Intro
A few months ago I decided to start rewatching Star Trek TNG, one episode a day. I am watching the series on BluRays which my housemates recently purchased. I have seen all the episodes already at some point, but that was 5-10 years ago. I've changed a lot as a person since then and I wanted to see if the space pajama explorer brigade holds up well. Episodes were roughly watched in order, usually not more than 5 episodes out of sequence, and I did not advance seasons until all episodes of a season were completed. Generally I've avoided spoilers in this thread, but there may be some exceptions here and there if it's very important when talking about a particular episode.
Rating System
Rather than assigning a single overall number to each episode, I instead ranked nine separate elements individually to help myself identify which aspects of the episode I thought worked and which ones did not, and then combined them to give an overall score that was a bit more detached that what a singular overall impression rating would be. The nine elements I rated were personal enjoyment & rewatch value, premise, theme, character, plot & structure, dialogue, performance, production design & setpieces, and cinematgreophy & editing, with double weighting for personal enjoyment & rewatch value. This makes a total weighting of 10, resulting in scores with 2 significant figures of precision. Each of these were ranked on a 1 to 10 scale, with a "5" representing a category which I felt was standard or by the numbers, "1" representing something that was actively painful, and "10" representing a category so masterfully executed it seemed to reach beyond the screen. For Star Trek TNG some of these elements such as cinematography, editing, or production design remain fairly consistent across a particular season; however, some notable exceptions do jump out.
Season Averages
Top 25
Bottom 5
What About Seasons 5, 6, and 7?
I haven't decided yet if I'll continue watching, but I probably will. This post took quite some effort to put together, so I won't do another unless this actually generates some cool discussion. Thanks for reading.
A few months ago I decided to start rewatching Star Trek TNG, one episode a day. I am watching the series on BluRays which my housemates recently purchased. I have seen all the episodes already at some point, but that was 5-10 years ago. I've changed a lot as a person since then and I wanted to see if the space pajama explorer brigade holds up well. Episodes were roughly watched in order, usually not more than 5 episodes out of sequence, and I did not advance seasons until all episodes of a season were completed. Generally I've avoided spoilers in this thread, but there may be some exceptions here and there if it's very important when talking about a particular episode.
Rating System
Rather than assigning a single overall number to each episode, I instead ranked nine separate elements individually to help myself identify which aspects of the episode I thought worked and which ones did not, and then combined them to give an overall score that was a bit more detached that what a singular overall impression rating would be. The nine elements I rated were personal enjoyment & rewatch value, premise, theme, character, plot & structure, dialogue, performance, production design & setpieces, and cinematgreophy & editing, with double weighting for personal enjoyment & rewatch value. This makes a total weighting of 10, resulting in scores with 2 significant figures of precision. Each of these were ranked on a 1 to 10 scale, with a "5" representing a category which I felt was standard or by the numbers, "1" representing something that was actively painful, and "10" representing a category so masterfully executed it seemed to reach beyond the screen. For Star Trek TNG some of these elements such as cinematography, editing, or production design remain fairly consistent across a particular season; however, some notable exceptions do jump out.
Season Averages
S1: 5.74
Perhaps unsurprisingly S1 was rated the lowest of the four seasons I watched. The first half of S1 especially has few to no notable episodes, and many that are fairly awful. It's very clear that the production team was still in the process of figuring out what they wanted the show to be, with scripts that feel like they were taken from the original Star Trek, complete with clunky dialogue and filmed by talent behind the camera that often lingers on shots and lacks a budget to rise to their imaginations. There are also an abundance of Wesley episodes here, but regardless of how you feel about the character the number is so high it feels forced and causes a lack of variety. There are some gems here though, with strong premises and characters, rounded out with creativity. The Neutral Zone, Heart of Glory, and Symbiosis are especially notable, getting ratings of 7.0 or better.
S2: 6.47
Despite several bad episodes, including the worst episode I watched, there are also several strong episodes here too. The show seemed to figure out that focusing more on characters like Data or Riker can be a lot of fun. Dr. Pulaski replaces Dr. Crusher for this season, and her unique personality as well as her arc with Data were a standout. This season features two of the most famous Star Trek TNG episodes: Measure of a Man and Q Who which both feature excellent scenes with the recurring character Guinan, but also many fun and forgotten gems such as Peak Performance, Contagion, and Manhunt.
S3: 7.22
Where in S1 good episodes were a rarity, by S3 the reverse was true. Even the worst episodes in S3 are competent or enjoyable for what they aimed for. The writers also seemed much more confident at this point, building narratives that introduce completely new side characters such as Barclay, or juggle multiple characters at once such as in The Enemy. Cinematography, editing, and production design are all aspects that notably improved over time since S1, featuring more diverse sets, more engaging camerawork and framing, and away missions to planets that aren't just monocrome backdrop behind rocks on what is clearly a small sound stage. Episodes types also become more complex, featuring several narratives that offer something new to the pallet other than interspecies negotiations or an ethical dilemma, culminating in a season finale with what may be the greatest cliffhanger of all time.
S4: 7.27
S4 managed to keep the high standard set in S3, continuing to tell a wide range of narratives with distinct character or thematic focuses. Many guest characters were brought back such as Lwaxana, O'Brian, and Barclay, giving them excellent episodes that focused on further exploration of their characters. The trend of diving further into the Federations adversaries such as the Romulans, the Klingons, and now the Cardassians made for many compelling stories and tense moments. But most importantly, interspersed between them all were some very powerful episodes which expertly dissect a particular theme or character flaw in context of a larger engaging narrative.
Perhaps unsurprisingly S1 was rated the lowest of the four seasons I watched. The first half of S1 especially has few to no notable episodes, and many that are fairly awful. It's very clear that the production team was still in the process of figuring out what they wanted the show to be, with scripts that feel like they were taken from the original Star Trek, complete with clunky dialogue and filmed by talent behind the camera that often lingers on shots and lacks a budget to rise to their imaginations. There are also an abundance of Wesley episodes here, but regardless of how you feel about the character the number is so high it feels forced and causes a lack of variety. There are some gems here though, with strong premises and characters, rounded out with creativity. The Neutral Zone, Heart of Glory, and Symbiosis are especially notable, getting ratings of 7.0 or better.
