBlade's subbing in for a single hammer vote in Luigi's Mansion)
2. Games in which there was a tie are voided from the record if you were part of the tie, but are counted as losses with half as many pseudo-'winners' as there were people who tied
3. Strategy games are counted (so Diplomacy or The Genius Game count), but games which do not require significant skill are not (so my Be Unpopular or Die win doesn't count)
4. Games in which no players won (BIGS 2, Dak Mafia) are not counted
5. Games which were designed specifically to be trolls (Troll NOC 2) are not counted
6. I'll format things as <Game Name> (<Players who Won>/<Players who Lost>) (Notes if I'm not sure of the number of players who won in any given game)
7. I'd appreciate it if places where I'm unsure about how many winners/players there were in a game someone could clarify it for me, if possible. Double-checking me on some of the older ones might be a good idea as well.
8. I define 'multifaction' as any game consisting of teams which does not fit with Mafia Vs. Village or a Free for All game. I define 'FFA' as any game where a significant portion of the players started out
9. I'm going to be including Big mafias within their respective sub-categories as well as in a category of their own; for cumulative win count across all categories I'm not going to double count them however
2. Games in which there was a tie are voided from the record if you were part of the tie, but are counted as losses with half as many pseudo-'winners' as there were people who tied
3. Strategy games are counted (so Diplomacy or The Genius Game count), but games which do not require significant skill are not (so my Be Unpopular or Die win doesn't count)
4. Games in which no players won (BIGS 2, Dak Mafia) are not counted
5. Games which were designed specifically to be trolls (Troll NOC 2) are not counted
6. I'll format things as <Game Name> (<Players who Won>/<Players who Lost>) (Notes if I'm not sure of the number of players who won in any given game)
7. I'd appreciate it if places where I'm unsure about how many winners/players there were in a game someone could clarify it for me, if possible. Double-checking me on some of the older ones might be a good idea as well.
8. I define 'multifaction' as any game consisting of teams which does not fit with Mafia Vs. Village or a Free for All game. I define 'FFA' as any game where a significant portion of the players started out
9. I'm going to be including Big mafias within their respective sub-categories as well as in a category of their own; for cumulative win count across all categories I'm not going to double count them however
Stats: UncleSam
Won (8)
Wayne Bradiest (13/36) (Spoiler alert)
Build Your Own Mafia (43/47)
Superhero Mafia (~20/40) (Unclear precisely how many winners and the anonymous forums gone forever now)
Smogon Mafia Mafia (11/38)
Heartless Mafia (12/36)
League of Legends Mafia (27/45)
Mafia Mafia 2 (16?/42) (Someone clarify how many winners there were lol)
Fire Emblem 2 Mafia (14/50)
Lost (3)
Everybody Votes (23/40)
Pocket Monsters Mafia (25?/45) (zorbees can probably clear this up)
Dude (2/43)
Totals:
Cumulative win rate: 206/462 = 44.6%
My win rate: 8/11 = 72.7%
Wayne Bradiest (13/36) (Spoiler alert)
Build Your Own Mafia (43/47)
Superhero Mafia (~20/40) (Unclear precisely how many winners and the anonymous forums gone forever now)
Smogon Mafia Mafia (11/38)
Heartless Mafia (12/36)
League of Legends Mafia (27/45)
Mafia Mafia 2 (16?/42) (Someone clarify how many winners there were lol)
Fire Emblem 2 Mafia (14/50)
Lost (3)
Everybody Votes (23/40)
Pocket Monsters Mafia (25?/45) (zorbees can probably clear this up)
Dude (2/43)
Totals:
Cumulative win rate: 206/462 = 44.6%
My win rate: 8/11 = 72.7%
Won (4)
Dragon Ball Z TvM (12/19)
ANOCymous (10/13)
Anonymous No Contact Mafia (10/13)
NOC Desktop Dungeons Mafia (16?/20)
Lost (3)
Amnesiac Mafia Game 1 (6/9)
Fire & Ice Mafia (~2/13)
Medieval NOC Mafia (6/24)
Totals:
Cumulative win rate: 62/111 = 55.9%
My Win rate: 4/7 = 57.1%
Dragon Ball Z TvM (12/19)
ANOCymous (10/13)
Anonymous No Contact Mafia (10/13)
