Freeroamer said:Can I ask why stuff is still being decided by council votes? I got the system straight after USM was released, and to a degree with the recent large tier shift, as these are situations in which quick and clear decisions are required to remove obviously broken elements from the tier which is the main selling point of the system. However these two Pokemon have been in the tier for a while now, certainly longer than you would expect an obviously broken or ridiculous element to stay without being removed, so why aren’t they being tested publicly? Every other tier apart from maybe Ubers uses the council selection then public voting system, so I’m just really wondering why UU is the anomaly.
Because the public test system everyone's been using and UU has used in the past has some major flaws. The one thing that makes that system "good" is the main problem with it: everyone can vote, as long as they have free time and decent level of skills. The system isn't for the top, knowledgeable players, it's for the people who can grind on the ladder. The general opinion of the "top players" (ie: the ones actively playing the tier in the highest levels of competition available) regularly differs from the opinion of the general public and the biggest example of this was in the Mega Latias vote, in which it got banned by a huge 73% majority despite the fact most top players were against the ban.
Being pro-Latias ban doesn't mean "we" consider you bad, in fact Manipulative was pro-ban and he got council after the vote, but after reading the NP thread and other UU areas it was pretty damn evident that most pro-ban voters had no idea of what they were talking about. I mean shit, in the thread we had people saying "if you don't prepare for Latias, it's likely you lose it" as a pro ban argument. This tiering decision was the last drop; we decided to start focusing on the highest level of UU play and balance the tier around that.
We decided to stop using a system that neglects top players and rewards free time. We have discussed about making public reqs
significantly harder, even if it means only having 7-10 voters qualifying that way, and let "top players" vote based on their merits, but finding a good balance and objective standards is important so this still is a WIP. Whenever we have a revamped system ready we'll start using it, but it's a complex subject that requires lots of discussion.
Council votes are also flawed, we know this, but they are much easier to closely monitor. This isn't PR friendly, nice or fair. We are doing what we think is the best for the tier.