S2: 6.47
Despite several bad episodes, including the worst episode I watched, there are also several strong episodes here too. The show seemed to figure out that focusing more on characters like Data or Riker can be a lot of fun. Dr. Pulaski replaces Dr. Crusher for this season, and her unique personality as well as her arc with Data were a standout. This season features two of the most famous Star Trek TNG episodes: Measure of a Man and Q Who which both feature excellent scenes with the recurring character Guinan, but also many fun and forgotten gems such as Peak Performance, Contagion, and Manhunt.
S3: 7.22
Where in S1 good episodes were a rarity, by S3 the reverse was true. Even the worst episodes in S3 are competent or enjoyable for what they aimed for. The writers also seemed much more confident at this point, building narratives that introduce completely new side characters such as Barclay, or juggle multiple characters at once such as in The Enemy. Cinematography, editing, and production design are all aspects that notably improved over time since S1, featuring more diverse sets, more engaging camerawork and framing, and away missions to planets that aren't just monocrome backdrop behind rocks on what is clearly a small sound stage. Episodes types also become more complex, featuring several narratives that offer something new to the pallet other than interspecies negotiations or an ethical dilemma, culminating in a season finale with what may be the greatest cliffhanger of all time.
S4: 7.27
S4 managed to keep the high standard set in S3, continuing to tell a wide range of narratives with distinct character or thematic focuses. Many guest characters were brought back such as Lwaxana, O'Brian, and Barclay, giving them excellent episodes that focused on further exploration of their characters. The trend of diving further into the Federations adversaries such as the Romulans, the Klingons, and now the Cardassians made for many compelling stories and tense moments. But most importantly, interspersed between them all were some very powerful episodes which expertly dissect a particular theme or character flaw in context of a larger engaging narrative.
Top 25
#: 25
Night Terrors
Rating: 7.5
Episode: S4 EP17
Episode Type: Mystery & Escape from a Problem
Character Focus: Troi
Logline: The Enterprise investigates a derelict starship while Deanna Troi has strange dreams.
This is a bit of a guilty pleasure episode and I don't imagine it making most people's lists. The episode doesn't have much to say thematically, but it remains an engaging, mysterious, and eerie science fiction story with nice little moments of discovery. Possibly the most spooky TNG episode too.
#: 24
Elementary, Dear Data
Rating: 7.5
Episode: S2 EP3
Episode Type: Mystery & Escape from a Problem
Character Focus: Data
Logline: A holographic adversary is created on the holodeck of the Enterprise when Data and Geordi take some time off to play a Sherlock Holmes game.
An episode about if an artificial intelligence has the capacity for intuition. While it doesn't fully explore the theme it presents, there are many fun moments from Geordi's frustrations over Data having the solutions to the mysteries already memorized, to Data being eager to prove to Pulaski that he has the capacity for deduction and creativity, to Geordi's realization at the magnitude and error of requesting an advisory capable of defeating Data.
#: 23
Pen Pals
Rating: 7.5
Episode: S2 EP15
Episode Type: Ethical Dilemma
Character Focus: Data & Wesley
Logline: Acting Ensign Wesley Crusher learns to manage a science team as Data helps a young girl on a troubled planet in potential violation of Starfleet's Prime Directive.
This is a strong contender for being one of the best episodes regarding the Prime Directive: Starfleet's general order #1 which states that it is unethical to intervene in the culture or natural progression of another society. Data attempts to save a child's planet which is threatened by cataclysmic volcanic activity once she sends out what he ultimately concludes is a distress call. It has many touching moments between an android with no feelings yet intent on a mission of mercy, and a thankful child who tragically can never meet or know who has risked so much to save her.
#: 22
Half A Life
Rating: 7.6
Episode: S4 EP22
Episode Type: Ethical Dilemma
Character Focus: Lwaxana
Logline: Lwaxana Troi falls in love with Timicin, a Kaelon scientist who is attempting to test his theories of stellar ignition in the hopes of saving his world's dying star, but as he is about to turn sixty years of age, he prepares instead for a ritual suicide.
A powerful episode about growing old, living life to the fullest, and the responsibilities a society has to its elderly.
#: 21
First Contact
Rating: 7.6
Episode: S4 EP15
Episode Type: Interspecies Negotiations
Character Focus: Riker & Picard
Logline: During an away mission to observe a pre-warp civilization, Commander Riker is injured and brought to a hospital, where the locals quickly realize he is not from their world.
Not to be confused with the awful feature film of the same title, this is an episode about society fearing what is different and what it does not understand. This is one of the few episodes where the logistics of interacting with an alien culture are explored in detail, as well as the impact it has on progressive vs. conservative values.
#: 20
A Matter of Honor
Rating: 7.6
Episode: S2 EP8
Episode Type: Interspecies Negotiations
Character Focus: Riker
Logline: Commander Riker is assigned to temporarily be the first officer aboard a Klingon vessel as part of an officer exchange program.
An exciting and funny adventure hosted by Commander Riker as he learns what it takes to be a Klingon officer. He eats alien food, makes crude jokes with the crew, and has to outwit his trigger-happy commanding officer. There's fun insight into an alien culture and a plot that culminates to a tense confrontation with the Enterprise.
#: 19
Where Silence Has Lease
Rating: 7.7
Episode: S2 EP2
Episode Type: Mystery & Escape from a Problem
Character Focus: Various
Logline: The Enterprise becomes enveloped by a void in space where the crew is tested by a powerful alien presence.
This episode is a bit of a guilty pleasure that rides mostly on a really cool premise, eerie moments, and the crew being messed with as they try to escape. To be fair though, the central conflict builds nicely and our lead characters respond in reasonable, relatable ways. A few moments of dialogue are overwritten and the episode teeters into philosophy class for a couple brief moments, but overall it's highly enjoyable.
#: 18
Redemption, Part I
Rating: 7.7
Episode: S4 EP26
Episode Type: Cinematic Exterior Threat
Character Focus: Worf & Picard
Logline: As Captain Picard travels to the Klingon homeworld to oversee Gowron's installation as leader of the High Council, Worf meets with Gowron and offers him the support of an alliance of Klingon warships led by his brother Kurn, if Gowron will restore his family's honor.
A worthy season finale and the final episode I watched. The plot is focused on Worf and Picard's involvement in the early stages of a Klingon civil war, building on the foundation set by several previous episodes. There are great little moments where our lead characters must balance personal desires with their professional and ethical obligations, complete with exciting twists and bursts of action.
#: 17
Allegiance
Rating: 7.7
Episode: S3 EP18
Episode Type: Mystery & Escape from a Problem
Character Focus: Picard
Logline: Captain Picard finds himself abducted from the Enterprise and held in a chamber with other prisoners, while a doppelgänger replacing him behaves strangely and gives increasingly disturbing orders.
This episode rides a strong science fiction premise about different cultures explicitly selected to quarrel amongst each other needing to work together to escape their imprisonment. While the episode doesn't attempt to say anything profound or tell a complex story, it does effectively explore the basics of response to authority within a narrative that is, more importantly, engaging and clever.
#: 16
Deja Q
Rating: 7.7
Episode: S3 EP13
Episode Type: Visitor on the Enterprise
Character Focus: Q
Logline: The starship Enterprise D struggles to prevent a moon from falling out of orbit, their situation is further complicated by a visit from a powerful nemesis named "Q", who informs them that he has been stripped of all his powers and must live out a mortal life.
A slice of life story about what happens when a god has to learn how to live life as a human. Between learning what it means to be human and developing a sense of empathy there are many fun moments such as Q being afraid of falling asleep, ordering ten ice cream sundays for dinner, and giving Data his first ever moment of laughter.
#: 15
Sarek
Rating: 7.8
Episode: S3 EP23
Episode Type: Visitor on the Enterprise
Character Focus: Picard
Logline: Sarek, the father of Spock and a highly regarded but elderly ambassador, is ferried by the Enterprise on his final mission for the Federation. While he is aboard the ship, the crew experiences an outbreak of irrational anger amongst themselves.
Sarek is a powerful episode about living with and accepting a terminal degenerative disease, and how it impacts your career, your loved ones, and your legacy. The performances and dialogue are some of the best in Star Trek TNG, backed up by strong characters and touching themes.
#: 14
Qpid
Rating: 7.8
Episode: S4 EP20
Episode Type: Visitor on the Enterprise
Character Focus: Picard
Logline: Captain Picard and Vash are reunited when the Enterprise hosts an archaeology symposium, but their disparate personalities soon have them sparring as Q arrives to offers Captain Picard a favor.
This episode has good narrative structure, some smart dialogue, and a relationship between Picard and Vash that is grounded, subtle, and highly relatable. As a Starfleet Captain and by his character Picard is private man that a more outgoing Vash sees as him being embarrassed or ashamed by her. More drama is added in the form of Picard's ethics and strict conscious being in conflict with Vash's disregard for rules and bounty hunter-like lifestyle. The theme isn't explored much beyond the identification of Picard's affinity for Vash being a fault, and some of Q's dialogue when discussing women has not aged well, although some of this may have been intentional.
#: 13
The Enemy
Rating: 7.8
Episode: S3 EP7
Episode Type: Interspecies Negotiations
Character Focus: Geordi, Worf, & Picard
Logline: Geordi La Forge is trapped on an inhospitable planet with a Romulan as Lt. Worf is faced with a conflict between his duty as a Starfleet officer and his Klingon prejudice against Romulans as Captain Picard must contend with a Romulan warbird intent on recovering their own personnel.
A great episode that comments on racism, xenophobia, and nationalism. With great effort and at personal sacrifice Geordi manages to open an enemy's eyes, while another challenges Worf's own prejudices. Picard must also walk a careful tightrope between preventing war with the Romulans and safeguarding those he is responsible for.
#: 12
Family
Rating: 7.9
Episode: S4 EP2
Episode Type: Complex
Character Focus: Picard, Worf, & Wesley
Logline: The Enterprise is docked at Earth as Captain Picard visits his brother's family in France, Wesley Crusher views a holographic recording made by his deceased father, and Lt. Worf's adoptive parents come on board the Enterprise to comfort him following his discommendation.
One of the stronger character driven episodes, Family doesn't have much action or plot, but throughly explores the resentments and sadness amidst belonging and support that comes with one's family. Coming off of The Best of Both Worlds this is a great episode to slow down and have our characters take a look at who they are, how they got here, and where they want to be. The relationships here are simple and grounded, but still have more than enough behind them to feel genuine and touching.
#: 11
Who Watches the Watchers
Rating: 8.1
Episode: S3 EP4
Episode Type: Ethical Dilemma
Character Focus: Picard
Logline: The Enterprise must undo the damage when a primitive civilization discovers a Federation observation team and concludes that the Starfleet personnel are gods.
A brilliant episode that juggles an ethical dilemma with themes that deconstruct the fear and irrationality that comes from belief in the supernatural. Picard must convince a civilization that he is not a god and is just as mortal as them; that he is simply a product of a more developed society whose "magic" is merely technology. In a very simple and engaging way the narrative effortlessly shows how even rational people can quickly be brought to hasty and destructive action when they submit to superstition after being confronted with that which they do not understand.
#: 10
Booby Trap
Rating: 8.2
Episode: S3 EP6
Episode Type: Mystery and Escape from a Problem
Character Focus: Geordi
Logline: The Enterprise discovers a derelict centuries-old alien battlecruiser that fell victim to an ancient booby trap, which the Enterprise also becomes trapped by.
