NOC Smalltown Mafia: Day 2

CaffeineBoost

Puzzle Hunt Champion
Vote: Bluedoom

My angle says he's scum. I think he's acting like he knows I'm town. Idk if it's a slip but it's susp.

Btw if we do lynch Bluedoom and he flips scum I am gonna table a formal request to have either protective role on me. SB. heuryalone note this down.
 
Initial thoughts: probably use all one shot abilities today, or doctor and bodyguard protect them d1. That leaves doctor vulnerable though. Im not a huge fan of using bodyguard to protect a role, because if bosyguard dies then you don't know if mafia targeted the bodyguard or the role the bodyguard was protecting.

I think deathstump is good candidate for pacifier. It's harder to get reads on someone that can hide behind their nonvotes. An alternative is by 48 hours of this day phase, everyone gives a nonofficial vote, and we use pacifier on that player.

Supersaint needs to be vigged or poisoned. I vote poison cuz I still want to see their vote and reads end of d1.

Reading caffeine as having a town mindset.

And....
Oh it’s vengeful but on killing vote

wow why did scum not choose this role?
scum read on apricity
 
Why did everyone pick the roles they did? I picked bodyguard cuz mafia would be less likely to nightkilled and often I get scum read when I play with people first time, so this way I can try to force death on myself rather than a more townie player.
 
So the issue with using the pacifier on hal is if he flips mafia, the day ends and the dayvig might be nk'd.Then we're stuck having to use the poisoner, and there are a lot of things that can go wrong here (poisoner,you in this case, could be mafia, scum!uto can block you and save hal,although i guess that's bad because that would reveal his alignment)
If we out hal as scum and the dayvig dies we can just leave him or force a scumread to hammer him (since apparently hammer does exist?), it’s not really a problem.

Mafia N1ing dayvig here is trolling because from a purely mechanical perspective there are only 3 roles worth protecting imo.

heuryalone Can you explain your scumread? I don't understand it.
 
heuryalone Can you explain your scumread? I don't understand it.
The statement just doesn't make sense. Obviously mafia picked their roles before they knew their alignment. The only motivation I see behind the statement is a forced distancing themself from the alignment of mafia. I just tend to scum read people that make subtle statements that say "Look at me, Im town!"

In response to duskfall, hi! New to smogon. Used to play some mafia an another forum that closed down. Im sure the meta is different here so wouldnt be surprised if I completely screw this game up :D
 

Duskfall98

Votecount Specialist
is a Forum Moderator
Moderator
We can't lynch hal if it's 3-2 because numbers go 2-1 -> 1-1 and we lose. The probability of hitting mafia goes roughly from 40% (2/5) normally to 25% (1/4). So I think we should just resolve this slot as soon as possible?
Yeah I thought it was a different supersaint at that point which is why I'm suggesting he gets pacified
 
Also role absorber should definitely be idling rn imo, it doesn't really help town to be stealing roles and creating confusion
if you insist
Vote: Bluedoom

My angle says he's scum. I think he's acting like he knows I'm town. Idk if it's a slip but it's susp.

Btw if we do lynch Bluedoom and he flips scum I am gonna table a formal request to have either protective role on me. SB. heuryalone note this down.
i cant disagree but at the same time i cant exactly see your reasoning

Why did everyone pick the roles they did? I picked bodyguard cuz mafia would be less likely to nightkilled and often I get scum read when I play with people first time, so this way I can try to force death on myself rather than a more townie player.
bg is just slightly worse doctor but i respect your thought process and reasoning

i picked absorber to basically tbag mafia whenever i take their roles

however i have been asked to idle today and im leaning toward compliance for the sake of the poisoners sanity :^)
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 2, Guests: 0)

Top