So basically I used the RAND() function in Excel to generate 32 random numbers between 0-1. I put them in the column next to the numbers 1-32 and then sorted the rows based on the random numbers. In short, each row number is now matched with a random number between 1 and 32. Both the god list and the signup list has a set order in the OP, so the matching is easy--the gray column represents the gods and the white column represents the users. Double check my matching if you want to, but all the players were included in the list below, so I think I did it right.