An all around great episode that skillfully connects an engaging and exciting plot with simple themes through the use of action and smart dialogue. Geordi learns the age old lesson regarding relationships to simply be himself, but not before requiring Guinan's wisdom, a complex computer simulation of the designer of the Enterprise's engines, and for him to overcome a technically challenging and life-threatening engineering problem. There are many other little moments, such as Picard's excitement over the archeological significance of the battlecruiser, and awe at primitive exploration which is realized in the climax of the episode as he alone navigates the Enterprise from danger using only two thrusters.
#: 9
Future Imperfect
Rating: 8.2
Episode: S3 EP8
Episode Type: Mystery and Escape from a Problem
Character Focus: Riker
Logline: During an away mission, Riker falls unconscious and awakens to discover that sixteen years have passed, and he is now captain of the Enterprise. Having no memory whatsoever of the time that has passed, he begins to suspect that the future he finds himself in may not be real.
One of the earlier (and better) science fiction film / TV episodes to feature a simulation within a simulation. This episodes lives up to its premise with a tight plot punctuated by the two moments when Riker realizes the deception. Riker handles the brutal concept of being trapped in Plato's Cave quite well, responding in intelligent, and more importantly, relatable ways. Although a bit comical in execution the conclusion has a nice sentiment, and a satisfying resolution to a premise that many lesser narratives don't quite live up to.
#: 8
Clues
Rating: 8.3
Episode: S4 EP14
Episode Type: Picking up the Pieces of a Mystery
Character Focus: Data & Picard
Logline: While en route to investigate a mysterious planet the entire crew, with the exception of Data, is rendered unconscious by an apparent wormhole. After they revive, Data explains they were unconscious for thirty seconds but a variety of clues seem to indicate that he is lying.
One of the best mystery episodes of TNG so far, this episode effortlessly handles many different plot points and pieces of evidence to build a fairly complex narrative that is fascinating to watch unfold. Greater still is this episode has excellent rewatch value, with the twist bringing new perspective to Data's actions and performance. Ultimately it presents a highly satisfying resolution and a powerful moment of revelation, which many other TV mysteries fail to deliver on.
#: 7
Data's Day
Rating: 8.3
Episode: S4 EP14
Episode Type: Visitor on the Enterprise
Character Focus: Data
Logline: As Data contemplates the impending marriage of his friend Keiko Ishikawa he investigates the apparent death of the Vulcan ambassador whom the Enterprise was ferrying to the Neutral Zone in order to conduct negotiations with the Romulans.
A slice of life episode that revolves around Data cataloging his experiences for his former adversary Bruce Maddox. Many small moments of joy, laughter, and tension manage to produce a result that, much like Data, is more than just a sum of its parts. The dialogue, narrative structure, and themes are among the sharpest of TNG episodes thus far, never imposing, only there to be seen by those that want to engage with them.
#: 6
Q Who
Rating: 8.3
Episode: S2 EP16
Episode Type: Cinematic Exterior Threat
Character Focus: Picard
Logline: The omnipotent entity known as "Q" arrives on the Enterprise and sends the ship across the galaxy where the crew make first contact with the cybernetically enhanced assimilating race known as the Borg.
The origin story for the Borg, and a strong episode about the complacency and arrogance that even explorers can find themselves possessing. The premise of the Borg is intriguing, and is an excellent thematic opposition / antagonist to the self-determining, individual-centric humans of the Federation. Everything to the production design, stark cinematography, and eerie score impart a distinct and ominous tone that is hard to forget, and the episode crams it all into a package just as dense as a Borg cube.
#: 5
The Mind's Eye
Rating: 8.4
Episode: S4 EP24
Episode Type: Interspecies Negotiations
Character Focus: Geordi
Logline: Geordi La Forge sets out for a vacation on Risa, but his shuttle is apprehended by Romulans who hope to use him in a plot to drive a wedge between the Federation and its Klingon allies.
A fantastic episode that effortlessly offers a complete package of alien negotiations, a compelling mystery, action and suspense, and a perturbing takeaway. The plot builds exceptionally well, leaving each act with greater escalation and momentum that culminates in Data's race against time to discover the truth of what happened on Geordi's trip to Risa and the meaning of the mysterious E-Band signals on board. There's even brief moments of stylistic cinematography as well as exceptional visual storytelling which further elevate this episode to something truly special.
#: 4
The Defector
Rating: 8.5
Episode: S3 EP10
Episode Type: Visitor on the Enterprise
Character Focus: Various
Logline: A Romulan defector requests asylum aboard the Enterprise after claiming to possess vital information about an imminent Romulan invasion.
This episode centers around a Romulan officer who claims of an impending invasion, and the extent to which his information can be trusted. There are many effective twists and turns, interspersed with pieces of evidence being examined and questions, all amidst the emotion that comes with a man who abandoned his home, family, and people to prevent a possible war. The climax with a Romulan encounter is among the best in TNG.
#: 3
The Drumhead
Rating: 8.7
Episode: S4 EP10
Episode Type: Ethical Dilemma
Character Focus: Various
Logline: An explosion aboard the Enterprise leads to a high-level investigation headed by Admiral Norah Satie, a retired officer renowned for her skill at exposing conspiracies.
Perhaps the ultimate Picard episode that culminates in the ultimate Picard speech, The Drumhead is about the ethics of conspiratorial investigation, how that can impede or nullify human rights and freedoms, and the dangers of a fearful and distrustful regime determined to snuff out any and all opposition no matter the cost. In the end vigilance is the price that is paid, a vigilance upheld by not underestimating the value in the opinions of professional and of first-hand sources.
#: 2
The Measure of a Man
Rating: 8.8
Episode: S2 EP10
Episode Type: Ethical Dilemma
Character Focus: Data & Picard
Logline: The rights of the android officer Lt. Commander Data are threatened by a scientist who wishes to dismantle him in order to produce replicas of him.
A courtroom examination of what it means to be man or machine. This idea is explored much further by questioning if an emergent life form of technology is entitled to the same rights as a biological life form, and the implications of what it would mean if they were not. Dialogue is top notch, particularly in articulating the various facets of the issues. It remains engaging and exciting, despite mostly taking place in a single room with a small cast of characters.
#: 1
The Best of Both Worlds, Part I
Rating: 9.1
Episode: S3 EP26
Episode Type: Cinematic Exterior Threat
Character Focus: Riker
Logline: The Enterprise must battle the Borg who are intent on conquering Earth, with a captured and assimilated Captain Picard as their emissary.
I really wasn't expecting this to end up being my highest rated episode, but it's masterfully done on every front. The core of the episode is about Riker trying to figure out where he truly wants to be: to take command of his own ship and continue to pursue ambition, or to be content with his position on the Enterprise. Riker is trapped in a very relatable dilemma, one which may be the most important decision many people, especially those early in their careers, find themselves in. Fear and anxiety over not pursuing your greatest potential, or the risk of giving up the happiness which you've obtained so far. Riker sees the change in himself and his dwindling ambition when confronted by Commander Shelby, an up and coming officer who's an expert on the Borg, and who has the fire and rashness that he once did. In an exciting series of events which culminate in an epic encounter with the Borg, Picard is captured and assimilated, leaving Riker with the best of both worlds: becoming captain, and his command being the Enterprise.
Night Terrors
Rating: 7.5
Episode: S4 EP17
Episode Type: Mystery & Escape from a Problem
Character Focus: Troi
Logline: The Enterprise investigates a derelict starship while Deanna Troi has strange dreams.
This is a bit of a guilty pleasure episode and I don't imagine it making most people's lists. The episode doesn't have much to say thematically, but it remains an engaging, mysterious, and eerie science fiction story with nice little moments of discovery. Possibly the most spooky TNG episode too.
#: 24
Elementary, Dear Data
Rating: 7.5
Episode: S2 EP3
Episode Type: Mystery & Escape from a Problem
Character Focus: Data
Logline: A holographic adversary is created on the holodeck of the Enterprise when Data and Geordi take some time off to play a Sherlock Holmes game.
An episode about if an artificial intelligence has the capacity for intuition. While it doesn't fully explore the theme it presents, there are many fun moments from Geordi's frustrations over Data having the solutions to the mysteries already memorized, to Data being eager to prove to Pulaski that he has the capacity for deduction and creativity, to Geordi's realization at the magnitude and error of requesting an advisory capable of defeating Data.
#: 23
Pen Pals
Rating: 7.5
Episode: S2 EP15
Episode Type: Ethical Dilemma
Character Focus: Data & Wesley
Logline: Acting Ensign Wesley Crusher learns to manage a science team as Data helps a young girl on a troubled planet in potential violation of Starfleet's Prime Directive.
This is a strong contender for being one of the best episodes regarding the Prime Directive: Starfleet's general order #1 which states that it is unethical to intervene in the culture or natural progression of another society. Data attempts to save a child's planet which is threatened by cataclysmic volcanic activity once she sends out what he ultimately concludes is a distress call. It has many touching moments between an android with no feelings yet intent on a mission of mercy, and a thankful child who tragically can never meet or know who has risked so much to save her.
#: 22
Half A Life
Rating: 7.6
Episode: S4 EP22
Episode Type: Ethical Dilemma
Character Focus: Lwaxana
Logline: Lwaxana Troi falls in love with Timicin, a Kaelon scientist who is attempting to test his theories of stellar ignition in the hopes of saving his world's dying star, but as he is about to turn sixty years of age, he prepares instead for a ritual suicide.
A powerful episode about growing old, living life to the fullest, and the responsibilities a society has to its elderly.
#: 21
First Contact
Rating: 7.6
Episode: S4 EP15
Episode Type: Interspecies Negotiations
Character Focus: Riker & Picard
Logline: During an away mission to observe a pre-warp civilization, Commander Riker is injured and brought to a hospital, where the locals quickly realize he is not from their world.
Not to be confused with the awful feature film of the same title, this is an episode about society fearing what is different and what it does not understand. This is one of the few episodes where the logistics of interacting with an alien culture are explored in detail, as well as the impact it has on progressive vs. conservative values.
#: 20
A Matter of Honor
Rating: 7.6
Episode: S2 EP8
Episode Type: Interspecies Negotiations
Character Focus: Riker
Logline: Commander Riker is assigned to temporarily be the first officer aboard a Klingon vessel as part of an officer exchange program.
An exciting and funny adventure hosted by Commander Riker as he learns what it takes to be a Klingon officer. He eats alien food, makes crude jokes with the crew, and has to outwit his trigger-happy commanding officer. There's fun insight into an alien culture and a plot that culminates to a tense confrontation with the Enterprise.
#: 19
Where Silence Has Lease
Rating: 7.7
Episode: S2 EP2
Episode Type: Mystery & Escape from a Problem
Character Focus: Various
Logline: The Enterprise becomes enveloped by a void in space where the crew is tested by a powerful alien presence.
This episode is a bit of a guilty pleasure that rides mostly on a really cool premise, eerie moments, and the crew being messed with as they try to escape. To be fair though, the central conflict builds nicely and our lead characters respond in reasonable, relatable ways. A few moments of dialogue are overwritten and the episode teeters into philosophy class for a couple brief moments, but overall it's highly enjoyable.
#: 18
Redemption, Part I
Rating: 7.7
Episode: S4 EP26
Episode Type: Cinematic Exterior Threat
Character Focus: Worf & Picard
Logline: As Captain Picard travels to the Klingon homeworld to oversee Gowron's installation as leader of the High Council, Worf meets with Gowron and offers him the support of an alliance of Klingon warships led by his brother Kurn, if Gowron will restore his family's honor.
A worthy season finale and the final episode I watched. The plot is focused on Worf and Picard's involvement in the early stages of a Klingon civil war, building on the foundation set by several previous episodes. There are great little moments where our lead characters must balance personal desires with their professional and ethical obligations, complete with exciting twists and bursts of action.
#: 17
Allegiance
Rating: 7.7
Episode: S3 EP18
Episode Type: Mystery & Escape from a Problem
Character Focus: Picard
Logline: Captain Picard finds himself abducted from the Enterprise and held in a chamber with other prisoners, while a doppelgänger replacing him behaves strangely and gives increasingly disturbing orders.
This episode rides a strong science fiction premise about different cultures explicitly selected to quarrel amongst each other needing to work together to escape their imprisonment. While the episode doesn't attempt to say anything profound or tell a complex story, it does effectively explore the basics of response to authority within a narrative that is, more importantly, engaging and clever.
#: 16
Deja Q
Rating: 7.7
Episode: S3 EP13
Episode Type: Visitor on the Enterprise
Character Focus: Q
Logline: The starship Enterprise D struggles to prevent a moon from falling out of orbit, their situation is further complicated by a visit from a powerful nemesis named "Q", who informs them that he has been stripped of all his powers and must live out a mortal life.
A slice of life story about what happens when a god has to learn how to live life as a human. Between learning what it means to be human and developing a sense of empathy there are many fun moments such as Q being afraid of falling asleep, ordering ten ice cream sundays for dinner, and giving Data his first ever moment of laughter.
#: 15
Sarek
Rating: 7.8
Episode: S3 EP23
Episode Type: Visitor on the Enterprise
Character Focus: Picard
Logline: Sarek, the father of Spock and a highly regarded but elderly ambassador, is ferried by the Enterprise on his final mission for the Federation. While he is aboard the ship, the crew experiences an outbreak of irrational anger amongst themselves.
Sarek is a powerful episode about living with and accepting a terminal degenerative disease, and how it impacts your career, your loved ones, and your legacy. The performances and dialogue are some of the best in Star Trek TNG, backed up by strong characters and touching themes.
#: 14
Qpid
Rating: 7.8
Episode: S4 EP20
Episode Type: Visitor on the Enterprise
Character Focus: Picard
Logline: Captain Picard and Vash are reunited when the Enterprise hosts an archaeology symposium, but their disparate personalities soon have them sparring as Q arrives to offers Captain Picard a favor.
This episode has good narrative structure, some smart dialogue, and a relationship between Picard and Vash that is grounded, subtle, and highly relatable. As a Starfleet Captain and by his character Picard is private man that a more outgoing Vash sees as him being embarrassed or ashamed by her. More drama is added in the form of Picard's ethics and strict conscious being in conflict with Vash's disregard for rules and bounty hunter-like lifestyle. The theme isn't explored much beyond the identification of Picard's affinity for Vash being a fault, and some of Q's dialogue when discussing women has not aged well, although some of this may have been intentional.
#: 13
The Enemy
Rating: 7.8
Episode: S3 EP7
Episode Type: Interspecies Negotiations
Character Focus: Geordi, Worf, & Picard
Logline: Geordi La Forge is trapped on an inhospitable planet with a Romulan as Lt. Worf is faced with a conflict between his duty as a Starfleet officer and his Klingon prejudice against Romulans as Captain Picard must contend with a Romulan warbird intent on recovering their own personnel.
A great episode that comments on racism, xenophobia, and nationalism. With great effort and at personal sacrifice Geordi manages to open an enemy's eyes, while another challenges Worf's own prejudices. Picard must also walk a careful tightrope between preventing war with the Romulans and safeguarding those he is responsible for.
#: 12
Family
Rating: 7.9
Episode: S4 EP2
Episode Type: Complex
Character Focus: Picard, Worf, & Wesley
Logline: The Enterprise is docked at Earth as Captain Picard visits his brother's family in France, Wesley Crusher views a holographic recording made by his deceased father, and Lt. Worf's adoptive parents come on board the Enterprise to comfort him following his discommendation.
One of the stronger character driven episodes, Family doesn't have much action or plot, but throughly explores the resentments and sadness amidst belonging and support that comes with one's family. Coming off of The Best of Both Worlds this is a great episode to slow down and have our characters take a look at who they are, how they got here, and where they want to be. The relationships here are simple and grounded, but still have more than enough behind them to feel genuine and touching.
#: 11
Who Watches the Watchers
Rating: 8.1
Episode: S3 EP4
Episode Type: Ethical Dilemma
Character Focus: Picard
Logline: The Enterprise must undo the damage when a primitive civilization discovers a Federation observation team and concludes that the Starfleet personnel are gods.
A brilliant episode that juggles an ethical dilemma with themes that deconstruct the fear and irrationality that comes from belief in the supernatural. Picard must convince a civilization that he is not a god and is just as mortal as them; that he is simply a product of a more developed society whose "magic" is merely technology. In a very simple and engaging way the narrative effortlessly shows how even rational people can quickly be brought to hasty and destructive action when they submit to superstition after being confronted with that which they do not understand.
#: 10
Booby Trap
Rating: 8.2
Episode: S3 EP6
Episode Type: Mystery and Escape from a Problem
Character Focus: Geordi
Logline: The Enterprise discovers a derelict centuries-old alien battlecruiser that fell victim to an ancient booby trap, which the Enterprise also becomes trapped by.
An all around great episode that skillfully connects an engaging and exciting plot with simple themes through the use of action and smart dialogue. Geordi learns the age old lesson regarding relationships to simply be himself, but not before requiring Guinan's wisdom, a complex computer simulation of the designer of the Enterprise's engines, and for him to overcome a technically challenging and life-threatening engineering problem. There are many other little moments, such as Picard's excitement over the archeological significance of the battlecruiser, and awe at primitive exploration which is realized in the climax of the episode as he alone navigates the Enterprise from danger using only two thrusters.
