Pain Split

[ZhengTann]

So after the Discussion here, it's time for the Council to convene and decide on the results that would best suit the ASB community. Part one of the slate as follows:

What should be done to the maximum HP difference for Pain Split?
No change (25 HP cap)
20 HP cap
15 HP cap

Tag time. Texas Cloverleaf / Dogfish44 / Frosty / Flamestrike / Engineer Pikachu / Gerard

 

[Engineer Pikachu]

probably not a particularly popular opinion but

No change

having been on both ends of it, I do agree it's a powerful attack but it's not overwhelming

 

[Frosty]

20 HP cap
No change (25 HP cap)
15 HP cap

 

[Gerard]

No change (25 HP cap)
20 HP cap
15 HP cap

 

[Flamestrike]

20 HP cap
No change (25 HP cap)
15 HP cap

 

[ZhengTann]

No change (25 HP cap)
20 HP cap

Actually, I'm agreeing with Engi and Gerard on this.

 

[Frosty]

Dogfish44
Texas Cloverleaf

 

[Texas Cloverleaf]

Honestly I was never really into this idea from the start, Pain Split has always been very strong but not really overwhelming and I'm happy with an EN adjustment for this, for now.

No Change

 

[Frosty]

Majority.

Slate 2:

What should be done to Pain Split's EN cost?
No change (6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/3)
6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/2.5
6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/2
6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/1.5

Texas Cloverleaf / Dogfish44 / Frosty / Flamestrike / Engineer Pikachu / Gerard / ZhengTann

 

[Dogfish44]

6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/2
6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/1.5
6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/2.5
No change (6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/3)

/2 leads to less awkward decimals slightly more often. And I think my stance on decimals is known fairly well -_-

 

[ZhengTann]

6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/2
6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/1.5

 

[Gerard]

I'm not too concerned about decimals and I like having the same numbers as protect.

6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/2.5
No change (6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/3)
6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/2
6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/1.5

 

[Flamestrike]

6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/2
6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/2.5
No change (6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/3)
6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/1.5

Interesting, I didn't realize so many people were against a cap change. Silent majority and all that I suppose.

 

[Frosty]

6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/2
6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/1.5
6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/2.5
No change (6+(|Opponent's HP - User's HP|)/3)


Majority.