NOC Desktop Dungeons Mafia (16?/20)
Lost (3)
Amnesiac Mafia Game 1 (6/9)
Fire & Ice Mafia (~2/13)
Medieval NOC Mafia (6/24)
Totals:
Cumulative win rate: 62/111 = 55.9%
My Win rate: 4/7 = 57.1%
Won (7)
Dragon Mafia (9/18)
Alliance Mafia (13/25)
Animated Movie Mafia (3/25)
Metroid Other M Mafia (10/22)
Ampharos Mafia (4/25)
Smogon Mafia Mafia (11/38)
League of Legends Mafia (27/45)
Lost (7)
Curvy Bust Cream Mafia (5/13)
Ancient Mafia (8/24)
Snack Food Mafia (5/24)
Lynch Mafia (5/25)
Final Fantasy 3 Mafia (5/24)
We Don't Need No Mafia (12/29)
RPS Mafia (7/22)
Totals:
Cumulative win rate: 124/359 = 34.5%
My win rate: 7/14 = 50.0%
Dragon Mafia (9/18)
Alliance Mafia (13/25)
Animated Movie Mafia (3/25)
Metroid Other M Mafia (10/22)
Ampharos Mafia (4/25)
Smogon Mafia Mafia (11/38)
League of Legends Mafia (27/45)
Lost (7)
Curvy Bust Cream Mafia (5/13)
Ancient Mafia (8/24)
Snack Food Mafia (5/24)
Lynch Mafia (5/25)
Final Fantasy 3 Mafia (5/24)
We Don't Need No Mafia (12/29)
RPS Mafia (7/22)
Totals:
Cumulative win rate: 124/359 = 34.5%
My win rate: 7/14 = 50.0%
Won (5)
Late Summer Diplomacy (1/7)
Space War 2 (6/11)
Wayne Bradiest (13/36) (Spoiler alert)
Heartless Mafia (12/36)
Fire Emblem 2 Mafia (14/50)
Lost (6)
The Genius Game (1/12)
Wayne Bradier (6/24)
Card Game Mafia (11/30)
Dog-Eat-Dog Mafia (1/30)
Pokemon Trading Card Game Mafia (6/24)
Flow Mafia (1/21)
Totals:
Cumulative win rate: 72/281 = 25.6%
My win rate: 5/11 = 45.5%
Late Summer Diplomacy (1/7)
Space War 2 (6/11)
Wayne Bradiest (13/36) (Spoiler alert)
Heartless Mafia (12/36)
Fire Emblem 2 Mafia (14/50)
Lost (6)
The Genius Game (1/12)
Wayne Bradier (6/24)
Card Game Mafia (11/30)
Dog-Eat-Dog Mafia (1/30)
Pokemon Trading Card Game Mafia (6/24)
Flow Mafia (1/21)
Totals:
Cumulative win rate: 72/281 = 25.6%
My win rate: 5/11 = 45.5%
Won (10)
Underground Mafia (4/24)
MAGMAfia (4/20)
Aypak (13/19)
Luigi's Mansion Mafia (5/25)
Mob Mafia (16/25)
Fallout 3 Mafia (2/25)
Redwall Mafia (16/25)
Build Your Own Mafia (43/47)
Superhero Mafia (~20/40)
Mafia Mafia 2 (16?/42)
Lost (11)
ALLCAPS (4/19)
Flavorful Mafia (6/24)
ELECTRO Mafia (3/18)
Lord of the Flies Mafia (16/25)
Awesomeness Mafia (6/25)
Remoraid Mafia (6/23)
Defense of the Ancients Mafia (4/23)
Bad Character Mafia (6/22)
Everybody Votes (23/40)
Pocket Monsters Mafia (25?/45)
Dude (2/43)
Totals:
Cumulative win rate: 240/599 = 40.1%
My win rate: 10/21 = 47.6%
Underground Mafia (4/24)
MAGMAfia (4/20)
Aypak (13/19)
Luigi's Mansion Mafia (5/25)
Mob Mafia (16/25)
Fallout 3 Mafia (2/25)
Redwall Mafia (16/25)
Build Your Own Mafia (43/47)
Superhero Mafia (~20/40)
Mafia Mafia 2 (16?/42)
Lost (11)
ALLCAPS (4/19)
Flavorful Mafia (6/24)
ELECTRO Mafia (3/18)
Lord of the Flies Mafia (16/25)
Awesomeness Mafia (6/25)
Remoraid Mafia (6/23)
Defense of the Ancients Mafia (4/23)
Bad Character Mafia (6/22)
Everybody Votes (23/40)
Pocket Monsters Mafia (25?/45)
Dude (2/43)
Totals:
Cumulative win rate: 240/599 = 40.1%
My win rate: 10/21 = 47.6%
Totals across all games:
Cumulative win rate: 498/1350 = 36.9%
My win rate: 26/53 = 49.1%
Average per game: 25.5 players with 9.40 winners.
I wasn't surprised by my stats much, I know I'm worst at NOCs relative to the average and the order NOCs < Mafia Vs. Village < Multifaction < FFAs is what I'd have guessed going into this so it's interesting that the stats worked out that way.
Also worth noting that this manner of stats is a bit misleading for certain games (particularly FFAs), because some games you can do quite well in but not technically win (for example, Walrein getting second in Late Summer Diplomacy or me coming in second in The Genius Game both just count as generic losses using this reckoning). Would welcome input on better ways to keep these.
Anyway feel free to comment with your own stats, corrections to mine, or comments on changes that ought to be made in how we keep player stats. Personally I'd rather we only keep player stats for players who want the stats to be kept and who submit their stats, though if we could get a few people who review stats that would be good as well.
So ya go nuts! Calling for Walrein to show his no bich