#: 9
Future Imperfect
Rating: 8.2
Episode: S3 EP8
Episode Type: Mystery and Escape from a Problem
Character Focus: Riker
Logline: During an away mission, Riker falls unconscious and awakens to discover that sixteen years have passed, and he is now captain of the Enterprise. Having no memory whatsoever of the time that has passed, he begins to suspect that the future he finds himself in may not be real.
One of the earlier (and better) science fiction film / TV episodes to feature a simulation within a simulation. This episodes lives up to its premise with a tight plot punctuated by the two moments when Riker realizes the deception. Riker handles the brutal concept of being trapped in Plato's Cave quite well, responding in intelligent, and more importantly, relatable ways. Although a bit comical in execution the conclusion has a nice sentiment, and a satisfying resolution to a premise that many lesser narratives don't quite live up to.
#: 8
Clues
Rating: 8.3
Episode: S4 EP14
Episode Type: Picking up the Pieces of a Mystery
Character Focus: Data & Picard
Logline: While en route to investigate a mysterious planet the entire crew, with the exception of Data, is rendered unconscious by an apparent wormhole. After they revive, Data explains they were unconscious for thirty seconds but a variety of clues seem to indicate that he is lying.
One of the best mystery episodes of TNG so far, this episode effortlessly handles many different plot points and pieces of evidence to build a fairly complex narrative that is fascinating to watch unfold. Greater still is this episode has excellent rewatch value, with the twist bringing new perspective to Data's actions and performance. Ultimately it presents a highly satisfying resolution and a powerful moment of revelation, which many other TV mysteries fail to deliver on.
#: 7
Data's Day
Rating: 8.3
Episode: S4 EP14
Episode Type: Visitor on the Enterprise
Character Focus: Data
Logline: As Data contemplates the impending marriage of his friend Keiko Ishikawa he investigates the apparent death of the Vulcan ambassador whom the Enterprise was ferrying to the Neutral Zone in order to conduct negotiations with the Romulans.
A slice of life episode that revolves around Data cataloging his experiences for his former adversary Bruce Maddox. Many small moments of joy, laughter, and tension manage to produce a result that, much like Data, is more than just a sum of its parts. The dialogue, narrative structure, and themes are among the sharpest of TNG episodes thus far, never imposing, only there to be seen by those that want to engage with them.
#: 6
Q Who
Rating: 8.3
Episode: S2 EP16
Episode Type: Cinematic Exterior Threat
Character Focus: Picard
Logline: The omnipotent entity known as "Q" arrives on the Enterprise and sends the ship across the galaxy where the crew make first contact with the cybernetically enhanced assimilating race known as the Borg.
The origin story for the Borg, and a strong episode about the complacency and arrogance that even explorers can find themselves possessing. The premise of the Borg is intriguing, and is an excellent thematic opposition / antagonist to the self-determining, individual-centric humans of the Federation. Everything to the production design, stark cinematography, and eerie score impart a distinct and ominous tone that is hard to forget, and the episode crams it all into a package just as dense as a Borg cube.
#: 5
The Mind's Eye
Rating: 8.4
Episode: S4 EP24
Episode Type: Interspecies Negotiations
Character Focus: Geordi
Logline: Geordi La Forge sets out for a vacation on Risa, but his shuttle is apprehended by Romulans who hope to use him in a plot to drive a wedge between the Federation and its Klingon allies.
A fantastic episode that effortlessly offers a complete package of alien negotiations, a compelling mystery, action and suspense, and a perturbing takeaway. The plot builds exceptionally well, leaving each act with greater escalation and momentum that culminates in Data's race against time to discover the truth of what happened on Geordi's trip to Risa and the meaning of the mysterious E-Band signals on board. There's even brief moments of stylistic cinematography as well as exceptional visual storytelling which further elevate this episode to something truly special.
#: 4
The Defector
Rating: 8.5
Episode: S3 EP10
Episode Type: Visitor on the Enterprise
Character Focus: Various
Logline: A Romulan defector requests asylum aboard the Enterprise after claiming to possess vital information about an imminent Romulan invasion.
This episode centers around a Romulan officer who claims of an impending invasion, and the extent to which his information can be trusted. There are many effective twists and turns, interspersed with pieces of evidence being examined and questions, all amidst the emotion that comes with a man who abandoned his home, family, and people to prevent a possible war. The climax with a Romulan encounter is among the best in TNG.
#: 3
The Drumhead
Rating: 8.7
Episode: S4 EP10
Episode Type: Ethical Dilemma
Character Focus: Various
Logline: An explosion aboard the Enterprise leads to a high-level investigation headed by Admiral Norah Satie, a retired officer renowned for her skill at exposing conspiracies.
Perhaps the ultimate Picard episode that culminates in the ultimate Picard speech, The Drumhead is about the ethics of conspiratorial investigation, how that can impede or nullify human rights and freedoms, and the dangers of a fearful and distrustful regime determined to snuff out any and all opposition no matter the cost. In the end vigilance is the price that is paid, a vigilance upheld by not underestimating the value in the opinions of professional and of first-hand sources.
#: 2
The Measure of a Man
Rating: 8.8
Episode: S2 EP10
Episode Type: Ethical Dilemma
Character Focus: Data & Picard
Logline: The rights of the android officer Lt. Commander Data are threatened by a scientist who wishes to dismantle him in order to produce replicas of him.
A courtroom examination of what it means to be man or machine. This idea is explored much further by questioning if an emergent life form of technology is entitled to the same rights as a biological life form, and the implications of what it would mean if they were not. Dialogue is top notch, particularly in articulating the various facets of the issues. It remains engaging and exciting, despite mostly taking place in a single room with a small cast of characters.
#: 1
The Best of Both Worlds, Part I
Rating: 9.1
Episode: S3 EP26
Episode Type: Cinematic Exterior Threat
Character Focus: Riker
Logline: The Enterprise must battle the Borg who are intent on conquering Earth, with a captured and assimilated Captain Picard as their emissary.
I really wasn't expecting this to end up being my highest rated episode, but it's masterfully done on every front. The core of the episode is about Riker trying to figure out where he truly wants to be: to take command of his own ship and continue to pursue ambition, or to be content with his position on the Enterprise. Riker is trapped in a very relatable dilemma, one which may be the most important decision many people, especially those early in their careers, find themselves in. Fear and anxiety over not pursuing your greatest potential, or the risk of giving up the happiness which you've obtained so far. Riker sees the change in himself and his dwindling ambition when confronted by Commander Shelby, an up and coming officer who's an expert on the Borg, and who has the fire and rashness that he once did. In an exciting series of events which culminate in an epic encounter with the Borg, Picard is captured and assimilated, leaving Riker with the best of both worlds: becoming captain, and his command being the Enterprise.
Bottom 5
The Battle
Rating: 4.0
Episode: S1 EP9
Episode Type: Interspecies Negotiations
Character Focus: Picard
Logline: Captain Picard is given his former vessel, the Stargazer, as a gift by the Ferengi DaiMon Bok who intends to use it to take revenge.
This is mostly just a boring episode where Picard has headaches and PTSD flashbacks caused by a glowing revenge orb. The Ferengi aren't a very compelling antagonist in this episode, and not a lot happens, nor does the episode have anything to say about worthwhile topics such as living with PTSD or the destructive futility of vengeance.
The Naked Now
Rating: 3.7
Episode: S1 EP9
Episode Type: Interspecies Negotiations
Character Focus: Picard
Logline: The Enterprise encounters a research ship where all personnel are found dead before the crew quickly become infected with the same affliction.
Frustrating at times and borderline sexist. A drunk Wesley essentially takes control of the Enterprise while it's at risk of being destroyed while every female crew member releases their sexual inhibitions. The frozen people are cool though.
Angel One
Rating: 3.5
Episode: S1 EP14
Episode Type: Interspecies Negotiations
Character Focus: Various
Logline: An away team visits a world dominated by women to search for survivors of a downed freighter, while the crew of the Enterprise suffer from the effects of a debilitating virus.
Despite a premise that has been done so many times before, this could be a worthwhile premise to explore, especially for Star Trek, but the execution ranges from awful to outright sexist. Beyond this there are occasional out of place moments of awkward romance.
Hide and Q
Rating: 3.5
Episode: S1 EP10
Episode Type: Visitor on the Enterprise
Character Focus: Riker
Logline: Q returns to the Enterprise and transports the bridge crew to a landscape where they are attacked by humanoids and grants Commander Riker the powers of the Q Continuum.
Not a surprise that 4/5 of the worst episodes are from the first half of S1. The crew of the Enterprise occasionally battles silly monsters on a terrible sound stage. Riker's transformation into a power-hungry arrogant person is so abrupt and cliched it goes beyond comical. The stated theme of "absolute power corrupts absolutely" is plain wrong, and shows a complete lack of understanding in regards to how power actually influences a person's choices or persona.
Shades of Gray
Rating: 1.8
Episode: S2 EP22
Episode Type: Clip Show
Character Focus: Riker
Logline: Commander Riker undergoes medical treatment by Dr. Pulaski for an alien infection and must relive numerous past events.
It's a clip show. I hesitate to call this the worst TNG episode if only because I'm not sure it actually qualifies to be called an episode.
Rating: 4.0
Episode: S1 EP9
Episode Type: Interspecies Negotiations
Character Focus: Picard
Logline: Captain Picard is given his former vessel, the Stargazer, as a gift by the Ferengi DaiMon Bok who intends to use it to take revenge.
This is mostly just a boring episode where Picard has headaches and PTSD flashbacks caused by a glowing revenge orb. The Ferengi aren't a very compelling antagonist in this episode, and not a lot happens, nor does the episode have anything to say about worthwhile topics such as living with PTSD or the destructive futility of vengeance.
The Naked Now
Rating: 3.7
Episode: S1 EP9
Episode Type: Interspecies Negotiations
Character Focus: Picard
Logline: The Enterprise encounters a research ship where all personnel are found dead before the crew quickly become infected with the same affliction.
Frustrating at times and borderline sexist. A drunk Wesley essentially takes control of the Enterprise while it's at risk of being destroyed while every female crew member releases their sexual inhibitions. The frozen people are cool though.
Angel One
Rating: 3.5
Episode: S1 EP14
Episode Type: Interspecies Negotiations
Character Focus: Various
Logline: An away team visits a world dominated by women to search for survivors of a downed freighter, while the crew of the Enterprise suffer from the effects of a debilitating virus.
Despite a premise that has been done so many times before, this could be a worthwhile premise to explore, especially for Star Trek, but the execution ranges from awful to outright sexist. Beyond this there are occasional out of place moments of awkward romance.
Hide and Q
Rating: 3.5
Episode: S1 EP10
Episode Type: Visitor on the Enterprise
Character Focus: Riker
Logline: Q returns to the Enterprise and transports the bridge crew to a landscape where they are attacked by humanoids and grants Commander Riker the powers of the Q Continuum.
Not a surprise that 4/5 of the worst episodes are from the first half of S1. The crew of the Enterprise occasionally battles silly monsters on a terrible sound stage. Riker's transformation into a power-hungry arrogant person is so abrupt and cliched it goes beyond comical. The stated theme of "absolute power corrupts absolutely" is plain wrong, and shows a complete lack of understanding in regards to how power actually influences a person's choices or persona.
Shades of Gray
Rating: 1.8
Episode: S2 EP22
Episode Type: Clip Show
Character Focus: Riker
Logline: Commander Riker undergoes medical treatment by Dr. Pulaski for an alien infection and must relive numerous past events.
It's a clip show. I hesitate to call this the worst TNG episode if only because I'm not sure it actually qualifies to be called an episode.
What About Seasons 5, 6, and 7?
I haven't decided yet if I'll continue watching, but I probably will. This post took quite some effort to put together, so I won't do another unless this actually generates some cool discussion. Thanks for reading.
