LGPE get more hate than what it deserve, most of the complains i see are for the catching system but i think is a better chalange than what the other games have (in the regular games is only a challange when the mon has a low catch rate and can easly ko yours, most of the time you just spam balls), and is better looking than SWSH. Its biggest flaws are the starters being too overpowered (the special moves should come way later and most starters can solo their own games easly anyway) and the lack of abilities ruining most megas (what is even the point of Pinsir). They are fine as Yellow remakes and as a introduction for casuals.Man even for me that's harsh. I do think this is in contention with LGPE as the worst remakes in the series from what I've seen so far.
I do think BDSP may end as the worst in the series but thats because, well, most pokemon games are mostly the same (and thats fine, the pokemon formula works), BDSP dont really seems to be adding much or doing anything special to be different from the other 20 or something games, and as remakes they have to be directly compared to the originals and their third version, and we know something like 80% of the game is the same as DP, with the underground being the most interesting change so far, but i still have to play it, and maybe there are more changes that could turn these games into something other than -those games we got while waiting for legends-.