-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
Resource RBY & Tradebacks Bug Report Thread
- Thread starter Joim
- Start date
Hey guys, I don't know the exact gen1-mechanics, so I'm not sure if this is a bug, but it seems wrong:
A previously toxiced pokemon is switched back in, toxic turns into normal poison, so far so good. It then gets seeded and leech seed drains 12% while poison does 12% damage every following turn, that means it doesn't increase after that. Just watch it yourself:
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen1customgame-233129074
I'm not sure what is supposed to happen. My guess is that poison and leech seed should both do 6% damage every turn, but maybe one of them should do increasing damage, or both.... Maybe one of you knows :)
A previously toxiced pokemon is switched back in, toxic turns into normal poison, so far so good. It then gets seeded and leech seed drains 12% while poison does 12% damage every following turn, that means it doesn't increase after that. Just watch it yourself:
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen1customgame-233129074
I'm not sure what is supposed to happen. My guess is that poison and leech seed should both do 6% damage every turn, but maybe one of them should do increasing damage, or both.... Maybe one of you knows :)
Toxic reverts to normal poison after switching out. That is not a bug.
I think he might've got confused because Leech Seed + Toxic accumulate damage when you don't switch out, and apparently when the Chansey was Seeded in the game, what occurred was normal poison (which in gen 1 does 1/16 damage each turn afaik) started doing 1/8, same as Leech Seed. EDIT: Wow I'm dumb, Isa is right. Leech Seed should do 1/16 too, so it doesn't make sense that both are doing 1/8 (I incorrectly assumed Leech Seed did 1/8 in gen 1)
I don't really know if that has to happen or not because, from what I read in Bulbapedia, what stacks is Toxic poison, not the normal one. Or maybe it just refers to mons that were hit by Toxic, meaning it's ok that Leech Seed and normal poison caused by Toxic stack. Maybe someone can try it out ingame?
I don't really know if that has to happen or not because, from what I read in Bulbapedia, what stacks is Toxic poison, not the normal one. Or maybe it just refers to mons that were hit by Toxic, meaning it's ok that Leech Seed and normal poison caused by Toxic stack. Maybe someone can try it out ingame?
Last edited:
They should be doing 6.25% each and should not stack after a switch
https://www.math.miami.edu/~jam/azure/attacks/t/toxic.htm
See the third paragraph, the counter used for toxic and leech seed that causes the glitch, becomes non-cumulative when a toxic'd mon is switched out.
https://www.math.miami.edu/~jam/azure/attacks/t/toxic.htm
See the third paragraph, the counter used for toxic and leech seed that causes the glitch, becomes non-cumulative when a toxic'd mon is switched out.
Hey guys, not sure if I understood that Paralysis/Burn stat drops stacking glitch entirely, but if a move reduces or increases a stat of a pokemon in battle and the pokemon that did not use the stat changing move is paralyzed or burned, the burn/para stat drop (atk/speed) is applied again. Is that right, or did i understand it wrong?
Anyways I belive, that in this replay, in Turn 5 Alakazam should not move first. The rest of the replay i was just trying out stuff, turns 4 and 5 are the ones that matter...
Anyways I belive, that in this replay, in Turn 5 Alakazam should not move first. The rest of the replay i was just trying out stuff, turns 4 and 5 are the ones that matter...
in that replay zam moved first cause eggy was also paralyzed, and no stat changing moves were used (psychic's drop is a secondary effect so it doesn't apply to this situation)
anyway, i run in another bug, here's a replay: http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen1ou-233864630
turn 63: +2 surf does 47% (+2 Slowbro Surf vs. Alakazam: 143-169 (45.6 - 53.9%)), and this is perfectly fine
turn 66: +4 surf does 48% (+4 Slowbro Surf vs. Alakazam: 215-253 (68.6 - 80.8%))
turns 69 and on: +6 surf does ~48-54% (+6 Slowbro Surf vs. Alakazam: 276-325 (88.1 - 103.8%))
is this some obscure mechanic i'm not aware of?
Crystal_
"Egg should've indeed moved second since Psychic's spc fall quartered zam's speed again"
Please for those (like me) who still don't undestand, explain, why EGG should move SECOND, ZAM's speed got QUARTERED.
Sorry, but in my logic the one who's speed got quartered has 4 times LESS speed than before, so why should that one still not move second?
I don't get it^^
"Egg should've indeed moved second since Psychic's spc fall quartered zam's speed again"
Please for those (like me) who still don't undestand, explain, why EGG should move SECOND, ZAM's speed got QUARTERED.
Sorry, but in my logic the one who's speed got quartered has 4 times LESS speed than before, so why should that one still not move second?
I don't get it^^
Last edited:
Hi, I'm not sure if this is something that's already known but Wrap PP is not correct, based on this battle. By my count my opponent had used Wrap 21 times when he claimed that it rolled over. This is further corroborated by the fact I did stay in on the last Wrap PP use, and my opponent had PP remaining after that.
Also manually counting PP is a monumental pain in the ass
Why exactly do people like using PS over PO again?
Also manually counting PP is a monumental pain in the ass
Why exactly do people like using PS over PO again?
because stupid shit like autobanning sleep trapping and the arbitrary 1024 turn limit
Why exactly do people like using PO over PS again? Do they enjoy downloading separate programs over their web browser?
Vastly superior teambuilder, better old gen mechanics (no disrespect Joim btw, you're doing good stuff), much more helpful battle window
Couldn't care less that it's a separate program
Just how often does the turn limit come into effect? lol
People actually want to play with sleep trapping? That's also a pretty minor concern in the scheme of things imo, even if the way it's implemented is bullshit
Couldn't care less that it's a separate program
Just how often does the turn limit come into effect? lol
People actually want to play with sleep trapping? That's also a pretty minor concern in the scheme of things imo, even if the way it's implemented is bullshit
http://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/smogtours-gen1ou-61954
zam drops starmie's special while they're both para'd and starmie is faster? fix it please. also then starmie drops zam's special as well and it turns into a speed tie between them?
zam drops starmie's special while they're both para'd and starmie is faster? fix it please. also then starmie drops zam's special as well and it turns into a speed tie between them?
EDIT: I think I've identified the problem. The speed is being quartered from the wrong target. You can see it better at turn 19. Alakazam's Psychic spc fall caused it to quarter its own speed, becoming slower than Starmie.
In the next turn (20), Starmie's Psychic spc fall caused it to quarter its own speed. Since both were at speed = floor (original speed/16) at that point, it resulted into a speed tie.
The bug at turn 9 dates back from turn 6, where zam got its speed quartered due to scoring a spc fall against a para'd starmie.
Last edited: